3.3 Dynamical Systems Theory
4 min read•july 30, 2024
Dynamical Systems Theory views movement as an emergent property arising from complex interactions. It emphasizes , , and the role of variability in motor control. This approach offers a fresh perspective on how we learn and adapt our movements.
Understanding constraints is key in this theory. Organismic, environmental, and shape our motor behavior. By manipulating these constraints, we can explore different movement solutions and develop more efficient and adaptable motor skills.
Dynamical Systems Theory for Motor Learning
Principles of Dynamical Systems Theory in Motor Control
Top images from around the web for Principles of Dynamical Systems Theory in Motor Control
Dynamical systems theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Attractive Gait Training: Applying Dynamical Systems Theory to the Improvement of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Dynamical systems theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Attractive Gait Training: Applying Dynamical Systems Theory to the Improvement of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Principles of Dynamical Systems Theory in Motor Control
Dynamical systems theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Attractive Gait Training: Applying Dynamical Systems Theory to the Improvement of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Dynamical systems theory - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Attractive Gait Training: Applying Dynamical Systems Theory to the Improvement of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Views movement as an emergent property arising from complex interactions between the individual, environment, and task
- Movement patterns are self-organized and understood as stable attractor states in a complex, nonlinear system
- Attractor states represent preferred or stable movement patterns that the system tends to gravitate towards
- Examples of attractor states include walking and running gaits, or the in bimanual tasks (in-phase and anti-phase)
- , such as movement speed or joint angles, can lead to transitions between different coordinative states or movement patterns
- Changes in control parameters can cause the system to shift from one attractor state to another
- For example, increasing walking speed can lead to a transition from a walking gait to a running gait
- Variability in movement is an essential feature of the system, allowing for flexibility and adaptability in response to changing constraints
- Variability enables the system to explore different movement solutions and adapt to perturbations or changes in the environment
- Example: Variability in joint angles during walking allows for adjustments to uneven terrain or obstacles
- Learning is viewed as a process of exploring the and discovering new, stable movement patterns through the interaction of constraints
- Learners actively explore the range of possible movement solutions within the constraints imposed by their body, the environment, and the task
- Through this exploration, learners discover and refine stable, efficient movement patterns that meet the task demands
Self-Organization and Emergence of Coordinated Movement
- Self-organization refers to the spontaneous formation of ordered, stable patterns from complex interactions within a system
- Ordered patterns emerge without the need for a central controller or explicit programming
- Examples of self-organization in nature include the formation of snowflakes, flocking behavior in birds, or the synchronization of firefly flashing
- In motor control, self-organization occurs through the interplay of the neuromusculoskeletal system, environment, and task demands
- The complex interactions between muscles, joints, sensory feedback, and environmental factors give rise to coordinated movement patterns
- For example, the rhythmic coordination of limbs during walking or swimming emerges from the self-organization of the neuromuscular system
- , or functional groupings of muscles and joints, arise through self-organization to produce efficient and coordinated movements
- Synergies reduce the dimensionality of the motor control problem by organizing multiple degrees of freedom into functional units
- Examples of synergies include the co-activation of leg muscles during jumping or the coordination of arm and hand muscles during reaching and grasping
- "" are collective variables that capture the essential dynamics of the system and govern the emergence of specific movement patterns
- Order parameters describe the overall state of the system and can be used to predict or control its behavior
- Examples of order parameters in motor control include relative phase in bimanual coordination or the center of mass trajectory in postural control
Constraints Shaping Motor Behavior
Types of Constraints
- refer to the individual's physical and psychological characteristics
- Body size, strength, flexibility, motivation, and attention are examples of organismic constraints
- These constraints shape the individual's "" or preferred movement patterns
- For example, an individual's height and limb lengths influence their natural walking stride length and frequency
- include factors external to the individual
- Gravity, surface properties, and the presence of obstacles or other individuals are examples of environmental constraints
- These constraints can facilitate or hinder specific movement patterns and influence the perception-action coupling
- For example, walking on a slippery surface requires different movement strategies compared to walking on a stable surface
- Task constraints encompass the goals, rules, and equipment specific to a particular motor task
- Task constraints define the "task space" or the range of possible movement solutions that can successfully achieve the goal
- Examples of task constraints include the target size and distance in a reaching task, or the rules and equipment in a sport
Interaction of Constraints and Motor Learning
- The interaction of organismic, environmental, and task constraints determines the "perceptual-motor workspace"
- The perceptual-motor workspace represents the range of possible movement solutions available to the individual within the given constraints
- Learners explore this workspace to discover and refine effective movement patterns
- Manipulating constraints can be used as a tool for shaping motor learning and facilitating the acquisition of new movement skills
- Modifying task constraints, such as increasing or decreasing the size of a target, can challenge learners to adapt their movements and promote learning
- Altering environmental constraints, such as practicing in different surface conditions, can enhance the transfer of skills to novel contexts
- Tailoring practice to individual organismic constraints, such as adjusting equipment size or providing specific feedback, can optimize learning for each learner
Key Terms to Review (22)
Affordances: Affordances refer to the perceived and actual properties of an object that determine how it can be used or interacted with by an individual. This concept is crucial in understanding how learners perceive their environment and how they adapt their movements based on the opportunities presented to them. Affordances highlight the relationship between an individual and their surroundings, indicating that movement is not just about physical abilities but also about recognizing the possibilities offered by the environment.
Attractor states: Attractor states refer to stable patterns of behavior or movement that emerge in dynamic systems, acting as a point toward which a system tends to evolve over time. These states are significant in understanding how complex motor behaviors can stabilize and repeat in predictable ways, demonstrating the interplay between environmental constraints and individual capabilities.
Chaos Theory: Chaos theory is a branch of mathematics that studies complex systems whose behavior is highly sensitive to initial conditions, often referred to as the 'butterfly effect.' This means that small changes in the starting point of a system can lead to vastly different outcomes, making long-term prediction impossible. In the context of dynamical systems, chaos theory helps in understanding how certain systems can exhibit unpredictable behavior even though they are governed by deterministic laws.
Control Parameters: Control parameters are variables that influence the dynamics of a system, determining how a movement or behavior is performed. They are essential in understanding how changes in these parameters can lead to shifts in movement patterns, playing a crucial role in motor learning and the adaptation of motor skills within a dynamical systems framework.
Coordination Patterns: Coordination patterns refer to the organized and efficient ways in which different body parts move together during skilled actions or tasks. These patterns are crucial for achieving optimal performance and fluidity in movements, highlighting the dynamic interplay between physical capabilities and task requirements. Understanding coordination patterns helps in analyzing how individuals adapt their movements to various contexts, allowing for improvements in skill acquisition and performance.
Dynamic Stability: Dynamic stability refers to the ability of a system to maintain its balance and perform effectively in the face of disturbances or changes in its environment. This concept highlights how movements and postures can adapt over time, allowing organisms or systems to return to a state of equilibrium after being disturbed. It's essential for understanding how individuals and systems manage variability during motion, which is a critical aspect of performance and learning in motor skills.
Emergent Properties: Emergent properties refer to characteristics or behaviors that arise from the interaction of simpler elements within a system, which cannot be predicted from the properties of the individual components alone. This concept highlights how complex systems exhibit new patterns, dynamics, or functions when their parts interact, emphasizing the importance of relationships and context in understanding behavior.
Environmental Constraints: Environmental constraints refer to the external factors in a person's surroundings that can influence movement and performance. These constraints can include physical aspects like gravity, terrain, and obstacles, as well as social or cultural influences that shape how skills are learned and executed. Understanding these constraints is crucial for comprehending how movement patterns emerge and are adapted during skill acquisition and execution.
Environmental Variability: Environmental variability refers to the changes and fluctuations in the external conditions that can affect the performance of motor skills. This concept emphasizes how different contexts, such as weather, terrain, or even social settings, can impact how a skill is executed. Understanding environmental variability is crucial as it helps in recognizing how adaptable an individual must be to achieve consistent performance in diverse situations.
Garry W. McPherson: Garry W. McPherson is a prominent figure in the field of music education and motor learning, known for his contributions to understanding how individuals acquire motor skills, particularly in music performance. His research emphasizes the application of Dynamical Systems Theory to music learning, focusing on the interaction between the learner and the environment. McPherson's work has significant implications for how educators approach teaching music and other motor skills.
Ilya Prigogine: Ilya Prigogine was a Belgian physical chemist best known for his work on dissipative structures and non-equilibrium thermodynamics. His research provided crucial insights into how systems far from equilibrium can exhibit self-organization, which is important for understanding complex systems in various fields including physics, chemistry, and even biology.
Interconnectedness: Interconnectedness refers to the relationship and interaction between different components within a system, highlighting how changes in one part can affect others. This concept emphasizes that systems, such as those involved in motor learning and control, are not isolated; rather, they function as dynamic networks where elements like individual behaviors, environmental factors, and task demands influence each other. Understanding interconnectedness is crucial for analyzing the complexities of movement patterns and motor performance.
Intrinsic Dynamics: Intrinsic dynamics refers to the natural, self-organizing patterns and behaviors that emerge from the interactions of a system's components without external influences. It highlights how individual elements within a complex system contribute to its overall behavior, showcasing the interplay between internal forces and structural constraints. Understanding intrinsic dynamics is crucial for grasping how systems adapt, evolve, and maintain stability over time.
Nonlinear dynamics: Nonlinear dynamics is a branch of mathematics and physics that studies systems in which the output is not directly proportional to the input, often leading to complex and unpredictable behavior. These systems can exhibit phenomena such as chaos, bifurcations, and attractors, making them significantly different from linear systems where changes are predictable and proportionate. In the context of dynamical systems theory, nonlinear dynamics plays a crucial role in understanding how movements and actions can evolve over time, often in unexpected ways.
Order Parameters: Order parameters are quantitative measures that capture the collective behavior and coordination of a system, particularly in the context of dynamical systems. They help to describe how individual elements of a system interact and synchronize to produce coherent patterns or behaviors, reflecting the transition from disorder to order. In motor control, order parameters can be used to analyze movement patterns and the stability of those patterns during performance.
Organismic constraints: Organismic constraints refer to the internal factors that limit or shape a person's ability to perform motor tasks, influenced by physical, psychological, and biological characteristics. These constraints can affect an individual's movement capabilities and are integral to understanding how people learn and control their motor skills within various environments.
Perception-Action Loop: The perception-action loop is a continuous process through which individuals perceive their environment and act upon it, enabling adaptive behavior. This loop involves the integration of sensory information, processing it to create an understanding of the surroundings, followed by executing movements based on that perception. The feedback from the actions then informs future perceptions, creating a dynamic interaction between sensory input and motor output.
Perceptual-Motor Workspace: The perceptual-motor workspace refers to the cognitive and neural processes that integrate perceptual information with motor commands to facilitate movement. This workspace acts as a mental space where sensory inputs and motor outputs converge, allowing for the planning, execution, and adjustment of movements based on real-time feedback from the environment. Understanding this concept is vital for analyzing how movement patterns are formed and modified during skill acquisition and performance.
Phase Transitions: Phase transitions refer to the process of changing from one state of a dynamical system to another, typically involving a qualitative shift in behavior or organization. These transitions are characterized by changes in stability and can manifest in various forms, such as shifting from coordinated to uncoordinated movement patterns. Understanding phase transitions helps in analyzing how complex systems adapt and reorganize under different conditions.
Self-organization: Self-organization refers to the process by which a system organizes itself without external guidance or control. In this context, it highlights how complex patterns and behaviors can emerge from the interactions of simpler components, illustrating the dynamic and adaptive nature of systems, particularly in motor learning and control.
Synergies: Synergies refer to the coordinated and cooperative interactions between different muscles and joints that work together to produce efficient and effective movements. This concept highlights how the nervous system organizes these muscular interactions to optimize performance, reduce energy expenditure, and ensure adaptability in various motor tasks.
Task constraints: Task constraints refer to the specific rules, requirements, and conditions that shape how a motor skill is performed, impacting the way learners approach and execute tasks. These constraints can influence progression through different stages of skill acquisition, as they can determine how individuals adapt their movements to achieve desired outcomes while navigating the challenges presented by the environment. Understanding task constraints is essential for recognizing how they interact with individual and environmental factors in motor learning.