Fiveable
Fiveable

🧿Intro to Literary Theory

🧿intro to literary theory review

9.2 Key Thinkers in Postcolonial Theory

3 min readLast Updated on July 22, 2024

Postcolonial theory challenges Western representations of the East and amplifies marginalized voices. Key thinkers like Said, Spivak, and Bhabha introduced concepts that reveal power dynamics in cultural discourse and identity formation.

These ideas expose how language and representation shape postcolonial identities. By examining Orientalism, the subaltern, and hybridity, we can better understand the complex legacies of colonialism and ongoing struggles for self-representation.

Key Thinkers in Postcolonial Theory

Contributions of postcolonial theorists

Top images from around the web for Contributions of postcolonial theorists
Top images from around the web for Contributions of postcolonial theorists
  • Edward Said
    • Developed concept of Orientalism argues Western representations of the East based on stereotypes and power relations (binary oppositions, justification for domination)
    • Emphasized examining relationship between knowledge and power in fields like literature, art, politics
  • Gayatri Spivak
    • Introduced concept of the subaltern refers to marginalized groups excluded from dominant discourses and power structures (women, working class, colonized peoples)
    • Questioned ability of subaltern to speak for themselves within dominant discourses often silenced or misrepresented
    • Highlighted need for intellectuals to critically engage with representation of subaltern acknowledges limitations of representation, risks of speaking for rather than with
  • Homi Bhabha
    • Developed concept of hybridity argues cultural identities not fixed but constantly negotiated and transformed
    • Emphasized importance of "third space" where cultural differences negotiated and new identities emerge
    • Contributed to understanding of mimicry and ambivalence in postcolonial contexts (appropriation of colonial culture, destabilization of colonial authority)

Concept of Orientalism

  • Orientalism refers to Western representation of the East as exotic, inferior, unchanging
  • Based on binary oppositions between rational, progressive West and irrational, backward East (civilized/uncivilized, modern/traditional)
  • Serves to justify Western domination and control over the East through discourses of civilization, progress, enlightenment
  • Shaped Western perceptions of the East in fields like literature (Arabian Nights), art (Orientalist paintings), politics (colonial policies)
  • Continues to influence contemporary representations and understandings of the East (media stereotypes, foreign policy)

Notion of the subaltern

  • Subaltern refers to marginalized groups excluded from dominant discourses and power structures
    • Includes women, working class, colonized peoples, racial and ethnic minorities
    • Often silenced or misrepresented within dominant discourses lack access to means of self-representation
  • Representing the subaltern poses challenges for intellectuals and activists
    • Risk of speaking for rather than with marginalized groups reinforces power imbalances
    • Need for critical engagement with representation acknowledges limitations and power dynamics
  • Subaltern studies aims to recover voices and experiences of marginalized groups (oral histories, vernacular literature)
  • Concept of the subaltern highlights power relations and exclusions within postcolonial societies (class hierarchies, gender inequalities)

Language in postcolonial identities

  • Language and discourse play central role in shaping postcolonial identities and power relations
  • Colonial discourses construct colonized as inferior and in need of civilizing (savage, primitive, childlike)
  • Postcolonial writers and theorists challenge and subvert colonial discourses through strategies like:
    1. Mimicry appropriation of colonial language and culture to destabilize authority (Caliban in The Tempest)
    2. Hybridity mixing of cultural forms and identities to create new spaces of resistance (Creole languages)
    3. Abrogation rejection of colonial language and assertion of indigenous languages and cultures (Ngugi wa Thiong'o)
  • Use of English as global language raises questions about linguistic imperialism and marginalization of indigenous languages (loss of cultural heritage, assimilation)
  • Postcolonial theory emphasizes examining power dynamics embedded in language and discourse (who speaks, who is silenced, what is valued)

Key Terms to Review (22)

African Literature: African literature refers to the body of written and oral works produced by authors from the African continent, encompassing a wide range of genres, styles, and languages. This literature reflects the diverse cultures, histories, and experiences of African people, often addressing themes of colonialism, identity, and resistance, making it deeply intertwined with the legacy of colonialism and the ongoing discourse in postcolonial theory.
Orientalism: Orientalism refers to the representation of Eastern cultures, primarily those of the Middle East and Asia, through a Western lens that often emphasizes stereotypes, exoticism, and cultural superiority. This concept highlights how literature and art have been used to create an image of the East that reinforces Western colonial and imperialist ideologies, thus shaping perceptions of non-Western societies.
Postcolonial feminism: Postcolonial feminism is an analytical framework that examines the intersection of gender, race, and colonial histories, highlighting how the experiences of women in formerly colonized nations differ from those in Western contexts. It critiques both colonial and feminist discourses, asserting that they often marginalize the voices and experiences of women of color while advocating for their rights and identities within a global context.
Language and discourse: Language refers to the system of communication used by humans, consisting of words, symbols, and rules for combining them, while discourse is the way language is used in context to convey meaning, shaping and reflecting social and cultural realities. Together, they are crucial for understanding how identities, power dynamics, and ideologies are constructed and communicated within societies.
Caribbean Studies: Caribbean Studies is an interdisciplinary field that examines the history, culture, literature, and politics of the Caribbean region, focusing on the effects of colonialism, slavery, and migration. This field connects to broader discussions in postcolonial theory, analyzing how Caribbean identity is shaped by historical and social dynamics, and how these elements contribute to global cultural narratives.
Colonial discourses: Colonial discourses refer to the ways in which knowledge, language, and power were constructed and circulated during the colonial period, often shaping perceptions of colonized peoples and places. This term connects to themes of identity, representation, and the impact of colonialism on both the colonizers and the colonized, highlighting how narratives were crafted to justify domination and exploitation.
Vernacular literature: Vernacular literature refers to written works that are composed in the native language of a specific region or community, as opposed to a more formal or classical language. This form of literature is significant because it makes stories, poetry, and other literary expressions accessible to the general population, often reflecting local culture, customs, and experiences.
Postcolonial studies: Postcolonial studies is an academic field that examines the effects and ongoing impacts of colonialism on cultures, societies, and identities. It explores how colonized nations and peoples respond to and resist colonial power, addressing issues of representation, identity, and the legacies of colonial history in contemporary contexts.
Oral histories: Oral histories are narrative accounts of personal experiences and events, conveyed through spoken word rather than written texts. They play a crucial role in preserving cultural identities and collective memories, particularly for marginalized communities whose stories may not be represented in mainstream historical narratives.
Cultural exchange: Cultural exchange refers to the mutual sharing and blending of cultural elements, such as ideas, practices, and traditions, between different societies or groups. This process often occurs through migration, trade, colonization, or globalization, leading to the enrichment and transformation of cultures involved. It plays a significant role in shaping identities and fostering understanding in a diverse world.
Third space: The third space is a concept that refers to a social and cultural space where different identities, cultures, and experiences intersect and interact. This space allows for the creation of new meanings and understandings, challenging binary oppositions such as colonizer/colonized or dominant/subordinate. It emphasizes fluidity and hybridity in identity, making it a critical idea in postcolonial discourse.
Edward Said: Edward Said was a Palestinian-American scholar, literary critic, and theorist, best known for his work in postcolonial studies, particularly through his influential book 'Orientalism.' His ideas challenge Western representations of the East and highlight the power dynamics in cultural discourse, which have implications for understanding literary theory's historical development, key postcolonial thinkers, and the impacts of globalization on world literature.
Ambivalence: Ambivalence refers to the coexistence of contradictory feelings or attitudes towards a person, object, or idea. It highlights the complexities of human emotions and thoughts, where individuals can simultaneously hold opposing views or feelings, leading to a sense of uncertainty or indecision. This term is particularly significant in understanding the dynamics of postcolonial theory, as it reflects the multifaceted relationships between colonizers and the colonized, showcasing how both admiration and resentment can exist side by side.
Hybridity: Hybridity refers to the blending of different cultural, linguistic, or social influences to create something new and unique. This concept is often examined in relation to colonialism and globalization, highlighting how cultures interact, influence one another, and produce mixed identities that challenge traditional categories.
Subaltern Studies: Subaltern Studies is an academic approach that focuses on the voices, experiences, and perspectives of marginalized groups, particularly in the context of colonialism and imperialism. It aims to challenge the dominant narratives created by those in power and highlights the importance of understanding history and society from the viewpoint of those who have been historically oppressed or ignored.
Subaltern: Subaltern refers to individuals or groups that are socially, politically, and geographically outside of the dominant power structures, often lacking representation and voice in society. This concept is essential in understanding the dynamics of power and identity, particularly in postcolonial contexts where marginalized voices struggle against colonial and imperial narratives.
Homi K. Bhabha: Homi K. Bhabha is a prominent postcolonial theorist known for his influential ideas on identity, culture, and colonial discourse. His work explores the complexities of hybrid identities formed in the aftermath of colonialism, emphasizing concepts like mimicry and the subaltern, which reflect the power dynamics between colonizers and the colonized. Bhabha's theories are vital for understanding contemporary globalization and how world literature is shaped by these intersecting cultural narratives.
Postcolonial identities: Postcolonial identities refer to the complex and dynamic ways in which individuals and groups define themselves in the aftermath of colonial rule. These identities are influenced by historical, cultural, and social factors that emerged from the colonial experience, leading to a blend of indigenous traditions and colonial legacies. Understanding postcolonial identities involves examining how former colonies navigate their sense of self in relation to the colonizers, the effects of globalization, and the ongoing struggles for cultural representation and autonomy.
Gayatri Spivak: Gayatri Spivak is an influential postcolonial theorist and literary critic, known for her critical insights into the ways Western intellectuals engage with the voices and narratives of the marginalized. She is particularly famous for her essay 'Can the Subaltern Speak?', where she examines the representation of colonized subjects in literature and theory, questioning whether those subjected to colonialism can truly express their own identities in a way that is understood by Western audiences.
Decolonization: Decolonization is the process through which colonies gain independence from colonial powers, leading to the dismantling of imperial structures and the emergence of new nation-states. This term encompasses not only political and territorial changes but also cultural and social transformations as formerly colonized peoples reclaim their identities, histories, and autonomy.
Mimicry: Mimicry refers to the act of imitating or copying the characteristics, behaviors, or language of another group, often in a way that can reinforce power dynamics and cultural hierarchies. In postcolonial contexts, mimicry can serve as a form of resistance while also highlighting the complexities of identity, as colonized individuals adopt aspects of the colonizer’s culture while simultaneously maintaining their own.
Cultural imperialism: Cultural imperialism refers to the imposition of one culture's values, beliefs, and practices over another culture, often as a result of economic or political dominance. This phenomenon manifests in literature and media, influencing how cultures perceive themselves and others, and is crucial for understanding the legacies of colonialism and imperialism.