3.2 Force and impedance control
4 min read•july 30, 2024
Force and are crucial in medical robotics for safe and precise interactions with patients. These techniques regulate forces applied by robots and modulate relationships between motion and forces, enabling adaptable behavior.
focuses on precise force application, while impedance control offers better adaptability to unknown environments. Choosing between them depends on task requirements, environmental uncertainties, and stability needs in robot-patient interactions.
Force and Impedance Control in Medical Robotics
Fundamental Concepts
Top images from around the web for Fundamental Concepts
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Design and Integration of Electrical Bio-impedance Sensing in Surgical Robotic Tools ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Fundamental Concepts
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Design and Integration of Electrical Bio-impedance Sensing in Surgical Robotic Tools ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Impedance Control for Robotic Rehabilitation: A Robust Markovian Approach View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Force control regulates forces and torques applied by robots to environments or patients ensuring safe and precise interactions
- Impedance control modulates relationships between robot motion and experienced forces allowing adaptable and compliant behavior
- defines dynamic relationships between force and motion regulated in impedance control
- Force control strategies categorized into direct and with distinct advantages in medical robotics
- Impedance control implemented as position-based or force-based depending on medical procedure requirements and robot capabilities
- Both control types rely on accurate force/torque sensing and real-time feedback loops to achieve desired robot behavior
- Selection between force and impedance control depends on task requirements, environmental uncertainties, and stability needs in robot-patient interactions
Control Techniques and Implementation
- Force control measures and regulates contact forces using force/torque in robot end-effectors
- Impedance control models robot-environment interactions as mass-spring-damper systems with adjustable and damping
- combines position and force control enabling precise manipulation in constrained environments (surgical procedures)
- , an impedance control variant, uses force measurements to generate position commands (prosthetic limb control)
- Implementation requires careful parameter tuning for stable robot behavior across medical tasks and conditions
- of control parameters accounts for changing environments or patient-specific requirements (tissue stiffness variations)
- Validation involves experimental testing with phantoms or tissue models ensuring safety and efficacy before clinical use
Applying Force and Impedance Control
Measurement and Modeling
- Force/torque sensors integrated into robot end-effectors measure contact forces (strain gauges, capacitive sensors)
- Robot-environment interaction modeled as mass-spring-damper system in impedance control (adjustable stiffness for different tissue types)
- Careful sensor calibration and noise filtering crucial for accurate force measurements (temperature compensation, signal processing)
- Environmental stiffness estimation techniques help adapt control parameters in real-time (force probing, online parameter estimation)
Control Strategies and Adaptation
- Hybrid position/force control divides task space into position-controlled and force-controlled subspaces (suturing task)
- Admittance control generates position commands based on measured forces (guiding a robotic arm for rehabilitation exercises)
- Real-time adaptation algorithms adjust control gains based on task phase or environmental conditions (varying tissue properties during surgery)
- Stability-guaranteed adaptive control ensures safe operation across varying conditions (bounded parameter adaptation)
Validation and Testing
- uses artificial tissue models to simulate various medical scenarios (silicone-based organ models)
- with animal tissues provides more realistic force interaction data (porcine tissue for surgical robot validation)
- Performance metrics include , , and
- Clinical validation involves collaboration with medical professionals assessing algorithm effectiveness in realistic scenarios ( trials)
Force vs Impedance Control Trade-offs
Task-Specific Considerations
- Force control excels in precise force application (minimally invasive surgery, tissue manipulation)
- Impedance control offers better adaptability to unknown environments (rehabilitation robotics, prosthetic devices)
- Force control may struggle with environmental uncertainties while impedance control sacrifices some force precision
- Stability of force control compromised in stiff environments while impedance control offers better stability
Application-Specific Advantages
- Force control preferred for accurate force tracking (robotic palpation for tumor detection)
- Impedance control favored in human-robot interaction scenarios (assistive devices, rehabilitation robots)
- Force control suitable for tasks requiring high stiffness and precision (bone drilling)
- Impedance control advantageous in compliant manipulation tasks (soft tissue handling)
Implementation Factors
- Computational complexity and sensor requirements differ between control types (force control may require higher sensor bandwidth)
- Operator expertise required varies affecting clinical adoption (force control may need more specialized training)
- Switching between or combining control strategies provides versatility in multi-functional systems (surgical robots with multiple end-effectors)
- Hardware limitations may influence control choice (actuator capabilities, sensor resolution)
Force and Impedance Control Algorithms
Mathematical Modeling and Control Law Design
- Algorithm development begins with robot dynamics modeling including , dynamics, and sensor characteristics
- Control structures selected based on application needs (PID, adaptive, model-based control)
- Control equations formulated for force or impedance regulation ()
- Stability analysis ensures control algorithms remain stable across operational range and uncertainties
- Robustness to parameter variations and disturbances considered in control design (H-infinity control, sliding mode control)
Simulation and Initial Testing
- Simulation platforms like MATLAB/Simulink or ROS/Gazebo used for initial algorithm testing
- Parameter tuning performed in simulation to optimize control performance (genetic algorithms, particle swarm optimization)
- Virtual environments created to simulate various medical scenarios (tissue deformation models, collision detection)
- Co-simulation techniques combine mechanical and control system models for comprehensive testing
Experimental Validation and Performance Evaluation
- Bench-top testing progresses from simple objects to complex tissue phantoms
- Ex-vivo testing with animal specimens provides realistic force interaction data
- Performance metrics include force tracking accuracy, position/velocity tracking, and stability margins
- Robustness to environmental variations and sensor noise evaluated experimentally
- Clinical validation assesses algorithm effectiveness in realistic scenarios and potential impact on patient outcomes
- Long-term stability and reliability testing ensures consistent performance over extended use
Key Terms to Review (31)
Actuators: Actuators are mechanical devices that convert energy into motion, playing a critical role in various systems by enabling movement and control. They are often used in robotics and automation to execute precise actions based on commands from control systems, making them essential for tasks that require accuracy and responsiveness. By utilizing different types of energy sources, such as electrical, hydraulic, or pneumatic, actuators facilitate dynamic interactions with the environment.
Admittance Control: Admittance control is a strategy used in robotics that focuses on how a system responds to external forces by adjusting its motion accordingly. This method emphasizes the relationship between force and motion, allowing robots to adapt their behavior based on interactions with their environment. The key idea is to control the velocity and position of a robot in response to sensed forces, making it suitable for tasks that require delicate touch and compliance.
Compliance: Compliance refers to the ability of a system or material to deform under an applied force. In the context of force and impedance control, it reflects how a robotic system responds to forces applied during interaction with the environment. A compliant system allows for flexibility and adaptability in response to external disturbances, which is crucial for tasks requiring precision and safety.
Direct Force Control: Direct force control is a technique used in robotics that involves actively measuring and adjusting the forces exerted by a robotic system to achieve desired interactions with its environment. This method emphasizes maintaining the desired force levels, allowing for more precise and stable control during tasks such as surgical procedures or robotic manipulation, which often require delicate handling of tissues or instruments. By prioritizing the feedback from force sensors, direct force control enables a robot to adapt in real-time to changes in its environment, ensuring safety and accuracy.
Dynamic Modeling: Dynamic modeling is a method used to represent and analyze the behavior of systems over time, incorporating the interactions between different components and the effects of forces acting on them. This approach is crucial in understanding how robotic systems react to external stimuli, particularly in applications that require precise force and impedance control. By simulating dynamic interactions, engineers can predict system responses and improve the performance and safety of robotic interventions in medical settings.
Error Margin: Error margin refers to the range of values within which a measurement or estimate is expected to fall, accounting for uncertainty and variability in the data. In the context of force and impedance control, understanding error margins is crucial for ensuring that robotic systems operate safely and effectively, particularly when interacting with delicate biological tissues or performing precise surgical tasks. A smaller error margin indicates a higher level of precision, which is vital in medical robotics where inaccuracies can lead to complications or adverse outcomes.
Ex-vivo testing: Ex-vivo testing refers to the evaluation of biological functions or medical devices outside of a living organism, typically using tissues or organs that have been removed from the body. This approach allows researchers and medical professionals to assess the safety and efficacy of surgical instruments and robotic systems in a controlled environment, thereby simulating real-life conditions without subjecting patients to immediate risks.
Force Accuracy: Force accuracy refers to the precision with which a robotic system can apply and measure forces during interactions with its environment. This concept is crucial in applications such as surgery and rehabilitation, where exact force application can significantly affect outcomes and patient safety. High force accuracy ensures that robotic systems can perform delicate tasks with the necessary sensitivity, which is vital when working with human tissues or other sensitive materials.
Force Control: Force control refers to the method of regulating the interaction forces between a robotic system and its environment during tasks that involve physical manipulation. This control strategy is essential for ensuring precision and safety in applications like surgery or rehabilitation, where the robot must apply appropriate forces to avoid damaging tissues or other objects while still performing tasks effectively.
Force Tracking Accuracy: Force tracking accuracy refers to the precision with which a system can measure and respond to forces applied during interactions between a robotic device and its environment. This concept is crucial in ensuring that robotic systems can replicate human-like dexterity and sensitivity, allowing for effective performance in tasks such as surgery or rehabilitation, where the correct application of force is essential to avoid damaging tissues or misplacing instruments.
Force-based control: Force-based control is a technique used in robotics that allows a system to apply and respond to forces acting on it, rather than just focusing on position or velocity. This approach is crucial in applications where interaction with the environment is necessary, such as in medical robotics and computer-assisted surgery, as it enables precise manipulation while ensuring safety and efficacy during procedures. By integrating force feedback, robots can adapt their actions in real-time based on the forces they encounter, enhancing their ability to perform complex tasks.
Haptic Feedback: Haptic feedback refers to the use of tactile sensations to provide information or cues to a user, typically through vibrations or forces that simulate the sense of touch. This technology plays a crucial role in enhancing the interaction between users and medical robotic systems by allowing surgeons to perceive forces and textures, making procedures more intuitive and precise.
Hiroshi Ishiguro: Hiroshi Ishiguro is a prominent Japanese roboticist known for his work in human-robot interaction and developing humanoid robots that closely resemble humans. His creations challenge the boundaries between humans and machines, particularly through the concepts of embodiment and social presence, impacting areas such as force control in robotics, therapeutic applications for neurological disorders, and advancements in soft robotics for prosthetics and orthotics.
Hybrid Position/Force Control: Hybrid position/force control is a control strategy that integrates both position control and force control to allow a robotic system to effectively interact with its environment. This approach enables the robot to maintain a desired position while simultaneously regulating the force exerted on or by the environment, making it particularly useful in tasks where both precision and compliance are critical. The combination of these two control modes helps improve performance in applications like surgery, where delicate maneuvers are necessary.
Impedance Control: Impedance control is a control strategy used in robotics that adjusts the mechanical impedance of a system, allowing it to respond dynamically to external forces. This approach is essential in applications where interaction with the environment or a human operator is required, as it enables the robot to adapt its stiffness and damping characteristics. By managing how the robot reacts to forces, impedance control enhances safety, precision, and performance in tasks such as surgery or delicate assembly.
Indirect Force Control: Indirect force control is a method used in robotic systems to manage the interaction forces between a robot and its environment, without directly measuring or controlling these forces. Instead of aiming for a specific force value, this approach focuses on achieving desired motion profiles that indirectly influence the forces experienced during operation. This technique is essential in applications where delicate touch and precision are necessary, such as in medical robotics and surgical procedures.
Kinematics: Kinematics is the branch of mechanics that deals with the motion of objects without considering the forces that cause this motion. It focuses on parameters such as position, velocity, and acceleration, which are crucial for understanding how robotic systems move and interact with their environment. This understanding is vital in designing robots for tasks like motion planning, force control, actuator selection, and developing prosthetics that mimic natural limb movement.
Mechanical Impedance: Mechanical impedance refers to the measure of a system's resistance to motion when subjected to a force. It is defined as the ratio of force applied to the resulting velocity, and it plays a critical role in understanding how systems respond to external forces, particularly in applications that require precise control, such as robotics and computer-assisted surgery.
Minimally Invasive Surgery: Minimally invasive surgery (MIS) is a surgical technique that reduces the size of incisions needed and shortens recovery time, allowing for less trauma to the body compared to traditional open surgery. This technique often utilizes advanced technologies, such as robotic systems and imaging techniques, to enhance precision and control during procedures. By minimizing damage to surrounding tissues, patients typically experience less pain, a lower risk of infection, and quicker return to daily activities.
Phantom Testing: Phantom testing refers to the evaluation of medical devices or surgical systems using artificial models that simulate human anatomy and physiological responses. This process allows for the assessment of device performance, safety, and efficacy in a controlled environment without involving real patients. By using phantoms, developers can test various parameters, including force and impedance control, which are critical for ensuring that robotic systems interact effectively with biological tissues during procedures.
Position-based control: Position-based control is a control strategy that focuses on regulating the position of a robotic system by determining and adjusting its movements to achieve a desired location or orientation. This method is essential in various robotic applications, particularly where precise positioning is crucial, such as in surgery or industrial automation. By ensuring accurate positioning, this technique enhances the overall performance and effectiveness of robotic systems, allowing them to interact safely and efficiently with their environment.
Position/Velocity Control: Position/velocity control refers to the methods used in robotic systems to regulate and manage the position and speed of a robotic manipulator or actuator. This approach is crucial for ensuring that a robot can perform precise movements and maintain accurate positioning during tasks, which is particularly important in applications like surgery and industrial automation. By adjusting inputs based on desired positions and velocities, these control strategies enable robots to interact safely and effectively with their environment.
Real-time adaptation: Real-time adaptation refers to the ability of a system to adjust its parameters and behavior dynamically in response to changing conditions during operation. This capability is essential for achieving optimal performance in environments that are unpredictable or where precise control is necessary, such as in robotic surgical systems. It allows for seamless interaction between the robot and the surgical environment, ensuring that the device can respond effectively to unexpected forces or changes in tissue compliance.
Response Time: Response time refers to the duration it takes for a system or device to react to an input or stimulus. In the context of robotics and control systems, it is a critical metric that reflects how quickly a robot can respond to changes in its environment or commands from a user. Short response times are essential for effective motion planning, ensuring accurate force control, optimizing actuator performance, and maintaining stability in feedback control systems.
Robot-assisted laparoscopic surgery: Robot-assisted laparoscopic surgery is a minimally invasive surgical technique that employs robotic systems to enhance the surgeon's capabilities during procedures performed through small incisions. This method improves precision and control, allowing for more complex surgeries to be performed with reduced recovery time and less trauma to the patient. The integration of advanced technology in this surgical approach also opens doors to various enhancements like better visualization, force feedback, and automation of certain tasks.
Robotic teleoperation: Robotic teleoperation refers to the ability to control a robot from a distance, allowing an operator to manipulate robotic systems remotely, often in challenging or hazardous environments. This technology enables real-time interaction between the operator and the robot, with the potential to integrate sensory feedback such as video and haptic sensations. In medical applications, robotic teleoperation can facilitate precise surgical procedures by providing surgeons with enhanced control and feedback.
Sensors: Sensors are devices that detect and respond to physical stimuli, converting these inputs into signals that can be measured and interpreted. In medical robotics and computer-assisted surgery, sensors play a crucial role by providing real-time feedback on various parameters such as force, position, and environmental conditions, enhancing the precision and safety of surgical procedures.
Stability Margins: Stability margins refer to the thresholds that indicate how well a system can maintain its stability when subjected to external disturbances or changes in operating conditions. In control systems, particularly in force and impedance control, these margins help assess the robustness of a system's performance and ensure it can respond appropriately to variations while minimizing oscillations and instability.
Stiffness: Stiffness is a measure of a material's resistance to deformation under applied force. In the context of robotics and control systems, it plays a crucial role in determining how a robotic system responds to external forces during interactions with its environment. Stiffness affects the performance of robotic manipulators, especially when precision and safety are paramount in tasks such as surgery or rehabilitation.
Surgical fidelity: Surgical fidelity refers to the accuracy and realism of a surgical simulation, which is essential for effective training and practice in surgical procedures. High surgical fidelity ensures that the simulation mimics real-life conditions as closely as possible, including tactile feedback, visual realism, and the response of tissues to surgical interventions. This realism is crucial for developing the skills and confidence necessary for surgeons to perform procedures safely and effectively.
Yoshiyuki Sankai: Yoshiyuki Sankai is a prominent Japanese roboticist and researcher known for his work in developing innovative robotic systems for medical applications, particularly in the field of rehabilitation. He is the founder of Cyberdyne, a company focused on creating robotic exoskeletons that assist patients with mobility impairments. His contributions have significantly impacted how robotic technology can enhance patient care and rehabilitation processes, particularly through force and impedance control strategies.