13.1 Parallel computing paradigms
4 min read•july 31, 2024
Parallel computing paradigms revolutionize mathematical applications by harnessing multiple processors. From shared-memory models with common memory space to distributed-memory models with message passing, these approaches offer diverse solutions for tackling complex computations efficiently.
and are powerful tools for implementing parallel algorithms. By understanding metrics, theoretical limits, and factors, we can optimize parallel code. Mathematical applications present numerous parallelization opportunities, from data and to domain decomposition techniques.
Shared-memory vs Distributed-memory models
Shared-memory model characteristics
Top images from around the web for Shared-memory model characteristics
Reading 23: Queues and Message-Passing View original
Is this image relevant?
Parallel Programming - HPC Wiki View original
Is this image relevant?
OpenMP - HPC Wiki View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading 23: Queues and Message-Passing View original
Is this image relevant?
Parallel Programming - HPC Wiki View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Shared-memory model characteristics
Reading 23: Queues and Message-Passing View original
Is this image relevant?
Parallel Programming - HPC Wiki View original
Is this image relevant?
OpenMP - HPC Wiki View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading 23: Queues and Message-Passing View original
Is this image relevant?
Parallel Programming - HPC Wiki View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Multiple processors access a shared memory space
- Processors communicate through shared variables in the common memory space
- Requires mechanisms to ensure data consistency and avoid when multiple processors access the same memory location simultaneously (locks, semaphores)
- Typically easier to program and has lower communication overhead compared to distributed-memory model
- May face scalability limitations due to memory contention and cache coherence issues
Distributed-memory model characteristics
- Each processor has its own local memory
- Processors communicate by exchanging messages over a network
- Requires explicit data partitioning and distribution among processors
- Requires communication and synchronization between processors to exchange data and coordinate computations
- Can scale to larger problem sizes and processor counts, as each processor has its own memory and can work independently
- Requires more complex programming and communication patterns compared to shared-memory model
Parallel algorithm implementation with OpenMP and MPI
OpenMP for shared-memory parallel programming
- API for shared-memory parallel programming in C, C++, and Fortran
- Allows parallelizing code using compiler directives, runtime library routines, and environment variables
- Supports parallel regions, where a block of code is executed by multiple threads in parallel
- Provides work-sharing constructs to distribute iterations or tasks among threads (parallel for, parallel sections)
- Offers synchronization constructs to coordinate access to shared data and ensure correctness in parallel execution (critical sections, atomic operations, barriers)
MPI for distributed-memory parallel programming
- Standard for distributed-memory parallel programming, defines a set of library routines for inter-process communication and synchronization
- Supports point-to-point communication between pairs of processes (send, receive)
- Provides collective communication among groups of processes (broadcast, scatter, gather)
- Allows creating parallel programs by launching multiple processes, each with its own memory space
- Coordinates process execution through message passing and synchronization primitives
Implementing parallel algorithms with OpenMP and MPI
- OpenMP implementation involves identifying parallelizable code regions, adding appropriate directives and clauses, and managing shared data and synchronization
- MPI implementation involves partitioning data and computations among processes, defining communication patterns and protocols, and managing message passing and synchronization between processes
Scalability and efficiency of parallel algorithms
Scalability metrics
- Scalability measures the ability of a parallel algorithm to achieve performance improvement as the problem size and the number of processors increase
- Strong scaling measures the achieved by increasing the number of processors for a fixed problem size
- Weak scaling measures the ability to maintain performance when both problem size and processor count increase proportionally
Theoretical limits on scalability
- Amdahl's law states that the speedup of a parallel algorithm is limited by the fraction of the code that cannot be parallelized (serial portion)
- Provides an upper bound on the maximum achievable speedup
- Gustafson's law suggests that for many practical problems, the serial portion of the code does not dominate the execution time
- Speedup can scale linearly with the number of processors if the problem size is increased proportionally
Efficiency of parallel algorithms
- Efficiency is defined as the ratio of speedup to the number of processors
- Measures how well the processors are utilized in the parallel execution
- is crucial for achieving good efficiency, ensures that the workload is evenly distributed among processors and minimizes idle time
- Communication overhead and synchronization costs can impact efficiency, especially in distributed-memory systems
- Should be minimized through careful design and optimization
Parallelization opportunities in mathematical applications
Types of parallelism in mathematical algorithms
- occurs when the same operation is applied to multiple data elements independently (vector and matrix operations)
- Can be exploited using techniques like parallel loops and vectorization
- Task parallelism arises when different operations or functions can be executed concurrently (divide-and-conquer algorithms, graph algorithms, numerical optimization methods)
- Pipeline parallelism can be employed when a sequence of operations is applied to a stream of data, allowing multiple stages of the pipeline to execute simultaneously on different data elements
Identifying parallelization opportunities
- Analyze dependencies and data flow in the algorithm
- Determine the granularity and scope of parallel tasks
- Many mathematical algorithms exhibit inherent parallelism, where multiple independent computations can be performed simultaneously (matrix operations, Monte Carlo simulations, finite element methods)
Techniques and tools for parallelization
- Domain decomposition techniques partition the problem domain into subdomains that can be processed in parallel (finite difference methods, particle simulations)
- Parallel linear algebra libraries can be leveraged to exploit parallelism in common mathematical operations and algorithms (ScaLAPACK, PETSc)
- Parallel frameworks provide high-level abstractions for parallel programming in mathematical applications (TensorFlow, PyTorch)
Key Terms to Review (18)
Concurrency: Concurrency is the ability of a system to manage multiple tasks simultaneously, allowing for overlapping execution. This concept is crucial in computer science, as it enables efficient resource utilization and improved performance by enabling processes to run independently and interact with each other. Concurrency can be achieved through various means, including multithreading and asynchronous programming, and plays a key role in enhancing the responsiveness of applications.
Data parallelism: Data parallelism is a computing paradigm that involves distributing data across multiple processing elements and performing the same operation on each element simultaneously. This approach leverages the power of parallel computing by allowing large datasets to be processed more efficiently, which is especially useful in tasks like numerical simulations, image processing, and machine learning. By breaking down data into smaller chunks and applying operations in parallel, systems can achieve significant performance improvements over traditional serial processing methods.
David Patterson: David Patterson is a prominent computer scientist known for his work in computer architecture and parallel computing. His contributions, particularly in developing the RISC (Reduced Instruction Set Computer) architecture, have greatly influenced modern computing. He has also focused on parallel computing paradigms, which play a critical role in improving processing efficiency and performance in various computing systems.
Deadlock: Deadlock is a situation in computing where two or more processes cannot proceed because each is waiting for the other to release resources. This creates a standstill, as the involved processes are effectively blocked and unable to continue their operations. Understanding deadlock is crucial in parallel computing as it impacts resource allocation, process synchronization, and overall system performance.
Distributed memory model: The distributed memory model is a parallel computing architecture where each processor has its own private memory. Processors communicate with each other through a network, sharing data and information only when needed, which allows for scalability and independence among processors. This model contrasts with shared memory systems, where multiple processors access a common memory space, making it essential for efficient data processing in large-scale applications.
Divide and Conquer: Divide and conquer is a problem-solving strategy that breaks a complex problem into smaller, more manageable subproblems, solves each subproblem independently, and then combines their solutions to address the original problem. This approach is particularly effective in optimizing efficiency and improving performance across various computational tasks.
Efficiency: Efficiency refers to the ability to achieve a desired outcome with minimal wasted resources, time, or effort. In computational contexts, it is crucial as it impacts performance, resource allocation, and overall effectiveness of algorithms and processes. Striving for efficiency can lead to faster computations, reduced costs, and improved scalability in both numerical methods and computing architectures.
John L. Hennessy: John L. Hennessy is a renowned computer scientist and co-author of the influential textbook 'Computer Architecture: A Quantitative Approach.' His work has significantly shaped modern computer architecture, particularly in the context of parallel computing paradigms, emphasizing efficiency and performance optimization in processors.
Load Balancing: Load balancing is the process of distributing workloads across multiple computing resources to optimize resource use, maximize throughput, reduce latency, and ensure reliability. This technique helps to maintain a balanced workload across servers or processors, which is essential for improving performance and minimizing the risk of overload on any single resource. It plays a vital role in enhancing efficiency and responsiveness in various computational scenarios.
Map-reduce: Map-reduce is a programming model and an associated implementation for processing and generating large data sets that can be parallelized across a distributed cluster of computers. It breaks down tasks into smaller sub-tasks (map), processes these in parallel, and then combines the results (reduce) to produce a final output. This approach allows for efficient data handling, enabling applications to scale across multiple servers.
MPI: MPI, or Message Passing Interface, is a standardized and portable message-passing system designed to allow processes to communicate with one another in a parallel computing environment. This allows for the efficient execution of parallel algorithms across multiple processors, enabling the scalability of applications. By facilitating communication between processes, MPI plays a crucial role in various parallel computing paradigms and performance optimization techniques.
OpenMP: OpenMP is an application programming interface (API) that supports multi-platform shared memory multiprocessing programming in C, C++, and Fortran. It allows developers to write parallel code easily using compiler directives, enabling programs to run faster by leveraging multiple processors. OpenMP is particularly relevant in the context of parallel computing paradigms and performance optimization techniques, as it provides a way to simplify the development of concurrent applications while improving computational efficiency.
Race Conditions: Race conditions occur in computing when two or more processes access shared data and attempt to change it simultaneously, leading to unpredictable outcomes. This situation is particularly critical in parallel computing paradigms where multiple threads or processes operate concurrently. If not managed properly, race conditions can result in data corruption, unexpected behavior, or crashes, making understanding and addressing them essential for developing reliable software systems.
Scalability: Scalability refers to the ability of a system to handle a growing amount of work or its potential to accommodate growth. It’s essential for ensuring that applications can efficiently manage increasing workloads without compromising performance. This concept connects to how systems are designed, implemented, and optimized for parallel tasks, distributed algorithms, and improving performance, enabling them to expand effectively as demands increase.
Shared memory model: The shared memory model is a parallel computing paradigm where multiple processes or threads can access a common memory space to read and write data. This model allows for efficient communication and data sharing among processes, as they can operate on the same data without needing to explicitly send messages to each other. It facilitates fast data exchanges, enabling higher performance in applications that require concurrent execution.
Speedup: Speedup is a measure of the efficiency gained by using multiple processors or cores in parallel computing, comparing the time it takes to complete a task on a single processor to the time it takes on multiple processors. It highlights how much faster a computational task can be performed when using parallel resources, thereby optimizing performance. Understanding speedup helps assess the effectiveness of different parallel computing paradigms in achieving faster execution times for complex problems.
Synchronization: Synchronization refers to the coordination of multiple processes or threads in a computing environment to ensure that they operate in a predictable and orderly manner. This concept is essential for avoiding conflicts when multiple tasks are accessing shared resources, thereby preventing issues such as data corruption or race conditions. In the context of parallel computing and GPU computing, synchronization ensures that computations occur in the correct sequence and that data integrity is maintained across different processing units.
Task parallelism: Task parallelism is a computing paradigm where multiple tasks are executed concurrently, allowing for efficient use of resources and faster execution of programs. This approach focuses on dividing a program into independent tasks that can be run simultaneously on different processors or cores, maximizing throughput and reducing overall execution time. It is distinct from data parallelism, which involves performing the same operation on different pieces of data at the same time.