11.1 End-Ordovician extinction

The end-Ordovician extinction, occurring 445 million years ago, was a devastating event that wiped out 85% of marine species. Global cooling, sea level drop, and ocean anoxia were key factors in this mass extinction, reshaping marine ecosystems and biodiversity patterns.

This extinction event had far-reaching consequences, causing reef collapse, faunal turnover, and ecosystem restructuring. Geochemical evidence provides insights into the environmental conditions, while the evolutionary aftermath set the stage for future marine life diversity throughout the Paleozoic era.

Causes of end-Ordovician extinction

• The end-Ordovician extinction, occurring approximately 445 million years ago, was one of the five major mass extinctions in Earth's history
• Multiple factors likely contributed to this devastating loss of marine biodiversity, with an estimated 85% of species going extinct during this event

Glaciation and sea level drop

Top images from around the web for Glaciation and sea level drop

• 

  Charting Earth’s (Many) Mass Extinctions — Blog of the Long Now View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Laurasia-Gondwana.png View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Exception Extinction View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charting Earth’s (Many) Mass Extinctions — Blog of the Long Now View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Laurasia-Gondwana.png View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Glaciation and sea level drop

• 

  Charting Earth’s (Many) Mass Extinctions — Blog of the Long Now View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Laurasia-Gondwana.png View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  The Exception Extinction View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Charting Earth’s (Many) Mass Extinctions — Blog of the Long Now View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  File:Laurasia-Gondwana.png View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Global cooling during the Late Ordovician led to the formation of extensive ice sheets on the supercontinent Gondwana
• Glaciation caused a significant drop in sea level (estimated at 50-100 meters), reducing the extent of shallow marine habitats
• Habitat loss due to sea level fall likely contributed to the extinction of many marine species, particularly those adapted to shallow water environments
• Cooling temperatures also altered ocean circulation patterns and nutrient cycling, further stressing marine ecosystems

Ocean anoxia and euxinia

• Widespread anoxia (oxygen depletion) and euxinia (sulfidic conditions) developed in the oceans during the Late Ordovician
• Anoxic conditions were likely triggered by a combination of factors, including reduced ocean mixing, increased nutrient input, and enhanced organic matter burial
• Many marine organisms, particularly those with limited mobility or high oxygen requirements, would have been unable to survive in oxygen-depleted waters
• Euxinic conditions, characterized by the presence of toxic hydrogen sulfide, would have further contributed to the extinction of marine life

Metal poisoning from volcanism

• Extensive volcanic activity during the Late Ordovician, potentially linked to the formation of the Appalachian Mountains, may have released large amounts of toxic metals into the oceans
• Metals such as mercury, lead, and cadmium can accumulate in marine organisms and disrupt physiological processes, leading to increased mortality
• Volcanic emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases could have also contributed to global warming and ocean acidification, further stressing marine ecosystems

Gamma-ray burst hypothesis

• Some researchers have proposed that a nearby gamma-ray burst (an extremely energetic cosmic event) could have played a role in the end-Ordovician extinction
• Gamma-ray bursts can deplete atmospheric ozone, exposing the Earth's surface to increased UV radiation and potentially triggering global cooling
• While intriguing, the gamma-ray burst hypothesis remains speculative and requires further evidence to confirm its role in the extinction event

Timing and duration of extinction

• The end-Ordovician extinction is characterized by its prolonged duration and complex temporal pattern, with multiple phases of species loss occurring over several million years

Two distinct pulses

• Detailed studies of fossil records and geochemical proxies have revealed two main pulses of extinction during the Late Ordovician
• The first pulse occurred during the Hirnantian Stage (445.2-443.8 Ma), coinciding with the onset of major glaciation and sea level fall
• The second pulse took place during the early Silurian Rhuddanian Stage (443.8-440.8 Ma), potentially linked to the post-glacial transgression and ocean anoxia

Relationship to glaciation cycles

• The timing and severity of the extinction pulses appear to be closely tied to the waxing and waning of Gondwanan ice sheets
• The first extinction pulse coincided with the rapid growth of ice sheets and the associated sea level drop, suggesting a direct link between glaciation and species loss
• The second pulse occurred during the post-glacial transgression, possibly due to the expansion of anoxic waters and the disruption of marine habitats

Graptolite and conodont extinctions

• Graptolites and conodonts, two groups of marine organisms commonly used as biostratigraphic markers, experienced significant extinctions during the Late Ordovician
• The extinction of graptolites, colonial marine animals, was particularly severe, with an estimated 95% of species lost
• Conodonts, small jawless vertebrates, also suffered major losses, with many lineages disappearing and others undergoing rapid evolutionary turnover
• The differential timing of graptolite and conodont extinctions provides insights into the complex and prolonged nature of the end-Ordovician event

Ecological impact of extinction

• The end-Ordovician extinction had far-reaching consequences for marine ecosystems, reshaping community structure, trophic relationships, and evolutionary trajectories

Marine invertebrate diversity loss

• The extinction event decimated marine invertebrate diversity, with an estimated 85% of species and 60% of genera going extinct
• Major groups affected included brachiopods, trilobites, bryozoans, corals, and echinoderms, among others
• The loss of diversity was not uniform across different taxonomic groups or geographic regions, with some clades and areas experiencing higher extinction rates than others

Reef collapse and recovery

• Reef ecosystems, which had become increasingly complex and diverse during the Ordovician, suffered a major collapse during the extinction event
• Many reef-building organisms, such as corals and stromatoporoids, went extinct or experienced significant declines
• The collapse of reef ecosystems likely had cascading effects on associated marine communities, reducing habitat complexity and altering nutrient cycling
• Reef recovery was slow and gradual, with new reef-building organisms (such as tabulate corals and sponges) emerging during the Silurian

Ordovician-Silurian faunal turnover

• The end-Ordovician extinction marked a major faunal turnover, with the disappearance of many characteristic Ordovician taxa and the rise of new Silurian faunas
• Groups that had dominated Ordovician marine communities, such as trilobites and brachiopods, experienced significant declines and were replaced by other taxa (e.g., mollusks and echinoderms)
• The faunal turnover reflects not only the selective nature of the extinction event but also the subsequent evolutionary radiation and ecological restructuring

Ecosystem restructuring and recovery

• The loss of key species and the collapse of certain ecosystem engineers (such as reefs) led to a major restructuring of marine ecosystems in the aftermath of the extinction
• Trophic relationships and energy flow patterns were likely altered, with the disappearance of some primary consumers and the rise of opportunistic taxa
• Recovery of marine ecosystems was a gradual process, spanning millions of years and involving the evolution of new species and the re-establishment of complex ecological networks
• The pace and pattern of ecosystem recovery varied across different regions and environmental settings, reflecting local factors such as nutrient availability and substrate type

Geochemical evidence for extinction

• Geochemical proxies preserved in sedimentary rocks provide valuable insights into the environmental conditions and processes associated with the end-Ordovician extinction

Carbon and oxygen isotope excursions

• Stable isotope records of carbon (δ13C) and oxygen (δ18O) from marine carbonates show significant excursions during the Late Ordovician
• Positive δ13C excursions, indicative of increased organic carbon burial, are observed during the Hirnantian glaciation and the early Silurian
• These excursions suggest major perturbations in the global carbon cycle, potentially linked to changes in ocean circulation, productivity, and weathering rates
• Oxygen isotope records (δ18O) provide evidence for global cooling and glaciation, with positive excursions reflecting the growth of ice sheets and the associated sea level fall

Sulfur isotope evidence for anoxia

• Sulfur isotope ratios (δ34S) in marine sediments can be used to infer the extent of ocean anoxia and euxinia during the end-Ordovician extinction
• Large positive δ34S excursions have been documented in Late Ordovician and early Silurian sediments, suggesting widespread sulfate reduction under anoxic conditions
• The development of anoxic and euxinic waters would have been detrimental to many marine organisms, contributing to the extinction event

Trace metal signatures of volcanism

• Elevated concentrations of trace metals, such as mercury (Hg), in Late Ordovician sediments have been interpreted as evidence for increased volcanic activity
• Volcanic emissions can release large amounts of toxic metals into the atmosphere and oceans, potentially contributing to the extinction of marine life
• The coincidence of trace metal enrichments with the extinction intervals suggests a possible causal link between volcanism and species loss

Sedimentary indicators of glaciation

• Sedimentological and stratigraphic evidence, such as the presence of glacial deposits (tillites) and erosional surfaces, provides direct evidence for Late Ordovician glaciation
• Glacial deposits are found in many Late Ordovician successions, particularly in regions that were part of the Gondwanan supercontinent
• Glacioeustatic sea-level changes, inferred from sequence stratigraphic analysis, support the occurrence of major glaciation events during the Late Ordovician
• The temporal relationship between glacial deposits, sea-level changes, and extinction intervals suggests a strong link between glaciation and the end-Ordovician biotic crisis

Evolutionary consequences of extinction

• The end-Ordovician extinction had profound evolutionary consequences, shaping the subsequent diversification and ecological structure of marine faunas

Preferential loss of endemic species

• The extinction event appears to have disproportionately affected endemic species, those with restricted geographic ranges and specialized ecological requirements
• Endemic taxa, often adapted to specific local conditions, were more vulnerable to environmental changes and habitat loss than widespread, generalist species
• The preferential loss of endemic species likely homogenized marine faunas and reduced regional diversity patterns

Survival of cosmopolitan genera

• In contrast to endemic taxa, cosmopolitan genera (those with wide geographic distributions) were more likely to survive the end-Ordovician extinction
• The survival of cosmopolitan genera may reflect their greater ecological flexibility, dispersal abilities, and resilience to environmental perturbations
• The differential survival of cosmopolitan vs. endemic taxa likely influenced the post-extinction evolutionary trajectories and biogeographic patterns

Reduction in average species duration

• The end-Ordovician extinction resulted in a significant reduction in the average duration of marine invertebrate species
• Many long-lived species, which had persisted for millions of years during the Ordovician, disappeared during the extinction event
• The selective loss of long-lived species and the subsequent dominance of shorter-lived taxa may have altered the pace and dynamics of evolutionary turnover in the aftermath of the extinction

Accelerated post-extinction diversification

• Following the end-Ordovician extinction, marine faunas underwent a rapid evolutionary diversification during the Silurian period
• The post-extinction diversification was characterized by the emergence of new clades, morphological innovations, and the exploration of novel ecological niches
• The accelerated pace of diversification may have been facilitated by the vacated ecospace and the reduced competition in the aftermath of the extinction
• The post-extinction diversification set the stage for the subsequent evolution and ecological structure of marine communities throughout the Paleozoic era

Comparison to other mass extinctions

• The end-Ordovician extinction shares some similarities with other major mass extinctions in Earth's history, but also exhibits unique features and consequences

Similarities vs differences in triggers

• Like other mass extinctions, the end-Ordovician event appears to have been triggered by a combination of abiotic factors, such as climate change, sea-level fluctuations, and ocean chemistry perturbations
• However, the specific role of glaciation as a primary driver sets the end-Ordovician extinction apart from other mass extinctions, which were often associated with global warming and ocean acidification (e.g., end-Permian, end-Triassic)
• The prolonged duration and multi-phase nature of the end-Ordovician extinction also distinguishes it from more abrupt events, such as the end-Cretaceous extinction

Extinction selectivity patterns

• The end-Ordovician extinction exhibited selective patterns in terms of the taxonomic groups and ecological guilds that were most affected
• Marine invertebrates, particularly those associated with shallow water habitats and carbonate platforms (e.g., brachiopods, bryozoans, corals), experienced the highest extinction rates
• The selectivity patterns of the end-Ordovician extinction differ from other mass extinctions, which often had more severe impacts on other groups (e.g., terrestrial vertebrates in the end-Cretaceous extinction)

Ecological vs evolutionary impacts

• The ecological consequences of the end-Ordovician extinction, such as the collapse of reef ecosystems and the restructuring of marine communities, are broadly similar to those observed in other mass extinctions
• However, the evolutionary impacts of the end-Ordovician event, such as the preferential loss of endemic species and the accelerated post-extinction diversification, may have been more pronounced compared to some other mass extinctions
• The long-term evolutionary consequences of the end-Ordovician extinction, including the rise of new dominant clades and the reshaping of marine biodiversity patterns, underscore its significance in the history of life

Recovery rates and ecosystem resilience

• The recovery of marine ecosystems following the end-Ordovician extinction was generally slower and more gradual compared to some other mass extinctions (e.g., the rapid recovery after the end-Cretaceous extinction)
• The prolonged recovery may reflect the severity and duration of the extinction event, as well as the time required for the re-establishment of complex ecological networks and the evolution of new taxa to fill vacant niches
• The differential recovery rates across taxonomic groups and geographic regions highlight the variable resilience of marine ecosystems to major perturbations
• Studying the recovery patterns and processes following the end-Ordovician extinction can provide insights into the factors that influence ecosystem resilience and the long-term consequences of biodiversity loss