Fiveable

๐ŸงFunctional Analysis Unit 10 Review

QR code for Functional Analysis practice questions

10.1 Bidual spaces and natural embeddings

10.1 Bidual spaces and natural embeddings

Written by the Fiveable Content Team โ€ข Last updated August 2025
Written by the Fiveable Content Team โ€ข Last updated August 2025
๐ŸงFunctional Analysis
Unit & Topic Study Guides

Bidual spaces take us on a journey through layers of linear functionals. We start with a normed space, create its dual of continuous linear functionals, then form the bidual of functionals on functionals. This process reveals deep connections between spaces.

Reflexivity is a key concept in this exploration. A space is reflexive if it's isomorphic to its bidual, meaning they're essentially the same. Non-reflexive spaces, however, have biduals that are strictly larger, showcasing the complexity of functional analysis.

Bidual Spaces

Construction of bidual spaces

  • Start with a normed linear space XX (Banach spaces, Hilbert spaces)
  • Form the dual space Xโˆ—X^* consisting of all continuous linear functionals on XX
    • Continuous linear functionals map elements of XX to scalars while preserving linearity and continuity
  • Construct the bidual space Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**} as the dual space of Xโˆ—X^*
    • Elements of Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**} are continuous linear functionals on Xโˆ—X^*, assigning scalars to functionals
  • Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**} is called the "dual of the dual" or "functionals on functionals"
    • Functionals in Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**} take functionals from Xโˆ—X^* as input and output scalar values
Construction of bidual spaces, Normals and the Inverse Transpose, Part 2: Dual Spaces โ€“ Nathan Reedโ€™s coding blog

Natural embedding and bidual relations

  • Define the natural embedding J:Xโ†’Xโˆ—โˆ—J: X \to X^{**} as J(x)(f)=f(x)J(x)(f) = f(x) for xโˆˆXx \in X and fโˆˆXโˆ—f \in X^*
    • JJ maps elements of XX to elements of Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**}
  • JJ is a linear map preserving the norm: โˆฅJ(x)โˆฅ=โˆฅxโˆฅ\|J(x)\| = \|x\| for all xโˆˆXx \in X
  • JJ is always injective (one-to-one), embedding XX into Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**}
    • Allows viewing XX as a subspace of its bidual Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**}
  • Injectivity of JJ means distinct elements of XX map to distinct elements of Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**}
    • Ensures no information is lost when mapping from XX to Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**}
Construction of bidual spaces, Normals and the Inverse Transpose, Part 2: Dual Spaces โ€“ Nathan Reedโ€™s coding blog

Reflexive Spaces

Isomorphisms in reflexive spaces

  • A space XX is reflexive if the natural embedding J:Xโ†’Xโˆ—โˆ—J: X \to X^{**} is surjective (onto)
    • Every element of Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**} is the image of some element in XX under JJ
  • In reflexive spaces, JJ is an isometric isomorphism between XX and Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**}
    • JJ is bijective (one-to-one and onto) and preserves the norm
  • Proof of isometric isomorphism in reflexive spaces:
    1. JJ is surjective by the definition of reflexivity
    2. JJ is injective and norm-preserving for any space
    3. Combining surjectivity, injectivity, and norm-preservation, JJ is an isometric isomorphism
  • Reflexive spaces can be identified with their biduals via the isometric isomorphism JJ
    • XX and Xโˆ—โˆ—X^{**} are essentially the same space in the reflexive case

Non-reflexive spaces vs biduals

  • Examples of non-reflexive spaces:
    1. c0c_0: space of sequences converging to zero
      • Its bidual is โ„“โˆž\ell^{\infty}, the space of bounded sequences
    2. L1(R)L^1(\mathbb{R}): space of absolutely integrable functions on the real line
      • Its bidual is Lโˆž(R)L^{\infty}(\mathbb{R}), the space of essentially bounded functions
  • In non-reflexive spaces, the bidual is strictly larger than the original space
    • Natural embedding JJ is injective but not surjective
  • Non-reflexive spaces have elements in the bidual that do not correspond to any element in the original space
    • Demonstrates that not all spaces are isomorphic to their biduals
  • Non-reflexivity highlights the distinction between a space and its bidual
    • Bidual may contain additional elements not present in the original space