6.4 Convertible securities
10 min read•august 21, 2024
Convertible securities are complex financial instruments that blend characteristics of debt and equity. They offer companies flexible financing options while providing investors potential upside. This topic explores the nature, accounting, and valuation of convertibles, as well as their impact on financial statements and earnings per share.
Understanding convertible securities is crucial in Intermediate Financial Accounting 2. We'll examine different types of convertibles, their key features, and the advantages and disadvantages for both issuers and investors. We'll also dive into the intricate accounting treatments and valuation methods used for these hybrid instruments.
Nature of convertible securities
- Convertible securities represent hybrid financial instruments combining debt or preferred stock with an embedded option to convert into common stock
- Provide flexibility for both issuers and investors, allowing companies to raise capital while offering potential upside to investors
- Play a significant role in corporate finance and investment strategies within the scope of Intermediate Financial Accounting 2
Types of convertible securities
Top images from around the web for Types of convertible securities
Pricing contingent convertible bonds in African banks View original
Is this image relevant?
Convertible Securities | Boundless Finance View original
Is this image relevant?
Let's learn about Convertible Note — Pavan Mirla View original
Is this image relevant?
Pricing contingent convertible bonds in African banks View original
Is this image relevant?
Convertible Securities | Boundless Finance View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Types of convertible securities
Pricing contingent convertible bonds in African banks View original
Is this image relevant?
Convertible Securities | Boundless Finance View original
Is this image relevant?
Let's learn about Convertible Note — Pavan Mirla View original
Is this image relevant?
Pricing contingent convertible bonds in African banks View original
Is this image relevant?
Convertible Securities | Boundless Finance View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- allow bondholders to exchange debt for a predetermined number of common shares
- gives holders the option to convert preferred shares into common stock
- automatically convert to common stock on a specified future date
- (CoCos) convert based on certain trigger events (falling below capital ratio thresholds)
Key features of convertibles
- determines the number of common shares received upon conversion
- sets the effective price per share at which the security can be converted
- represents the amount the conversion price exceeds current market price
- allow issuers to force conversion or redeem the securities early
- give investors the right to sell the securities back to the issuer at specified times
Advantages and disadvantages
- Advantages for issuers
- compared to straight debt
- Potential to avoid dilution if stock price doesn't rise enough for conversion
- Ability to attract investors seeking both income and growth potential
- Disadvantages for issuers
- of existing shareholders if converted
- Complex accounting treatment and valuation
- May limit future financing flexibility
- Advantages for investors
- Downside protection of debt with upside potential of equity
- Higher yield than common stock
- Conversion option provides built-in hedge against stock price increases
- Disadvantages for investors
- Lower yield than straight debt
- Limited upside compared to common stock if conversion doesn't occur
- Complexity in valuation and tax treatment
Accounting for convertible debt
- Convertible debt accounting involves complex considerations for initial recognition, subsequent measurement, and interest expense recognition
- Proper treatment impacts financial statement presentation and key metrics like earnings per share
- Understanding these accounting principles is crucial for accurately reporting and analyzing convertible securities in Intermediate Financial Accounting 2
Initial recognition
- Record convertible debt at fair value upon issuance
- Allocate proceeds between liability and equity components if separately accounted for
- Apply the with-and-without method to determine the value of the
- Consider transaction costs and allocate between debt and equity components
- Record any beneficial conversion feature as additional paid-in capital
Subsequent measurement
- Carry liability component at amortized cost using the effective interest method
- Do not remeasure equity component after initial recognition
- Assess for potential impairment of the debt component
- Evaluate for embedded derivatives requiring separate accounting treatment
- Adjust carrying amount for any modifications to the conversion terms
Interest expense recognition
- Recognize interest expense using the effective interest method
- Calculate effective interest rate based on the liability component's initial carrying amount
- Accrete the carrying amount of the liability component over time
- Record the difference between coupon interest and effective interest as additional interest expense
- Adjust interest expense for any changes in estimated cash flows
Conversion of convertible securities
- Conversion process transforms convertible securities into common stock based on predetermined terms
- Accounting at conversion date requires careful consideration of carrying values and fair market values
- Impacts various financial statement elements, affecting both balance sheet and income statement presentations
Conversion process
- Triggered by issuer call, investor put, or reaching maturity date
- Calculate number of shares issued based on conversion ratio or formula
- Determine any cash payments for fractional shares or accrued interest
- Verify compliance with conversion notice requirements and deadlines
- Execute the exchange of securities for common stock
Accounting at conversion date
- Remove carrying value of the liability component from the balance sheet
- Recognize the par value of newly issued common shares
- Record any difference between liability carrying value and par value as additional paid-in capital
- Transfer the carrying value of the equity component to additional paid-in capital
- Adjust for any unamortized issuance costs or discounts/premiums
Impact on financial statements
- Balance sheet effects
- Increase in common stock and additional paid-in capital
- Decrease in long-term debt or preferred stock
- Potential change in working capital ratios
- Income statement considerations
- No gain or loss recognized on conversion under the book value method
- Potential earnings per share dilution
- Cessation of interest or preferred dividend expenses
- Cash flow statement implications
- Classification of conversion as non-cash financing activity
- Potential tax effects on cash flows from operations
Valuation of convertible securities
- Valuation of convertible securities involves complex methodologies to determine fair value and allocate between components
- Accurate valuation is crucial for proper accounting treatment and financial reporting in Intermediate Financial Accounting 2
- Different approaches may be required depending on the specific features of the convertible instrument
Components approach
- Separate valuation of debt and equity components
- Determine standalone value of the debt component using market interest rates for similar non-convertible debt
- Calculate equity component as the residual between total fair value and debt component value
- Consider any embedded derivatives requiring separate valuation
- Apply appropriate valuation techniques (Black-Scholes, binomial model) for the conversion option
Fair value method
- Measure entire convertible instrument at fair value
- Use quoted market prices if available in an active market
- Apply valuation techniques (discounted cash flow, option pricing models) when market prices are unavailable
- Consider both observable and unobservable inputs in fair value hierarchy
- Recognize changes in fair value through profit or loss each reporting period
Effective interest method
- Calculate effective interest rate based on expected cash flows over the instrument's life
- Amortize any discount or premium using the effective interest rate
- Periodically reassess expected cash flows and adjust carrying amount if necessary
- Recognize interest expense based on the instrument's carrying amount and effective interest rate
- Account for any changes in conversion terms as a modification or extinguishment
Diluted earnings per share
- Convertible securities significantly impact (EPS) calculations
- Proper treatment of potential common shares is crucial for accurate financial reporting and analysis
- Understanding these concepts is essential in Intermediate Financial Accounting 2 for evaluating a company's performance and shareholder value
Impact on EPS calculations
- Diluted EPS reflects potential dilution from convertible securities and other dilutive instruments
- Convertible securities increase the denominator (weighted average shares outstanding) in EPS calculations
- Adjustments to the numerator (net income) may be required for interest expense or preferred dividends
- Apply the "if-converted" method for convertible debt and preferred stock
- Use the treasury stock method for convertible securities with a cash settlement option
If-converted method
- Assume conversion at the beginning of the period or date of issuance, if later
- Add back after-tax interest expense or preferred dividends to the numerator
- Increase the denominator by the number of potential common shares from conversion
- Apply only if the effect is dilutive (reduces EPS or increases loss per share)
- Consider partial-period conversions and weighted average calculations
Contingent share agreements
- Include contingently issuable shares in diluted EPS if conditions are met at the end of the reporting period
- Use the treasury stock method for contingent shares dependent on future stock prices
- Apply the reverse treasury stock method for contingently redeemable shares
- Consider performance-based contingencies and their probability of achievement
- Exclude contingent shares from basic EPS until all necessary conditions are satisfied
Disclosure requirements
- Proper disclosure of convertible securities is essential for transparent financial reporting
- Intermediate Financial Accounting 2 emphasizes the importance of comprehensive and clear disclosures
- Disclosures provide crucial information for investors and analysts to assess the impact of convertible instruments
Balance sheet presentation
- Present convertible debt as a separate line item within liabilities
- Classify as current or non-current based on maturity date or conversion options
- Disclose carrying amounts of liability and equity components separately
- Include fair value information for convertible instruments not measured at fair value
- Present any embedded derivatives separately if required by accounting standards
Income statement effects
- Disclose interest expense related to convertible debt
- Separate presentation of contractual interest and additional interest from accretion
- Include any fair value changes for instruments measured at fair value through profit or loss
- Disclose the impact on earnings per share, including potential dilution
- Present any gains or losses from early extinguishment or modification
Notes to financial statements
- Describe key terms and conditions of convertible securities
- Disclose conversion prices, ratios, and dates
- Explain any call or put provisions and their potential impacts
- Provide details on valuation methods and significant assumptions used
- Include a schedule of maturities and future minimum payments
- Discuss any covenant compliance issues or restrictions
Tax implications
- Tax treatment of convertible securities varies between issuers and investors
- Understanding tax implications is crucial for proper accounting and financial decision-making
- Intermediate Financial Accounting 2 covers the interplay between tax and financial reporting for these complex instruments
Tax treatment for issuers
- Interest payments on convertible debt are generally tax-deductible
- No tax deduction for the equity component of convertible instruments
- Potential tax implications of debt discounts or premiums
- Consider tax effects of any beneficial conversion features
- Tax treatment of conversion may differ from book treatment (potential taxable gain or loss)
Tax considerations for investors
- Interest income from convertible bonds typically taxed as ordinary income
- Potential for capital gains or losses upon sale or conversion
- Tax treatment of original issue discount (OID) for deeply discounted convertibles
- Implications of market discount for convertibles purchased below par
- Potential application of the constructive ownership rules for certain convertible securities
Convertible preferred stock
- Convertible preferred stock shares characteristics with both debt and equity instruments
- Accounting treatment differs from convertible debt in several key aspects
- Understanding these differences is important for proper financial reporting and analysis in Intermediate Financial Accounting 2
Similarities vs convertible debt
- Both offer conversion option into common stock
- Provide fixed income stream (dividends vs interest) prior to conversion
- May include call and put provisions
- Impact diluted earnings per share calculations
- Require allocation between equity and liability components in some cases
Accounting differences
- Classification as equity rather than liability on the balance sheet
- No interest expense recognition (dividends reduce retained earnings when declared)
- Conversion doesn't typically result in gain or loss recognition
- Different tax treatment (dividends not tax-deductible for issuer)
- Potential for cumulative dividend features
EPS implications
- Include convertible preferred dividends in the numerator for basic EPS
- Apply if-converted method for diluted EPS calculations
- Consider participating preferred stock in two-class method for EPS
- Evaluate potential antidilution from conversion of preferred to common
- Account for any redemption or induced conversion features in EPS calculations
Complex convertible instruments
- Complex convertible instruments incorporate additional features beyond basic conversion options
- These instruments require specialized accounting treatment and valuation techniques
- Understanding complex convertibles is crucial for advanced topics in Intermediate Financial Accounting 2
Contingent conversion features
- Conversion triggered by specific events (stock price thresholds, financial metrics)
- Evaluate for embedded derivatives requiring separate accounting
- Consider probability of contingent events in valuation and EPS calculations
- Assess impact on classification as liability or equity
- Disclose terms and potential effects of contingent conversion features
Beneficial conversion features
- Occurs when conversion price is below fair value of common stock at issuance
- Record as a discount to the convertible instrument with offset to additional paid-in capital
- Amortize discount over the life of the instrument or until conversion
- Consider in diluted EPS calculations from commitment date
- Evaluate for any subsequent modifications or adjustments to conversion terms
Embedded derivatives
- Identify potential embedded derivatives (conversion options, put/call features)
- Determine if embedded derivatives require bifurcation and separate accounting
- Apply relevant valuation techniques (Black-Scholes, Monte Carlo simulation)
- Account for changes in fair value of separated derivatives through earnings
- Consider implications for hedge accounting and risk management strategies
International accounting standards
- Differences exist between IFRS and US GAAP in the treatment of convertible securities
- Understanding these differences is crucial for global financial reporting and analysis
- Intermediate Financial Accounting 2 emphasizes the importance of international accounting standards convergence
IFRS vs US GAAP
- IFRS requires separate accounting for equity component in most cases
- US GAAP allows for entire instrument to be classified as debt in certain circumstances
- Different models for determining whether conversion feature requires bifurcation
- Variation in treatment of beneficial conversion features
- Differences in fair value option application and measurement
Key differences in treatment
- Classification of instruments as liability or equity
- Measurement of equity component (residual approach vs with-and-without method)
- Treatment of transaction costs (allocation between components vs expensing)
- Accounting for modifications and extinguishments
- Earnings per share calculations and presentation requirements
Key Terms to Review (21)
Allocation of proceeds: Allocation of proceeds refers to the process of distributing funds received from financial transactions, such as the issuance of securities, among various accounts or purposes. This is particularly relevant in complex financial arrangements where multiple instruments or equity classes may be involved, requiring careful consideration to determine how much of the proceeds will be allocated to each component based on specific terms and conditions.
Asc 470-20: ASC 470-20 is a section of the Accounting Standards Codification that provides guidance on accounting for convertible debt. This standard outlines how to recognize, measure, and disclose convertible securities, ensuring that companies accurately represent these financial instruments in their financial statements. The standard's focus on convertible debt helps clarify how these instruments impact both the company's liabilities and equity, which is crucial for investors and stakeholders assessing the company's financial health.
Call Provisions: Call provisions are clauses in a bond or preferred stock contract that allow the issuer to repurchase the security at a predetermined price before its maturity date. This feature is beneficial for issuers if interest rates decline, as it permits them to refinance their debt at a lower cost. Investors should be aware that call provisions can affect the yield and market value of these securities, as they introduce reinvestment risk.
Contingent Convertibles: Contingent convertibles, often referred to as CoCos, are hybrid financial instruments that can be converted from debt into equity upon the occurrence of specific events or triggers, usually related to the financial health of the issuing institution. These instruments are designed to absorb losses in times of financial distress, providing a buffer for banks during periods of capital strain, and are a significant component of regulatory frameworks in banking.
Conversion feature: The conversion feature is a provision in certain financial securities, such as convertible bonds or convertible preferred stock, that allows the holder to convert their security into a predetermined number of shares of common stock at specific times and under defined conditions. This feature is attractive to investors because it provides the potential for capital appreciation while still offering fixed-income characteristics, such as interest or dividends.
Conversion premium: The conversion premium is the amount by which the market price of a convertible security exceeds its conversion value, which is the value of the underlying common stock that the security can be converted into. This premium reflects the additional value investors are willing to pay for the flexibility and potential benefits of converting their securities into equity, rather than simply holding them as bonds or preferred shares.
Conversion price: The conversion price is the predetermined price at which a convertible security, like a bond or preferred stock, can be exchanged for shares of common stock. This price is crucial as it influences the decision of investors on whether to convert their securities into equity based on the current market value of the company's stock. Understanding the conversion price helps investors evaluate potential returns and assess the overall attractiveness of investing in convertible securities.
Conversion Ratio: The conversion ratio is a financial metric that indicates the number of shares of common stock that can be obtained for each unit of a convertible security, such as convertible bonds or preferred shares. This ratio is crucial as it helps investors understand the potential dilution of their equity stake and the profitability of converting their securities into stock, particularly in the context of market price movements and company performance.
Convertible bonds: Convertible bonds are hybrid debt securities that give bondholders the option to convert their bonds into a predetermined number of shares of the issuing company's stock. This feature allows investors to benefit from potential equity upside while still receiving fixed interest payments until conversion. The ability to convert enhances the appeal of these bonds, especially in complex capital structures, as they can impact earnings per share calculations and provide strategic financing options for companies.
Convertible preferred stock: Convertible preferred stock is a type of equity security that gives investors the right to convert their preferred shares into a predetermined number of common shares, usually at the discretion of the shareholder. This financial instrument offers the benefits of both fixed income and potential equity appreciation, making it attractive for investors who seek regular dividends while also wanting to participate in potential stock price increases.
Diluted earnings per share: Diluted earnings per share (EPS) measures a company's profitability on a per-share basis while accounting for all potential dilution that could occur from convertible securities, stock options, and other financial instruments. This metric provides a more conservative view of earnings available to shareholders because it assumes that all convertible securities are converted into common shares, which can affect the overall earnings allocated to each share.
Embedded Derivative: An embedded derivative is a component of a hybrid financial instrument that includes both a host contract and an additional derivative feature, allowing the holder to benefit from changes in the underlying asset's value. This dual nature means that the derivative portion can be separated and accounted for independently from the host contract, often impacting financial reporting and analysis significantly.
Fair Value Measurement: Fair value measurement refers to the process of determining the price at which an asset could be bought or sold in a current transaction between willing parties. It is crucial for financial reporting as it provides a more accurate picture of an entity's financial position and performance, especially when dealing with complex financial instruments and capital structures.
IFRS 9: IFRS 9 is an International Financial Reporting Standard that addresses the accounting for financial instruments. It establishes principles for recognizing and measuring financial assets and liabilities, which are crucial for understanding how entities assess risks and manage their financial reporting in relation to convertible securities, hedges, and derivatives.
Impairment Testing: Impairment testing is a process used to determine whether an asset's carrying amount exceeds its recoverable amount, indicating that the asset may be impaired and should be written down. This is crucial for maintaining accurate financial reporting and ensuring that assets are not overstated on the balance sheet. Impairment testing involves evaluating both tangible and intangible assets, including goodwill, to ensure they are appropriately valued and that any potential loss in value is recognized in a timely manner.
Lower interest rates: Lower interest rates refer to a reduction in the cost of borrowing money, which can stimulate economic activity by making loans more affordable for consumers and businesses. This concept is closely linked to monetary policy and can influence the demand for convertible securities, as investors seek higher returns when traditional fixed-income investments become less attractive due to lower yields.
Mandatory Convertibles: Mandatory convertibles are hybrid securities that must be converted into equity at a predetermined time or under specific conditions, typically within a few years after issuance. This type of security combines features of both debt and equity, offering investors fixed interest payments while also providing the potential for equity ownership in the issuing company upon conversion. These securities often appeal to investors looking for lower-risk investments with the opportunity for capital appreciation.
Market value: Market value is the price at which an asset or security would trade in a competitive auction setting. It reflects the collective opinion of investors about the value of an asset, considering factors like demand, supply, and future growth prospects. Understanding market value is crucial for assessing investment opportunities, as it provides insight into whether an asset is under or overvalued based on its perceived worth in the market.
Potential dilution: Potential dilution refers to the decrease in existing shareholders' ownership percentage in a company that may occur if convertible securities are converted into common stock. This situation arises when investors exercise their rights to convert these securities, leading to an increase in the total number of shares outstanding. The impact of potential dilution is particularly significant because it can affect both the voting power of existing shareholders and the value of their investment.
Put Options: Put options are financial contracts that give the holder the right, but not the obligation, to sell a specified amount of an underlying asset at a predetermined price within a specific time period. They are commonly used as a risk management tool to protect against declines in the value of an investment. Investors utilize put options to hedge against potential losses in their portfolios or to speculate on downward price movements.
Yield to Maturity: Yield to maturity (YTM) is the total expected return on a bond if it is held until it matures, expressed as an annual percentage. It incorporates all future coupon payments and the difference between the purchase price and the face value at maturity, making it a comprehensive measure of a bond's potential profitability. Understanding YTM is crucial when evaluating fixed-income investments like bonds, especially those that can be converted into equity.