8.1 Principles of split-plot designs
3 min read•august 7, 2024
Split-plot designs are a powerful tool in experimental research, combining two factors with different sizes of experimental units. They're perfect when one factor is harder to change or apply than the other, allowing for efficient resource use and precise measurements.
These designs have a unique structure with and subplots, each with their own factors and randomization. This setup leads to two error terms and requires special analysis methods, but it offers valuable insights into and interactions between factors.
Experimental Units and Factors
Experimental Units and Levels
Top images from around the web for Experimental Units and Levels
partR2: partitioning R2 in generalized linear mixed models [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
2. Statistics foundations | Untitled View original
Is this image relevant?
experiment design - ANOVA table for 4-factor split-plot - Cross Validated View original
Is this image relevant?
partR2: partitioning R2 in generalized linear mixed models [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
2. Statistics foundations | Untitled View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Experimental Units and Levels
partR2: partitioning R2 in generalized linear mixed models [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
2. Statistics foundations | Untitled View original
Is this image relevant?
experiment design - ANOVA table for 4-factor split-plot - Cross Validated View original
Is this image relevant?
partR2: partitioning R2 in generalized linear mixed models [PeerJ] View original
Is this image relevant?
2. Statistics foundations | Untitled View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Whole plot experimental units are the larger units to which the levels of the whole plot factor are randomly assigned
- Subplot experimental units are the smaller units within each whole plot to which the levels of the subplot factor are randomly assigned
- Levels of the whole plot factor are randomly assigned to whole plots while levels of the subplot factor are randomly assigned to subplots within each whole plot
- Having two sizes of experimental units (whole plots and subplots) is a key characteristic of split-plot designs
Factors and Levels
- Whole plot factor is the factor whose levels are randomly assigned to the whole plots
- Levels of the whole plot factor are applied to the larger experimental units (whole plots)
- Example: In an agricultural experiment, the whole plot factor could be irrigation method (drip or sprinkler)
- Subplot factor is the factor whose levels are randomly assigned to the subplots within each whole plot
- Levels of the subplot factor are applied to the smaller experimental units (subplots) within each whole plot
- Example: In the same agricultural experiment, the subplot factor could be fertilizer type (organic or synthetic)
Design Structure
Restricted Randomization
- Split-plot designs involve restricted randomization where the randomization of the subplot factor is restricted within each whole plot
- Randomization occurs at two levels:
- Whole plot factor levels are randomly assigned to whole plots
- Subplot factor levels are randomly assigned to subplots within each whole plot
- This restricted randomization structure is a defining feature of split-plot designs and distinguishes them from other designs like randomized complete block designs
Hierarchical Structure and Error Terms
- Split-plot designs have a hierarchical structure with subplots nested within whole plots
- This hierarchical structure leads to two different error terms:
- Whole plot error: Variation among whole plots that have been assigned the same level of the whole plot factor
- Subplot error: Variation among subplots within a whole plot that have been assigned the same level of the subplot factor (also called split-plot error)
- Having two error terms is another key characteristic of split-plot designs and affects the analysis and interpretation of results
Effects
Main Effects
- In split-plot designs, there are two types of main effects:
- Main effect of the whole plot factor: Compares the mean responses between levels of the whole plot factor, averaged across all levels of the subplot factor
- Main effect of the subplot factor: Compares the mean responses between levels of the subplot factor, averaged across all levels of the whole plot factor
- Interpreting main effects in split-plot designs requires considering the hierarchical structure and error terms
- Example: The main effect of irrigation method would compare the mean yield between drip and sprinkler irrigation, averaged across both fertilizer types
Interaction Effects
- Interaction effect assesses whether the effect of one factor depends on the level of the other factor
- In split-plot designs, the interaction of interest is usually between the whole plot factor and the subplot factor
- Determines if the effect of the subplot factor is consistent across all levels of the whole plot factor, or if it varies depending on the whole plot factor level
- Interpreting requires examining the pattern of mean responses across all combinations of factor levels
- Example: A significant interaction between irrigation method and fertilizer type would suggest that the effect of fertilizer type on yield differs depending on whether drip or sprinkler irrigation is used
Key Terms to Review (17)
ANOVA: ANOVA, or Analysis of Variance, is a statistical method used to test differences between two or more group means. This technique helps determine if at least one of the group means is significantly different from the others, making it a powerful tool in experimental design for comparing multiple treatments or conditions.
Blocking: Blocking is a technique used in experimental design to reduce the impact of variability among experimental units by grouping similar units together. This method allows researchers to control for specific variables, ensuring that comparisons between treatment groups are more accurate and reliable. By minimizing extraneous variability, blocking can enhance the precision of the experiment and improve the validity of conclusions drawn from the data.
Confounding Variables: Confounding variables are extraneous factors that can obscure or distort the true relationship between the independent and dependent variables in an experiment. These variables can lead to incorrect conclusions about cause-and-effect relationships, as they may influence the outcome alongside the variable being tested, thus making it difficult to determine if the observed effects are due to the independent variable or the confounding variable.
Control Group: A control group is a baseline group in an experiment that does not receive the experimental treatment or intervention, allowing researchers to compare it with the experimental group that does receive the treatment. This comparison helps to isolate the effects of the treatment and determine its effectiveness while accounting for other variables.
Experimental error: Experimental error refers to the variation between the measured values and the true value of a quantity in an experiment. This type of error can arise from various sources, such as limitations in measurement tools, environmental factors, or inherent biological variability. Understanding experimental error is crucial for accurately interpreting results and ensuring that findings are valid and reliable.
Fixed effects: Fixed effects refer to a statistical technique used in experimental design that controls for variables that do not change over time within a given group. By using fixed effects, researchers can isolate the impact of the variables of interest while accounting for unobserved factors that may confound results. This approach is particularly useful in split-plot designs, where different experimental units may be subjected to different treatments, allowing for more accurate estimation of treatment effects.
Interaction Effects: Interaction effects occur when the effect of one independent variable on a dependent variable changes depending on the level of another independent variable. This concept is crucial for understanding how different factors work together to influence outcomes in experimental designs.
Levels of factors: Levels of factors refer to the different settings or conditions that can be applied to a particular factor in an experimental design. Each factor can have multiple levels, which allows researchers to examine the effects of varying these conditions on the response variable. Understanding levels is crucial for interpreting interactions between factors and for designing experiments that yield clear insights into complex relationships.
Main Effects: Main effects refer to the individual impact of each independent variable on the dependent variable in an experimental design. Understanding main effects is crucial for interpreting the results of experiments, as they indicate how changes in a factor influence the outcome, independent of other factors in a study.
Mixed models: Mixed models are statistical models that incorporate both fixed effects and random effects, allowing researchers to analyze data that has multiple sources of variation. This makes them particularly useful in experimental designs where data may be collected from different groups or over time, accommodating the hierarchical structure of the data. They provide a flexible framework for understanding complex relationships and dependencies among variables.
Random Assignment: Random assignment is a technique used in experimental research to ensure that participants are allocated to different groups or conditions in a way that is not influenced by any biases or pre-existing differences. This process helps to create equivalent groups, enhancing the credibility of the experiment's conclusions by minimizing confounding variables.
Random effects: Random effects refer to variables in a statistical model that capture the random variability in the data, typically arising from differences among experimental units or groups. In the context of experimental design, random effects are important because they help account for variations that are not explicitly controlled by the experimenter, allowing for more accurate estimations of treatment effects and interactions.
Replication: Replication refers to the process of repeating an experiment or study to verify results and enhance reliability. It ensures that findings are not due to chance or specific conditions in a single study, thus contributing to the robustness of research conclusions and generalizability across different contexts.
Split-plot design: A split-plot design is a type of experimental design that involves multiple levels of experimental units, allowing researchers to study two or more factors simultaneously while accounting for the variability at different levels. This design is particularly useful when some factors are harder or more costly to manipulate than others, making it necessary to control these factors at a larger scale while manipulating others at a finer scale. This flexibility connects it to various principles and applications in experimental research.
Sub-plots: Sub-plots are secondary experimental units in a split-plot design, where one factor is applied at a higher level of experimental units while another factor is applied at a lower level. These sub-plots allow researchers to explore the interaction between treatments and factors that may vary within the main plot, providing insights into more complex relationships in the data. Understanding sub-plots is essential for effectively interpreting results and determining the influence of different factors on the overall outcome.
Treatment combinations: Treatment combinations refer to the various pairings of different levels of factors in an experiment, particularly in designs involving multiple factors. Understanding these combinations is crucial for exploring interactions between factors, which can significantly impact the outcome of an experiment. The careful selection and arrangement of treatment combinations allow researchers to efficiently test hypotheses and make informed conclusions about the effects of different conditions.
Whole plots: Whole plots are the larger experimental units in split-plot designs, which allow for the investigation of multiple factors at different levels of variability. They serve as a crucial component in experimental layouts where one factor is assigned to whole plots while another is applied to subplots, leading to more efficient designs when certain factors are difficult to manipulate or measure. Understanding whole plots helps clarify how different levels of treatment can be effectively applied and analyzed in experiments.