1.2 Policing models and philosophies
2 min read•august 9, 2024
Policing models shape how officers interact with communities. Traditional approaches focus on reactive crime control, while community-oriented strategies emphasize collaboration and problem-solving. These models reflect evolving philosophies about the role of law enforcement in society.
Problem-oriented and use data to target specific issues and guide decision-making. Meanwhile, theories like broken windows and influence how officers approach their work and engage with the public. Understanding these models is key to grasping modern policing.
Policing Models
Traditional and Community-Oriented Approaches
Top images from around the web for Traditional and Community-Oriented Approaches
Course Learning Objectives - Community Policing · Criminology Open View original
Is this image relevant?
Infographics: the 4 pillars of community policing — EUAM Ukraine View original
Is this image relevant?
National Rollout of Community Policing Programme — EUAM Ukraine View original
Is this image relevant?
Course Learning Objectives - Community Policing · Criminology Open View original
Is this image relevant?
Infographics: the 4 pillars of community policing — EUAM Ukraine View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Traditional and Community-Oriented Approaches
Course Learning Objectives - Community Policing · Criminology Open View original
Is this image relevant?
Infographics: the 4 pillars of community policing — EUAM Ukraine View original
Is this image relevant?
National Rollout of Community Policing Programme — EUAM Ukraine View original
Is this image relevant?
Course Learning Objectives - Community Policing · Criminology Open View original
Is this image relevant?
Infographics: the 4 pillars of community policing — EUAM Ukraine View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Traditional policing focuses on reactive law enforcement and crime control
- Emphasizes rapid response to calls for service
- Relies heavily on motorized patrol and arrests
- Measures success through crime statistics and clearance rates
- promotes collaboration between police and citizens
- Encourages and crime prevention
- Involves community members in identifying local issues (neighborhood watch programs)
- Fosters positive relationships through foot patrols and community meetings
- Aims to increase public trust and
Problem-Oriented and Intelligence-Led Strategies
- targets specific crime issues systematically
- Utilizes the : Scanning, Analysis, Response, Assessment
- Identifies underlying causes of recurring problems (repeat offenders, crime hot spots)
- Develops tailored solutions involving multiple stakeholders
- Evaluates effectiveness of interventions and adjusts strategies accordingly
- Intelligence-led policing leverages data analysis for strategic decision-making
- Employs and to allocate resources efficiently
- Focuses on prolific offenders and high-risk locations
- Integrates information from various sources (crime reports, informants, surveillance)
- Guides tactical operations and long-term planning based on intelligence assessments
Policing Philosophies and Theories
Environmental and Enforcement-Based Approaches
- links disorder to serious crime
- Posits that visible signs of neglect (broken windows, graffiti) invite criminal activity
- Advocates for addressing minor infractions to prevent escalation
- Influences strategies
- Critics argue it may lead to over-policing of disadvantaged communities
- aggressively enforces all laws, even minor offenses
- Aims to deter crime by creating an atmosphere of strict law enforcement
- Often associated with "quality of life" initiatives in urban areas
- Can result in increased arrests and citations for low-level violations
- Controversial due to potential for discriminatory application and community tensions
Justice-Oriented and Evidence-Based Strategies
- Procedural justice emphasizes fair treatment in police-citizen interactions
- Focuses on four key elements: voice, neutrality, respect, and trustworthiness
- Aims to enhance police legitimacy and public cooperation
- Encourages officers to explain their actions and listen to community concerns
- Can lead to improved compliance with the law and reduced complaints against police
- applies scientific research to inform police practices
- Relies on rigorous studies to identify effective strategies (randomized controlled trials)
- Encourages continuous evaluation and improvement of policing methods
- Promotes the use of data analysis to guide resource allocation and policy decisions
- Challenges traditional assumptions about "what works" in law enforcement
Key Terms to Review (20)
Accountability: Accountability refers to the obligation of individuals and organizations to report on their activities, accept responsibility for them, and disclose the results in a transparent manner. In policing, accountability encompasses the mechanisms and processes that ensure law enforcement agencies operate in accordance with the law and ethical standards, fostering public trust and integrity.
Broken windows theory: Broken windows theory is a criminological concept that suggests visible signs of disorder and neglect in a neighborhood, such as broken windows or graffiti, can lead to an increase in crime. The theory posits that maintaining and monitoring urban environments can prevent small crimes from escalating into larger ones, emphasizing the importance of order maintenance in policing.
Collaborative Policing: Collaborative policing is a strategy that emphasizes partnerships and cooperation between law enforcement agencies, community members, and various stakeholders to enhance public safety and address crime effectively. This approach fosters communication and collaboration to identify and solve community problems, shifting the focus from traditional policing methods to a more community-oriented framework that involves shared responsibility for crime prevention and resolution.
Collective Efficacy: Collective efficacy refers to the shared belief among a group of individuals in their ability to work together to achieve common goals, particularly in the context of social cohesion and mutual support. It highlights how communities can come together to exert social control and influence behaviors, which is crucial for crime prevention and fostering a safe environment. This concept underpins various policing models and community-based approaches, emphasizing the importance of collaboration between law enforcement and the communities they serve.
Community policing: Community policing is a proactive strategy that emphasizes building partnerships between police officers and community members to identify and solve problems related to crime and social disorder. This approach seeks to enhance the quality of life in neighborhoods by fostering trust and collaboration, while also focusing on crime prevention rather than just enforcement.
Crime Mapping: Crime mapping is the process of using geographic information systems (GIS) to visualize, analyze, and interpret crime data in a spatial context. This technique helps law enforcement agencies identify crime patterns, allocate resources effectively, and improve community safety through informed decision-making.
Evidence-based policing: Evidence-based policing is a practice that emphasizes the use of research and empirical data to inform and guide police decision-making, strategies, and policies. This approach aims to enhance the effectiveness of law enforcement by applying findings from rigorous studies to real-world policing issues, leading to improved public safety outcomes and more efficient resource allocation.
Intelligence-led policing: Intelligence-led policing is a strategic approach to law enforcement that focuses on the collection, analysis, and application of intelligence to guide police operations and decision-making. This method emphasizes proactive crime prevention and targeted resource allocation based on data-driven insights, ultimately aiming to improve public safety and enhance the effectiveness of police work.
Order Maintenance Policing: Order maintenance policing refers to a proactive policing strategy focused on maintaining public order and preventing minor offenses to avoid more serious crimes. This approach emphasizes the importance of community involvement and problem-solving to address underlying issues that contribute to disorder. By targeting quality-of-life offenses such as vandalism and loitering, order maintenance policing aims to create a safe environment and foster community trust in law enforcement.
Performance Metrics: Performance metrics are quantifiable measures used to evaluate the efficiency, effectiveness, and success of various policing activities and strategies. They serve as a tool for assessing how well police organizations meet their goals and objectives, guiding decision-making and resource allocation. By using these metrics, law enforcement agencies can analyze performance, identify areas for improvement, and enhance community relations through transparent reporting.
Police Legitimacy: Police legitimacy refers to the belief that the actions and authority of the police are justified and appropriate, leading to public support and cooperation. This concept is essential for effective policing, as it influences the relationship between law enforcement and the communities they serve, impacting everything from policing strategies to community trust.
Predictive analytics: Predictive analytics is the use of statistical techniques, algorithms, and machine learning to analyze historical data and forecast future outcomes. By identifying patterns and trends in large datasets, this approach helps law enforcement agencies anticipate potential criminal activity, optimize resource allocation, and improve community safety. The growing reliance on technology and data-driven decision-making has made predictive analytics an essential tool in modern policing strategies and innovations.
Proactive Problem-Solving: Proactive problem-solving is a strategic approach in policing that emphasizes identifying and addressing potential issues before they escalate into significant problems. This method encourages law enforcement to engage with communities, analyze data, and implement preventive measures that foster collaboration and enhance public safety. By focusing on root causes and fostering partnerships, proactive problem-solving seeks to create lasting solutions rather than simply reacting to incidents as they occur.
Problem-oriented policing: Problem-oriented policing is a proactive approach that focuses on identifying and addressing specific crime and disorder problems within a community, rather than merely responding to incidents as they occur. This strategy involves analyzing the underlying issues contributing to crime and working collaboratively with community members and other stakeholders to develop effective solutions, thus enhancing public safety and community well-being.
Procedural Justice: Procedural justice refers to the fairness of the processes that resolve disputes and allocate resources. It emphasizes the importance of transparency, impartiality, and equitable treatment in decision-making processes, especially within law enforcement. This concept is crucial for establishing legitimacy and trust between police and communities, influencing various aspects of policing models, accountability, community relations, and reform initiatives.
Quality of Life Initiatives: Quality of life initiatives refer to programs and strategies implemented by law enforcement agencies aimed at improving the overall living conditions and well-being of community members. These initiatives often focus on addressing issues like crime, disorder, public health, and environmental concerns, fostering a safer and more vibrant community. They are rooted in the belief that policing should not only enforce laws but also enhance the quality of life for all residents.
SARA Model: The SARA model stands for Scanning, Analysis, Response, and Assessment, and is a problem-solving framework used in policing to address community issues. It emphasizes a systematic approach to identifying problems, understanding their causes, implementing solutions, and evaluating their effectiveness. This model is key in enhancing community engagement and collaboration between law enforcement and the public, making it vital for effective policing strategies.
Social Capital: Social capital refers to the networks, relationships, and trust that exist within a community, which enable individuals to work together effectively for mutual benefit. This concept is crucial in understanding how communities interact with law enforcement and contribute to policing models, as strong social ties can lead to increased cooperation between the police and the public, fostering safer neighborhoods and a more responsive justice system.
Transparency: Transparency in policing refers to the openness and accessibility of police operations, policies, and decision-making processes to the public. It is essential for building trust between law enforcement agencies and communities, fostering accountability, and enhancing the legitimacy of police actions.
Zero-tolerance policing: Zero-tolerance policing is a law enforcement strategy that enforces strict punishment for minor offenses to deter more serious crimes. This approach focuses on maintaining order and reducing crime by emphasizing enforcement of all laws, regardless of their severity, under the belief that even small infractions can lead to larger issues if left unchecked. It aims to create a strong deterrent effect, promoting a sense of safety and community compliance with the law.