5.1 Theories of Musical Emotion
3 min read•august 9, 2024
Music stirs up feelings in us, but how exactly does that happen? Scientists have come up with some cool ideas to explain it. They look at things like what we expect to hear and how the music moves up and down.
One theory says our emotions come from imagining what's next in a song. Another thinks our brains build emotions by mixing body feelings with thoughts. These ideas help us understand why different tunes make us feel happy, sad, or pumped up.
Cognitive Theories of Musical Emotion
ITPRA and Conceptual Act Theories
Top images from around the web for ITPRA and Conceptual Act Theories
Frontiers | Emotions and Instructed Language Learning: Proposing a Second Language Emotions and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Assessments of Acoustic Environments by Emotions – The Application of Emotion Theory ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Regulation of Emotions to Optimize Classical Music Performance: A Quasi-Experimental ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Emotions and Instructed Language Learning: Proposing a Second Language Emotions and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Assessments of Acoustic Environments by Emotions – The Application of Emotion Theory ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for ITPRA and Conceptual Act Theories
Frontiers | Emotions and Instructed Language Learning: Proposing a Second Language Emotions and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Assessments of Acoustic Environments by Emotions – The Application of Emotion Theory ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Regulation of Emotions to Optimize Classical Music Performance: A Quasi-Experimental ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Emotions and Instructed Language Learning: Proposing a Second Language Emotions and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Assessments of Acoustic Environments by Emotions – The Application of Emotion Theory ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- explains emotional responses to music through five components: Imagination, Tension, Prediction, Reaction, and Appraisal
- Imagination involves anticipating future events in music
- Tension arises from uncertainty about upcoming musical elements
- Prediction occurs when listeners form expectations about musical progression
- Reaction happens as immediate response to musical events
- Appraisal involves evaluating the significance of musical experiences
- posits emotions as constructed experiences rather than innate responses
- Combines physiological sensations with cognitive interpretations
- Emphasizes the role of context and prior knowledge in shaping emotional responses to music
- Suggests emotions are actively created through mental categorization processes
Expectancy and Contour Theories
- focuses on how musical expectations influence emotional responses
- Listeners develop expectations based on musical patterns and cultural norms
- Violations or confirmations of these expectations generate emotional reactions
- Unexpected harmonies or rhythms can evoke surprise or tension
- Familiar chord progressions often elicit feelings of satisfaction or comfort
- proposes that emotional responses to music mirror the contours of physical gestures
- Rising melodic lines may evoke feelings of excitement or anticipation
- Descending melodies might induce calmness or
- Staccato rhythms can generate energetic or agitated emotions
- Legato phrases often elicit smooth or flowing emotional states
Prototype Theory in Musical Emotion
- suggests emotions are categorized based on their similarity to prototypical examples
- Applies concept of cognitive prototypes to emotional responses in music
- Listeners compare musical experiences to prototypical emotional categories
- Helps explain why certain musical features consistently evoke specific emotions across cultures
- Accounts for individual differences in emotional responses based on personal prototypes
- Prototypical musical features for emotions include:
- : fast tempo, major key, consonant harmonies
- Sadness: slow tempo, minor key, descending melodies
- Anger: loud dynamics, dissonant harmonies, rhythmic intensity
- Fear: irregular rhythms, sudden changes in dynamics or pitch
Dimensional Models of Musical Emotion
Arousal-Valence Model
- represents emotions along two primary dimensions
- Arousal axis ranges from low (calm) to high (excited)
- Valence axis spans from negative (unpleasant) to positive (pleasant)
- Allows for mapping of complex emotional states in a two-dimensional space
- Joy: high arousal, positive valence
- Sadness: low arousal, negative valence
- Anger: high arousal, negative valence
- Contentment: low arousal, positive valence
- Provides a framework for understanding how musical features influence emotional responses
- Tempo and rhythm primarily affect arousal levels
- Harmony and mode predominantly influence valence
- Facilitates research on emotional transitions in music as compositions move through different quadrants of the model
Mood Congruence Theory and Applications
- proposes that individuals tend to process information congruent with their current emotional state
- Applies to musical preferences and emotional responses to music
- Listeners often seek out music that matches their current mood
- Can explain why sad people sometimes prefer melancholic music
- Implications for music therapy and mood regulation
- Gradual mood shifts can be achieved by starting with mood-congruent music and slowly transitioning to desired emotional states
- Helps in designing effective playlists for or therapeutic purposes
- Interactions with the Arousal-Valence Model
- Mood congruence can be mapped onto specific regions of the arousal-valence space
- Allows for predictions about which types of music will be most effective for different emotional states
- Helps explain individual variations in emotional responses to the same piece of music
Key Terms to Review (26)
Aesthetic Experience: Aesthetic experience refers to a profound emotional and cognitive engagement that individuals have when encountering art, music, or other forms of creative expression. This experience often leads to feelings of pleasure, beauty, and connection, as well as introspection and self-discovery. Aesthetic experiences can significantly influence emotional responses to music and are linked to the physiological and neurological processes that underlie musical emotions.
Affective response theory: Affective response theory posits that individuals experience emotional reactions to music that are shaped by their personal, cultural, and contextual backgrounds. This theory emphasizes the role of feelings and emotions in the perception and enjoyment of music, suggesting that these responses can vary widely among listeners based on factors like mood, memories, and cultural associations.
Arousal-valence model: The arousal-valence model is a framework used to describe and categorize emotional responses, focusing on two key dimensions: arousal, which refers to the level of alertness or activation, and valence, which indicates the intrinsic attractiveness or averseness of an emotion. This model helps in understanding how different musical elements can evoke varying emotional states, highlighting the complexity of musical emotion and its psychological impact.
Autonomic arousal: Autonomic arousal refers to the physiological responses that occur automatically and involuntarily in reaction to emotional stimuli, such as increased heart rate, sweating, and changes in respiration. This concept is crucial in understanding how music can evoke emotional responses by triggering these bodily reactions, thereby linking physiological experiences to emotional states associated with musical engagement.
Cognitive Appraisal Theory: Cognitive appraisal theory explains how individuals assess and interpret emotional experiences, which significantly influences their emotional responses. This theory posits that the meaning one assigns to a stimulus, like music, shapes how they feel and react to it. By understanding this process, we can see how emotions related to music can be influenced by personal experiences, cultural background, and situational contexts.
Cognitive Perspective: The cognitive perspective is an approach in psychology that focuses on the mental processes involved in perception, memory, thought, and problem-solving. This viewpoint emphasizes how individuals process information and how these cognitive processes influence behavior, including the interpretation and emotional response to music. By examining mental activities, researchers can better understand aspects like auditory processing, emotional responses to music, and even how musical preferences can reflect personality traits.
Conceptual Act Theory: Conceptual Act Theory is a psychological framework that suggests emotions are not innate, but rather constructed through the interplay of perception, concepts, and context. This theory emphasizes that our emotional experiences arise from how we interpret stimuli based on prior knowledge and situational factors, making emotions more about the cognitive processing of experiences rather than simply physiological responses.
Contour Theory: Contour Theory posits that the emotional response to music is primarily driven by the shape and direction of melodic lines, rather than specific notes or harmonic structures. This theory suggests that listeners perceive emotions in music based on the overall contour, which includes rising and falling patterns that convey different emotional states.
David Huron: David Huron is a prominent music psychologist known for his extensive research on the psychology of music, particularly how we perceive and process musical sounds and emotions. His work has helped bridge the gap between the fields of music theory and cognitive psychology, exploring how our understanding of music influences emotional responses and behavior in various contexts, such as marketing and consumer behavior.
Embodied Cognition: Embodied cognition is the theory that our thoughts and understanding are deeply influenced by our physical experiences and interactions with the world around us. It suggests that cognition is not just a brain-centered activity but involves the body, meaning that our sensory and motor experiences shape how we think and perceive emotions, including musical emotions. This perspective is especially relevant in understanding how music evokes emotional responses by engaging both our bodies and minds.
Emotional Contagion: Emotional contagion refers to the phenomenon where individuals mimic and synchronize their emotional states with those of others, often leading to shared feelings and responses. This process can occur through various channels, including facial expressions, vocal tone, and body language, making it particularly relevant in social situations like music listening or performance. It plays a significant role in how people connect with each other emotionally, impacting responses to music, group dynamics, and social bonding.
Emotional expressiveness: Emotional expressiveness refers to the ability to convey emotions through various means, such as facial expressions, body language, and vocal tone. This concept is crucial in understanding how individuals communicate their feelings and how those feelings can be perceived by others, particularly in musical contexts where emotions are often expressed and elicited through sound.
Emotional Regulation: Emotional regulation refers to the processes through which individuals influence their emotions, including the ways they experience and express them. It plays a crucial role in managing emotional responses to various stimuli and situations, helping individuals cope with stress, enhance social interactions, and maintain mental well-being.
Expectancy Theory: Expectancy theory is a psychological framework that explains how individuals make decisions based on their expectations of the outcomes of their actions. It suggests that people are motivated to act in a certain way if they believe that their actions will lead to desired results, such as emotional responses or experiences when engaging with music. This theory highlights the importance of the anticipation of emotional impact and the role it plays in the experience and enjoyment of musical pieces.
Heart Rate Variability: Heart rate variability (HRV) refers to the fluctuation in time intervals between consecutive heartbeats, reflecting the autonomic nervous system's regulation of the heart. This measure is significant in understanding physiological responses to music, as it can indicate emotional and psychological states while also providing insights into stress levels and overall well-being.
Itpra theory: Itpra theory is a psychological framework that seeks to explain how music evokes emotions in listeners by identifying five key components: imagery, tension, prediction, reaction, and appraisal. Each of these components interacts to create an emotional response to music, emphasizing the importance of personal experience and perception in emotional reactions. This theory helps in understanding not just what emotions music can convey, but how listeners interpret and respond to musical elements.
Joy: Joy is a complex emotional experience characterized by feelings of happiness, delight, and contentment. In the context of musical emotion, joy can arise from various elements such as melody, harmony, rhythm, and the listener's personal associations with a piece. This emotional response can vary widely depending on individual experiences and cultural backgrounds, making joy an essential aspect of how people engage with music.
Juslin & Västfjäll: Juslin & Västfjäll refer to researchers who explored the emotional responses elicited by music, particularly through their development of a theoretical framework explaining how music can evoke feelings in listeners. Their work integrates various psychological theories and proposes that musical emotion is a complex interplay of cognitive, physiological, and contextual factors that shape an individual's emotional experience with music.
Mood congruence theory: Mood congruence theory suggests that the emotional state of an individual influences their recall of information that is consistent with that mood. This theory posits that people in a positive mood are more likely to remember happy or uplifting experiences, while those in a negative mood are inclined to recall sad or distressing memories. This connection between mood and memory plays a significant role in how we experience and interpret music, linking emotional responses to musical choices.
Mood induction: Mood induction refers to the process of evoking or manipulating a specific emotional state in individuals through various stimuli or techniques. This can include music, imagery, or other sensory experiences that are designed to elicit a particular mood, such as happiness, sadness, or nostalgia. Understanding mood induction is crucial for exploring how emotional responses to music can vary based on the methods used to induce those emotions.
Neuroimaging: Neuroimaging refers to a variety of techniques used to visualize the structure and function of the brain. These methods allow researchers to observe brain activity and understand how it relates to cognitive processes like music perception and emotion. By providing insights into how the brain processes music, neuroimaging plays a critical role in advancing knowledge in areas such as emotional responses to music, the relationship between music and language, and the integration of innovative technologies in music psychology research.
Nostalgia: Nostalgia is a complex emotional experience characterized by a sentimental longing for the past, often evoking feelings of warmth, happiness, or sadness. This emotion can be triggered by music, leading to a connection between specific songs and personal memories, influencing emotional responses and preferences throughout life. Nostalgia not only shapes our personal musical experiences but also plays a significant role in how different demographic factors affect music preferences over time.
Prototype theory: Prototype theory is a cognitive framework that suggests people categorize objects, concepts, and experiences based on typical or 'prototypical' examples rather than strict definitions. This theory highlights how certain features or characteristics are more representative of a category than others, influencing how individuals perceive and interpret music and emotions, as well as their musical preferences and tastes.
Psychological constructivism: Psychological constructivism is a theory that emphasizes the role of individual mental processes in understanding and interpreting experiences, particularly how these processes shape one's emotional responses to music. This perspective asserts that emotions are not solely reactions to external stimuli but are constructed through personal experiences, cognitive evaluations, and cultural contexts, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of musical emotion.
Sadness: Sadness is an emotional state characterized by feelings of sorrow, disappointment, or loss. It often arises in response to negative life events, such as the loss of a loved one or personal failures. In music, sadness can be expressed through specific melodies, harmonies, and rhythms that evoke a sense of melancholy and reflection, connecting deeply with listeners' emotional experiences.
Surveys: Surveys are research tools used to collect data from individuals, typically through structured questionnaires or interviews, to gather insights about attitudes, opinions, or behaviors. In the context of music psychology, surveys play a vital role in understanding how individuals experience musical emotion, communicate socially through music, develop musical tastes, and reveal personality traits based on their music preferences.