8.1 The nature of the polis and citizenship
3 min read•august 9, 2024
Aristotle's political philosophy centers on the , an ancient Greek . He sees it as a natural association arising from human social tendencies, developing from smaller units like families and villages. The polis aims for self-sufficiency and for its citizens.
in the polis involves active participation in governance, with rights and duties. Aristotle views humans as political animals, naturally inclined towards communal living. The household (oikos) serves as the foundation of the polis, reflecting the natural progression of human associations.
Nature of the Polis
The Polis as a Natural Association
Top images from around the web for The Polis as a Natural Association
History of Western civilization before AD 500 - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Stagira (ancient city), birthplace and grave of Aristotle | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Aristotle | Introduction to Philosophy View original
Is this image relevant?
History of Western civilization before AD 500 - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Stagira (ancient city), birthplace and grave of Aristotle | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for The Polis as a Natural Association
History of Western civilization before AD 500 - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Stagira (ancient city), birthplace and grave of Aristotle | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Aristotle | Introduction to Philosophy View original
Is this image relevant?
History of Western civilization before AD 500 - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Stagira (ancient city), birthplace and grave of Aristotle | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Polis refers to the ancient Greek city-state, a self-governing political entity
- Functions as a natural association arising from human social tendencies
- Develops organically from smaller units like families and villages
- Represents the highest form of human community in Aristotle's political theory
- Embodies collective pursuit of the good life and virtuous citizenship
Autarkeia and Self-Sufficiency
- Autarkeia describes the self-sufficiency and independence of the polis
- Enables citizens to meet their material and spiritual needs within the community
- Fosters economic stability through local production and trade
- Promotes political autonomy by reducing reliance on external entities
- Cultivates cultural identity and shared values among citizens
Telos and the Purpose of the Polis
- Telos signifies the ultimate purpose or end goal of the polis
- Aims to achieve eudaimonia (human flourishing) for its citizens
- Provides framework for moral and intellectual development
- Facilitates the practice of virtues through civic participation
- Creates conditions for individuals to realize their full potential as human beings
Citizenship and Political Life
Defining Citizenship in the Polis
- Citizenship entails active participation in the governance of the polis
- Requires fulfillment of civic duties and responsibilities
- Grants rights to vote, hold office, and engage in public deliberation
- Limited to free adult males in ancient Greek society (excluded women, slaves, and foreigners)
- Viewed as a privilege and source of personal identity and pride
Humans as Political Animals
- Aristotle characterizes humans as political animals (zoon politikon)
- Emphasizes innate social nature and need for communal living
- Highlights capacity for rational speech and moral reasoning
- Argues essential for human fulfillment
- Suggests isolation from society unnatural and detrimental to human development
Koinonia and Political Community
- Koinonia represents the concept of political community or association
- Encompasses shared values, customs, and goals among citizens
- Fosters sense of belonging and collective identity within the polis
- Promotes cooperation and mutual support among community members
- Serves as foundation for political stability and social cohesion
Household and City
The Oikos as Foundation of the Polis
- Oikos refers to the household unit in ancient Greek society
- Consists of family members, slaves, and property under patriarchal authority
- Functions as basic economic and social unit within the polis
- Provides framework for early moral education and character development
- Serves as microcosm of larger political structure in Aristotle's theory
Relationship Between Oikos and Polis
- Polis emerges from the natural growth and association of multiple oikoi
- Household management (oikonomia) influences political governance
- Polis protects and regulates households through laws and institutions
- Citizenship rights often tied to household status and property ownership
- Tensions between private household interests and of the polis
Natural Progression of Human Associations
- Aristotle outlines natural progression from individual to family to village to polis
- Each stage of association fulfills increasingly complex human needs
- Family provides basic necessities and reproduction
- Village offers expanded economic opportunities and social interactions
- Polis achieves highest level of self-sufficiency and political organization
- Natural association emphasizes organic development of political communities
Key Terms to Review (19)
Athenian Democracy: Athenian democracy was a system of direct democracy developed in ancient Athens around the 5th century BCE, where citizens participated directly in decision-making processes rather than through elected representatives. This form of governance was foundational in shaping political thought and practices regarding citizenship, civic participation, and the role of the individual within the polis.
Citizenship: Citizenship refers to the status of being a recognized member of a political community, typically associated with rights, duties, and participation in governance. It connects individuals to the polis, or city-state, defining their role within the community and shaping their involvement in political life, which is crucial for understanding both historical and contemporary governance structures.
City-state: A city-state is a sovereign political entity that consists of a city and its surrounding territory, functioning independently with its own government and laws. This concept is crucial in understanding the development of political organization in ancient Greece, where these entities formed the foundation of social, economic, and political life, fostering a sense of citizenship and community among their inhabitants.
Civic virtue: Civic virtue refers to the moral responsibility of citizens to actively participate in their community and contribute to the common good. This concept emphasizes that individuals should prioritize the welfare of the polis over personal interests, fostering a sense of belonging and duty towards one's community. Civic virtue is essential for the health of a democratic society, as it encourages engagement and promotes ethical behavior among citizens.
Common good: The common good refers to the benefits and interests shared by a community as a whole, which promotes the welfare of all its members. It emphasizes collective well-being and suggests that individuals can achieve their own good by contributing to the greater good of society. This concept is crucial for understanding how individuals relate to the state and each other, particularly in the context of citizenship, governance, justice, and education.
Democracy: Democracy is a system of government in which power is vested in the people, who exercise that power directly or through elected representatives. In Ancient Greece, democracy was a groundbreaking development that fostered civic participation and shaped political identity, particularly in city-states like Athens. This form of governance contrasted with earlier monarchies and oligarchies, emphasizing the role of citizens in decision-making processes and the importance of political equality.
Full citizen: A full citizen is an individual who possesses complete legal rights and responsibilities within a polis, participating actively in its political life. This status typically includes the ability to vote, hold public office, and engage in civic duties, distinguishing them from non-citizens or residents who lack such rights. Full citizenship is central to the concept of the polis, as it emphasizes active participation in governance and the shared responsibilities that bind members of the community together.
Greek city-states: Greek city-states, or 'poleis', were independent, self-governing communities that emerged in ancient Greece around the 8th century BCE. Each polis consisted of a central urban area and its surrounding countryside, functioning as a political, economic, and cultural hub where citizens participated in governance and public life. The unique structure of the city-states fostered a sense of identity among citizens and laid the groundwork for concepts of democracy and citizenship.
Justice: Justice refers to the moral and legal principles that govern fairness, equality, and the proper administration of laws within a society. It encompasses the idea of giving each individual their due, whether in terms of rights, resources, or treatment, and is crucial for maintaining social order and harmony in the community. In the context of a polis, justice is central to citizenship, as it dictates how citizens interact, share responsibilities, and fulfill their roles in governance.
Metics: Metics were resident aliens in ancient Athens who did not have full citizenship rights but contributed to the economic and cultural life of the polis. Although they were not born Athenians, metics were often skilled workers or merchants and played a vital role in Athenian society, significantly impacting trade and crafts. Their unique status highlights the distinctions between citizenship and residency within the structure of the polis.
Monarchy: Monarchy is a form of government in which a single individual, the monarch, holds absolute or symbolic authority over a state, typically through hereditary succession. This system is characterized by the concentration of power in one person, where the monarch's role can vary significantly from absolute rule to constitutional frameworks where their powers are limited. Monarchy also reflects the cultural and social values of a society, influencing concepts of citizenship and governance.
Nicomachean Ethics: Nicomachean Ethics is a philosophical text by Aristotle that explores the nature of ethical virtue and the path to achieving a good life, which he defines as eudaimonia or human flourishing. The work emphasizes the importance of character, moral virtue, and the role of reason in achieving happiness, connecting these ideas to the broader context of human society and individual purpose.
Oligarchy: Oligarchy is a form of government in which power is held by a small group of individuals or families, often distinguished by wealth, social status, or political influence. This concentration of power can lead to a system where the interests of the few outweigh those of the many, raising questions about representation and justice within the community. The concept is important for understanding different governance structures and their implications for citizenship and the common good.
Polis: The polis is a fundamental concept in ancient Greek society, referring to a city-state that served as an independent political entity. Each polis was characterized by its own government, laws, and customs, fostering a strong sense of community among its citizens. This notion of the polis shaped not only political structures but also social and cultural life, as it emphasized active citizenship and civic engagement.
Political participation: Political participation refers to the ways in which individuals engage in the political process to influence decisions and policies that affect their community and society. This can include voting, activism, attending public meetings, and other forms of civic engagement. The nature of political participation is crucial to understanding citizenship, as it reflects the relationship between individuals and the polis, where active involvement is often seen as a duty of citizens.
Politics: Politics refers to the activities, actions, and policies that are used to gain and hold power in a government or to influence the behavior of people within a society. It is deeply connected to the organization of communities and the principles that guide human interactions, making it a crucial aspect of understanding the nature of governance, citizenship, and justice.
Public good: A public good is a type of commodity that is made available to all members of a society, which is characterized by non-excludability and non-rivalry. This means that no one can be effectively excluded from using the good, and one person's use does not diminish another's ability to use it. Understanding public goods is essential for grasping how communities function and how citizens engage in the governance of their polis, as well as how ethical considerations are vital in the art of persuasion.
The good life: The good life refers to a state of flourishing and fulfillment that is achieved through virtuous living, meaningful relationships, and the pursuit of knowledge. It emphasizes the importance of living in accordance with reason and virtue within the context of a community, suggesting that personal happiness is intertwined with the well-being of society as a whole.
Virtue: Virtue refers to a trait or quality deemed morally good and is a fundamental aspect of human character in Aristotle's philosophy. It emphasizes the importance of developing good habits and dispositions that lead to moral excellence, enabling individuals to achieve their ultimate purpose or 'telos'. Virtue connects to various aspects of life, including ethical behavior, community engagement, governance, and the appreciation of art.