12.3 Hierarchical Theory of Motor Control
7 min read•july 30, 2024
The hierarchical theory of motor control suggests our nervous system is organized in levels, from the cerebral cortex down to muscles. Higher levels plan complex movements, while lower levels execute them. This structure allows for flexible, adaptable movement control.
Information flows both up and down the hierarchy, integrating sensory feedback with motor commands. This bidirectional flow enables us to adjust movements on the fly, adapting to changes in our environment or task demands. It's like a well-oiled machine, constantly fine-tuning our actions.
Hierarchical Motor Control System
Organization and Structure
Top images from around the web for Organization and Structure
Introduction to Neural Control of Movement – KINES 200: Introductory Neuroscience View original
Is this image relevant?
Brain | Biology for Majors II View original
Is this image relevant?
Motor cortex - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Introduction to Neural Control of Movement – KINES 200: Introductory Neuroscience View original
Is this image relevant?
Brain | Biology for Majors II View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Organization and Structure
Introduction to Neural Control of Movement – KINES 200: Introductory Neuroscience View original
Is this image relevant?
Brain | Biology for Majors II View original
Is this image relevant?
Motor cortex - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Introduction to Neural Control of Movement – KINES 200: Introductory Neuroscience View original
Is this image relevant?
Brain | Biology for Majors II View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- The hierarchical theory proposes that the motor control system is organized into distinct levels, with higher levels exerting control over lower levels
- The hierarchy typically includes the following levels: the cerebral cortex, basal ganglia, cerebellum, brainstem, spinal cord, and muscles
- Each level of the hierarchy has specific roles and functions in controlling and coordinating movement
- Higher levels of the hierarchy are responsible for planning and initiating complex, goal-directed movements, while lower levels are involved in the execution and refinement of these movements
- For example, the cerebral cortex may plan a reaching movement, while the spinal cord and muscles execute the necessary muscle activations
Information Flow and Integration
- Information flows both top-down (from higher to lower levels) and bottom-up (from lower to higher levels) within the hierarchy, allowing for the integration of sensory feedback and the adjustment of motor commands
- Top-down flow: Higher levels send motor commands to lower levels to initiate and control movements
- Bottom-up flow: Lower levels provide sensory feedback to higher levels, informing them about the current state of the body and the environment
- This bidirectional flow of information enables the motor control system to adapt to changes in the environment or task demands and to fine-tune movements based on sensory feedback
- The integration of information from multiple levels allows for the coordination of complex, multi-joint movements and the maintenance of stability and balance
Levels of Motor Control
Cerebral Cortex and Basal Ganglia
- The cerebral cortex, particularly the primary motor cortex, premotor cortex, and supplementary motor area, is involved in planning and initiating voluntary movements, as well as in the selection of appropriate motor programs
- Primary motor cortex: Directly controls the execution of movements by sending motor commands to the spinal cord and muscles
- Premotor cortex: Involved in the preparation and planning of movements, as well as in the integration of sensory information
- Supplementary motor area: Plays a role in the coordination of bilateral movements and in the planning of complex, sequential actions
- The basal ganglia play a role in the selection and initiation of motor programs, as well as in the control of movement parameters such as , force, and amplitude
- The basal ganglia receive input from the cerebral cortex and send output back to the cortex via the thalamus, forming a loop that modulates cortical activity
- Disorders of the basal ganglia, such as Parkinson's disease and Huntington's disease, can lead to difficulties in initiating or controlling movements
Cerebellum and Brainstem
- The cerebellum is involved in the coordination, timing, and precision of movements, as well as in the adaptation of motor programs based on sensory feedback and error signals
- The cerebellum receives input from the cerebral cortex, brainstem, and spinal cord, and sends output to the brainstem and cortex via the thalamus
- Damage to the cerebellum can result in impairments in balance, coordination, and the of movements (ataxia)
- The brainstem contains important nuclei, such as the vestibular nuclei and reticular formation, which are involved in postural control, balance, and the integration of sensory information
- Vestibular nuclei: Process information from the vestibular system (inner ear) to maintain balance and orientation in space
- Reticular formation: Modulates arousal, attention, and the overall excitability of the motor control system
Spinal Cord and Muscles
- The spinal cord contains local circuits, such as central pattern generators (CPGs), that can produce rhythmic, stereotyped movements (walking, swimming) even in the absence of higher-level input
- CPGs are networks of neurons that generate alternating patterns of muscle activation, enabling the production of repetitive movements
- The activity of CPGs can be modulated by input from higher levels of the hierarchy, allowing for the adaptation of these movements to different contexts or goals
- Muscles are the final effectors of the motor control system, responsible for generating the forces necessary for movement
- The activation of muscles is controlled by motor neurons in the spinal cord, which receive input from higher levels of the hierarchy
- Sensory receptors in muscles (muscle spindles) and tendons (Golgi tendon organs) provide feedback about muscle length and tension, respectively, which is used to regulate muscle activity and maintain stable postures
Motor Equivalence and Hierarchy
Concept and Implications
- Motor equivalence refers to the ability to achieve the same movement goal using different combinations of muscle activations and joint angles
- For example, reaching for an object can be accomplished using various arm and hand configurations
- The hierarchical theory suggests that higher levels of the hierarchy specify the overall goal of the movement, while lower levels determine the specific muscle activations and joint angles required to achieve that goal
- Higher levels (cortex, basal ganglia): Specify the desired endpoint or trajectory of the movement
- Lower levels (spinal cord, muscles): Determine the specific muscle activations and joint angles needed to realize the goal
- Motor equivalence allows for flexibility and adaptability in movement execution, as the motor control system can compensate for changes in the environment or constraints on the body
- If one muscle or joint is unavailable or constrained, the system can use alternative muscle activations or joint configurations to achieve the same goal
Support for Hierarchical Organization
- The existence of motor equivalence supports the idea that the motor control system is organized hierarchically, with higher levels specifying the desired outcome and lower levels determining the means to achieve it
- If the motor control system were not hierarchically organized, it would be more difficult to explain how the same movement goal can be achieved using different muscle activations and joint angles
- The hierarchical organization allows for the separation of the "what" (goal) and the "how" (means) of movement, enabling flexibility and adaptability in motor control
- Computational models based on the hierarchical theory have been successful in simulating motor equivalence and the ability to adapt to novel environments or task demands
Evidence for Hierarchical Control
Lesion Studies and Neurophysiology
- Studies of patients with brain lesions at different levels of the hierarchy (cortical, subcortical, or spinal cord lesions) have provided insights into the specific roles of each level in motor control
- Cortical lesions: Can lead to deficits in the planning and initiation of voluntary movements, as well as in the selection of appropriate motor programs
- Basal ganglia lesions: Can result in difficulties in initiating or controlling movements, as seen in Parkinson's disease and Huntington's disease
- Cerebellar lesions: Can cause impairments in balance, coordination, and the accuracy of movements (ataxia)
- Spinal cord lesions: Can lead to paralysis or weakness of the muscles innervated by the affected spinal cord segments
- Neurophysiological studies, such as single-unit recordings and functional brain imaging, have revealed the activity patterns of neurons at different levels of the hierarchy during various motor tasks
- These studies have shown that neurons in higher levels of the hierarchy (cortex, basal ganglia) are more involved in the planning and initiation of movements, while neurons in lower levels (spinal cord, muscles) are more directly related to the execution of movements
Behavioral Studies and Computational Models
- Behavioral studies have demonstrated the existence of motor equivalence and the ability of the motor control system to adapt to perturbations or changes in task demands
- Experiments have shown that individuals can achieve the same movement goal using different combinations of muscle activations and joint angles, even when faced with novel constraints or perturbations
- These studies support the idea that the motor control system is hierarchically organized, with higher levels specifying the goal and lower levels determining the means to achieve it
- Computational models based on the hierarchical theory have been successful in simulating and explaining various aspects of motor control, such as the generation of complex movements and the adaptation to novel environments
- These models typically include multiple levels of control, with higher levels specifying the desired outcome and lower levels determining the specific muscle activations and joint angles required to achieve that outcome
- The success of these models in replicating key features of motor control provides further support for the hierarchical organization of the motor control system
Evolutionary Considerations
- Evolutionary considerations support the idea of a hierarchical organization, as it allows for the progressive development of more complex and flexible motor behaviors while maintaining the basic functionality of lower levels
- The hierarchical organization of the motor control system may have evolved in a stepwise manner, with lower levels (spinal cord, brainstem) emerging earlier in evolutionary history and providing the foundation for the development of higher levels (cortex, basal ganglia, cerebellum)
- This organization allows for the preservation of essential motor functions (reflexes, rhythmic movements) at lower levels, while enabling the emergence of more complex and adaptive behaviors through the addition of higher levels of control
- The hierarchical structure also facilitates the integration of sensory information and the adaptation to changing environments, which are crucial for the survival and success of organisms across different species
Key Terms to Review (19)
Accuracy: Accuracy refers to the degree to which a movement or task is performed correctly and as intended, aligning closely with the desired outcome or target. It is a crucial component of skill performance, as it directly relates to how well an individual can execute a motor skill, achieve goals in sports, and refine techniques during the learning process. Achieving high levels of accuracy often reflects mastery in movement execution and is vital for progression in various learning stages, particularly as skills develop and become more refined.
Adam G. H. H. D. J. D. Van Der Heijden: Adam G. H. H. D. J. D. Van Der Heijden is a prominent figure in the field of motor control, known for his contributions to the Hierarchical Theory of Motor Control. This theory emphasizes the organization of motor skills in a hierarchical structure, where higher levels of control influence lower levels, creating a systematic approach to understanding motor behavior and coordination.
Associative stage: The associative stage is the second phase of motor skill learning, where learners begin to refine their skills and make adjustments based on feedback. During this stage, individuals develop a greater understanding of the task, leading to smoother and more coordinated movements. This phase is characterized by decreased variability in performance and improved consistency, connecting it to various aspects of sensory-motor adaptation and learning.
Autonomous stage: The autonomous stage is the final phase in the motor learning process where a performer demonstrates refined skill execution with minimal conscious effort. In this stage, movements become automatic, allowing individuals to perform tasks efficiently and focus on strategic decision-making rather than the mechanics of the skill itself.
Central pattern generator: A central pattern generator (CPG) is a neural network that produces rhythmic patterned outputs without sensory feedback. These networks are crucial for controlling repetitive movements, such as walking, running, or swimming, by coordinating muscle activity in a rhythmic manner. CPGs operate at a level of the nervous system that allows for complex motor tasks to be performed automatically, highlighting their role in facilitating coordinated movement sequences.
Closed-loop control: Closed-loop control is a system of motor control that uses feedback to regulate and adjust movements in real-time. This mechanism relies on sensory information from the environment to provide continuous updates, enabling corrections and refinements during the execution of a task, which is crucial for skillful performance across various activities.
Cognitive stage: The cognitive stage is the first phase in the motor learning process, where individuals are learning a new skill and rely heavily on conscious thought and feedback to understand the task. During this stage, learners focus on understanding the basic mechanics of the skill, which often leads to a high number of errors as they experiment and refine their movements.
Cortical control: Cortical control refers to the regulation of motor functions and movement patterns by the cerebral cortex, which is the outer layer of the brain. This control involves the integration of sensory information and the coordination of voluntary movements, allowing for precise and adaptive responses to various tasks. It plays a critical role in higher-level motor planning and execution, influencing both fine and gross motor skills.
Degrees of freedom: Degrees of freedom refers to the number of independent parameters or variables that can change in a system without violating any constraints. In motor learning and control, this concept is crucial as it relates to how movements can be planned and executed with various joint and muscle combinations. It highlights the complexity involved in motor tasks and the necessity for effective control mechanisms to manage this complexity across different levels of the nervous system.
Fine Motor Skills: Fine motor skills are the abilities that require the use of small muscles in the hands, fingers, and wrists to perform precise movements. These skills are crucial for tasks such as writing, buttoning a shirt, or using utensils, and are often developed through practice and experience. Mastering fine motor skills involves coordination, dexterity, and control, which are essential for various daily activities and play a significant role in overall motor learning and development.
Gross Motor Skills: Gross motor skills refer to the abilities that involve the large muscles of the body, which enable movements like walking, jumping, running, and maintaining balance. These skills are essential for physical development and play a significant role in various activities and sports, as well as in daily life.
Motor program: A motor program is a structured set of commands that the central nervous system uses to control movements and execute motor skills. It serves as a blueprint for coordinated actions, detailing how to perform a movement sequence from initiation to completion. This concept highlights how complex movements are often pre-planned and organized, allowing for efficient execution and adaptation in various contexts.
N. a. bernstein: N. A. Bernstein was a prominent Russian neurophysiologist and movement scientist known for his significant contributions to the understanding of motor control and learning. He developed a hierarchical model of motor control that emphasized the complex interplay between neural mechanisms and motor performance, highlighting how higher levels of the nervous system organize and coordinate lower-level movements.
Open-loop control: Open-loop control refers to a type of motor control system where the output is generated without using feedback from the environment. In this model, once a command is initiated, the system executes the action without adjusting based on the outcome, making it ideal for actions that require quick responses without the need for continuous adjustment.
Skill retention: Skill retention refers to the ability to maintain and recall motor skills over time after they have been learned. This concept is crucial as it reflects the durability of practice and the effectiveness of learning strategies used to encode skills into long-term memory. Factors such as the amount of practice, the nature of the skill, and the variability in practice can significantly influence how well a skill is retained over time.
Speed: Speed refers to the rate at which a movement is executed, typically defined as the distance traveled per unit of time. In the context of motor control, speed can influence how quickly a person can react to stimuli and perform actions, which is essential for effective performance in various physical tasks.
Subcortical control: Subcortical control refers to the regulation of motor functions by neural structures located beneath the cerebral cortex, primarily involving the basal ganglia, cerebellum, and brainstem. These structures play a crucial role in coordinating and refining movements, allowing for automatic and unconscious processing that aids in the execution of motor tasks without the need for higher cognitive input.
Synergies: Synergies refer to the coordinated and cooperative interactions between different muscles and joints that work together to produce efficient and effective movements. This concept highlights how the nervous system organizes these muscular interactions to optimize performance, reduce energy expenditure, and ensure adaptability in various motor tasks.
Transfer of Learning: Transfer of learning refers to the influence that prior learning experiences have on the performance of a new skill or task. It encompasses both positive transfer, where previous experiences enhance the learning of new skills, and negative transfer, where past experiences hinder performance. Understanding this concept is crucial for optimizing practice conditions and designing effective training regimens.