10.5 Intertemporal choice and hyperbolic discounting
4 min read•august 16, 2024
examines how we make decisions involving costs and benefits at different times. It's key to understanding saving, spending, and investing behaviors, with and discount rates playing crucial roles in shaping our choices.
challenges traditional economic models by showing we value immediate rewards more strongly than future ones. This explains behaviors like procrastination and impulsive spending, and has important implications for personal finance and policy-making.
Intertemporal Choice in Economics
Time-Based Decision Making
Top images from around the web for Time-Based Decision Making
Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Time-Based Decision Making
Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Impact of Consumers’ Choice Deferral Behavior on Their Intertemporal Choice ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Individual Differences in Intertemporal Choice View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Intertemporal choice involves tradeoffs between costs and benefits occurring at different points in time
- Fundamental to understanding individual decisions about saving, spending, and investing across various time horizons
- Time preferences reflect how individuals value present versus future consumption
- represents the rate at which future values are discounted to present values in intertemporal choice models
- Applies to various economic behaviors (retirement planning, education investments, long-term financial decisions)
- Closely related to and over time
Key Components of Intertemporal Choice
- calculates the current worth of a future sum of money given a specified rate of return
- determines the value of a current asset at a specified date in the future based on an assumed growth rate
- considers the potential returns foregone by choosing one option over another
- Risk and uncertainty factor into decisions involving future outcomes
- influences the willingness to hold cash versus other assets
- affects the weight given to short-term versus long-term consequences
Hyperbolic vs Exponential Discounting
Characteristics of Hyperbolic Discounting
- Time-inconsistent model where discount rate decreases over time
- Stronger preference for immediate payoffs when choosing between near-term options compared to long-term options
- Discount function characterized by steep initial decline followed by gradual decrease
- Can lead to as time to decision approaches
- Better explains observed human behavior in various economic contexts (procrastination, self-control problems)
- Challenges assumption of time consistency in traditional economic models
Comparison with Exponential Discounting
- assumes constant discount rate over time
- Hyperbolic discounting results in higher discount rates for near-term periods compared to exponential discounting
- Exponential discounting maintains time consistency, while hyperbolic allows for changing preferences
- Hyperbolic model often provides better fit to empirical data on intertemporal choice
- Exponential discounting aligns with rational choice theory, while hyperbolic incorporates behavioral insights
- Mathematical representations differ: hyperbolic uses hyperbolic functions, exponential uses exponential functions
Implications of Hyperbolic Discounting
Financial Decision Making
- Can lead to undersaving due to undervaluing future benefits relative to present consumption
- Explains difficulty in sticking to long-term financial plans (retirement savings, debt repayment)
- May result in preference for short-term gains over potentially larger long-term returns in investments
- Affects consumption patterns, leading to impulsive spending or choosing smaller immediate rewards
- Contributes to time-inconsistent preferences, causing conflicts between short-term desires and long-term goals
- Explains effectiveness of (automatic savings plans, self-imposed penalties) in promoting long-term financial well-being
Behavioral Consequences
- Helps understand procrastination in tasks with future benefits but immediate costs (studying, exercise)
- Explains addiction and behaviors involving immediate gratification at expense of future well-being
- Can lead to cyclical behavior patterns (dieting followed by overeating)
- Influences career choices, potentially favoring jobs with immediate rewards over long-term growth potential
- Affects decision-making in healthcare (preventive care, medication adherence)
- Impacts environmental choices, potentially undervaluing long-term sustainability for short-term convenience
Policy Implications of Intertemporal Choice
Retirement and Financial Planning
- Supports policies encouraging early and consistent retirement savings (automatic enrollment in pension plans)
- Justifies design of commitment devices in public policy (locked savings accounts, cooling-off periods for major financial decisions)
- Informs development of financial literacy programs incorporating insights from hyperbolic discounting research
- Suggests need for policies addressing undersaving (matching contributions, tax incentives)
- Supports implementation of default options favoring long-term financial health in retirement plans
- Encourages development of apps and tools leveraging behavioral insights to promote better financial planning
Environmental and Public Health Policies
- Environmental conservation policies may need to account for undervaluing of future benefits
- Justifies stronger present-day regulations or incentives for environmental protection
- Informs design of public health campaigns, particularly for reducing behaviors with long-term negative consequences
- Climate change policies may need to emphasize short-term co-benefits to overcome discounting of long-term impacts
- Supports implementation of immediate rewards for environmentally friendly behaviors (tax rebates for electric vehicles)
- Suggests framing of public health messages to highlight near-term benefits of healthy behaviors
Key Terms to Review (21)
Actual savings rates: Actual savings rates refer to the proportion of disposable income that households save rather than spend on consumption. This concept is crucial in understanding how individuals make decisions over time, balancing current consumption against future benefits, and relates closely to ideas of intertemporal choice and hyperbolic discounting, where present bias affects saving behavior and consumption patterns.
Commitment devices: Commitment devices are tools or strategies that help individuals stick to their long-term goals by restricting their future choices. These devices are used to counteract tendencies like procrastination and impulsive decision-making, often seen in intertemporal choices. By making certain future actions more difficult or costly, commitment devices help align short-term behavior with long-term objectives, particularly when preferences change over time.
Daniel Kahneman: Daniel Kahneman is a psychologist who is best known for his work in behavioral economics, particularly regarding how psychological factors influence economic decision-making. His groundbreaking research, particularly on prospect theory and cognitive biases, highlights the systematic ways in which people's judgments deviate from rationality, shaping our understanding of risk, loss aversion, and decision-making under uncertainty.
Discount rate: The discount rate is the interest rate used to determine the present value of future cash flows, reflecting the time preference for money. It plays a crucial role in intertemporal choice, as individuals and businesses weigh the value of immediate benefits against future gains. A higher discount rate implies a greater preference for immediate rewards, while a lower rate suggests a willingness to wait for larger future benefits.
Experiment results on discount rates: Experiment results on discount rates refer to findings from studies that investigate how individuals value future rewards compared to immediate ones. These experiments reveal patterns in decision-making that often show people tend to prefer smaller, immediate rewards over larger, delayed ones, leading to insights into behaviors related to intertemporal choice and hyperbolic discounting.
Exponential Discounting: Exponential discounting is a method used in economics to represent how individuals value future rewards or benefits compared to immediate ones. It suggests that people perceive the value of future gains to decrease exponentially over time, leading to a consistent choice pattern where the present value of future outcomes is determined by a discount factor. This concept plays a crucial role in understanding intertemporal choice, where decisions are made considering trade-offs between costs and benefits occurring at different times.
Future Value: Future value is the amount of money that an investment made today will grow to at a specified point in the future, taking into account a specific interest rate over time. This concept is crucial for understanding how individuals make decisions about savings and investments, as it illustrates the benefits of delaying consumption for potential greater returns in the future.
Hyperbolic Discounting: Hyperbolic discounting is a behavioral economics concept that describes how individuals value rewards over time, often showing a preference for immediate gratification over future benefits. This model suggests that people tend to discount the value of future rewards at a decreasing rate, leading to inconsistent decision-making when faced with choices involving delayed outcomes. Unlike exponential discounting, which assumes a constant rate of time preference, hyperbolic discounting illustrates a more realistic view of human behavior, particularly in intertemporal choices.
Intertemporal choice: Intertemporal choice refers to the decision-making process where individuals consider trade-offs between costs and benefits occurring at different times. This concept highlights how people value immediate rewards versus future gains, often influenced by their discount rates, which dictate how much they devalue future outcomes compared to the present. Understanding intertemporal choice is crucial for analyzing consumer behavior, savings, investments, and consumption patterns over time.
Liquidity Preference: Liquidity preference is the demand for money or liquid assets over non-liquid investments, driven by the desire for immediate access to funds. This concept highlights individuals' preferences for holding cash or easily convertible assets rather than tying up their wealth in long-term investments. It plays a crucial role in intertemporal choice and hyperbolic discounting, where people's time preferences influence their saving and spending behaviors.
Opportunity Cost: Opportunity cost refers to the value of the next best alternative that is forgone when a choice is made. This concept is central to understanding economic decision-making, as it helps individuals and businesses evaluate trade-offs and make informed choices about resource allocation.
Patience vs Impulsivity: Patience refers to the ability to delay gratification and wait for a more favorable outcome, while impulsivity involves making quick decisions without considering the long-term consequences. This concept is significant in understanding how individuals make choices over time, as it highlights the contrast between immediate rewards and future benefits, especially when evaluating options that have delayed payoffs.
Preference reversals: Preference reversals refer to a phenomenon where individuals change their preferences between options when the context or method of evaluation is altered, leading to inconsistent decision-making. This inconsistency can often be attributed to factors like framing effects and cognitive biases, which challenge the assumption of stable preferences in economic theory.
Present Value: Present value is the current worth of a sum of money that is to be received or paid in the future, discounted back to the present using a specific interest rate. This concept helps individuals and businesses make informed decisions about investments and expenditures over time by illustrating how future cash flows compare to current amounts. It plays a crucial role in intertemporal choice, allowing for the evaluation of benefits or costs that occur at different times, and helps in understanding behaviors like hyperbolic discounting, where people might place disproportionately higher value on immediate rewards compared to future ones.
Rational Choice Theory: Rational choice theory is a framework for understanding and modeling social and economic behavior, positing that individuals make decisions by weighing the expected benefits against the costs in a logical and systematic way. This theory assumes that people are rational actors who seek to maximize their utility based on their preferences, which can significantly influence choices over time, especially in contexts like saving or consumption decisions.
Richard Thaler: Richard Thaler is a prominent American economist known for his groundbreaking work in behavioral economics, particularly focusing on how psychological factors influence economic decision-making. He is recognized for developing concepts such as mental accounting and the endowment effect, which explain why individuals often deviate from traditional economic theories that assume rational behavior.
Short-run vs long-run preferences: Short-run vs long-run preferences refer to the differences in how individuals value present versus future consumption or benefits. In the short run, people often prioritize immediate gratification and may choose options that yield quick rewards, while in the long run, they tend to consider the overall benefits and may opt for choices that lead to greater future satisfaction.
Time Horizon: Time horizon refers to the length of time over which decisions and their consequences are evaluated, particularly in the context of intertemporal choice. It influences how individuals prioritize present versus future benefits, shaping their consumption, savings, and investment decisions. Understanding time horizons is essential for analyzing behaviors related to discounting future utility and assessing the implications of hyperbolic discounting.
Time inconsistency: Time inconsistency refers to the situation where a decision-maker's preferences change over time in such a way that what is considered optimal at one point becomes suboptimal at a later time. This often occurs in scenarios involving intertemporal choice, where individuals must decide how to allocate resources over different time periods. The concept is crucial for understanding behaviors that lead to hyperbolic discounting, where individuals disproportionately favor immediate rewards over future benefits.
Time Preferences: Time preferences refer to the relative valuation individuals place on receiving goods or services at different points in time, influencing their decision-making regarding consumption, savings, and investments. This concept highlights how people may favor immediate rewards over future ones, affecting their behavior in various economic situations such as intertemporal choices and negotiations.
Utility Maximization: Utility maximization is the process by which consumers allocate their resources in a way that maximizes their overall satisfaction or utility from consuming goods and services. This concept highlights how individuals make choices based on their preferences and budget constraints, striving to achieve the highest possible level of satisfaction given their limited resources. Understanding this concept helps illustrate how consumers navigate scarcity and make decisions that reflect their priorities and trade-offs.