5.5 Patents
7 min read•august 20, 2024
Patents are crucial for protecting inventions and gaining a competitive edge. They grant exclusive rights to inventors for a limited time in exchange for public disclosure. Different types of patents exist, each with specific requirements and terms.
Understanding patent requirements and the application process is essential for entrepreneurs. Inventions must be novel, non-obvious, and useful to qualify for patent protection. The examination process involves communication with USPTO examiners and potential appeals.
Types of patents
- Patents provide inventors with exclusive rights to their inventions for a limited time in exchange for public disclosure of the invention
- Different types of patents protect different aspects of an invention and have varying requirements and terms
Utility patents
Top images from around the web for Utility patents
Chapter 12 – Thomas Alva Edison – History of Applied Science & Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
The 1709 Blog: Fair use in the US: the Wiley case and prior art for patents View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 12 – Thomas Alva Edison – History of Applied Science & Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
The 1709 Blog: Fair use in the US: the Wiley case and prior art for patents View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Utility patents
Chapter 12 – Thomas Alva Edison – History of Applied Science & Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
The 1709 Blog: Fair use in the US: the Wiley case and prior art for patents View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 12 – Thomas Alva Edison – History of Applied Science & Technology View original
Is this image relevant?
The 1709 Blog: Fair use in the US: the Wiley case and prior art for patents View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Protect the functional aspects and features of an invention (machines, processes, compositions of matter)
- Most common type of patent granted by the
- Term of protection is generally 20 years from the filing date of the application
- Requires the invention to be novel, non-obvious, and useful
Design patents
- Protect the ornamental design or appearance of an article of manufacture (product designs, user interfaces)
- Do not protect the functional aspects of the design
- Term of protection is 15 years from the date of grant
- Requires the design to be novel, non-obvious, and ornamental
Plant patents
- Protect new and distinct varieties of asexually reproduced plants (excluding tuber-propagated plants)
- Term of protection is 20 years from the filing date of the application
- Requires the plant variety to be novel, distinct, and asexually reproducible
Patent requirements
- To obtain a patent, an invention must meet certain legal requirements set forth by patent law
- These requirements ensure that patents are only granted for deserving inventions and do not unduly restrict innovation
Novel invention
- The invention must be new and not previously known or used by others
- , including patents, publications, and public disclosures, is considered when assessing
- Inventors have a one-year grace period to file a after public disclosure of the invention in the United States
Non-obvious improvement
- The invention must not be obvious to a person skilled in the relevant field, considering the prior art
- Combinations of prior art that would be obvious to a skilled person are not patentable
- Factors considered include the scope and content of the prior art, differences between the invention and prior art, and the level of ordinary skill in the field
Usefulness of invention
- The invention must have a specific, substantial, and credible utility
- The patent application must disclose how to make and use the invention
- Inventions that are inoperable, impossible, or lack practical utility are not patentable
Patent application process
- Obtaining a patent involves a multi-step application process that requires careful preparation and attention to detail
- Inventors can file provisional or non-provisional applications and must provide a detailed description of the invention
Prior art search
- Conducting a thorough prior art search helps determine the novelty and of an invention
- Searches can include patent databases, scientific publications, and other public disclosures
- Identifying relevant prior art can help refine the invention and strengthen the patent application
Provisional vs non-provisional applications
- Provisional applications establish an early filing date but do not mature into a granted patent
- Provide a 12-month window to file a non-provisional application
- Require a detailed description of the invention but not formal claims or drawings
- Non-provisional applications are the formal patent applications that are examined by the USPTO
- Must include a specification, claims, drawings (if necessary), and an oath or declaration
- Publication typically occurs 18 months after the earliest filing date
Application components and fees
- Specification: Detailed description of the invention, including how to make and use it
- Claims: Define the scope of protection sought for the invention
- Drawings: Visual representations of the invention, if necessary
- Oath or Declaration: Statement by the inventor(s) attesting to the originality of the invention
- Fees: Filing, search, and examination fees are required and vary based on application type and entity status (micro, small, or large)
Patent examination
- After filing, a patent application undergoes examination by a USPTO patent examiner to determine its
- The examination process involves a series of communications between the applicant and the examiner
Office actions and responses
- Office actions are formal communications from the examiner that outline any objections or rejections to the application
- Common rejections include lack of novelty, obviousness, and insufficient disclosure
- Applicants must respond to office actions within a set time period, typically 3-6 months
- Responses can include amendments to the claims or arguments against the rejections
Allowance vs rejection
- If the examiner determines that the application meets all patentability requirements, a notice of allowance is issued
- Applicants must pay the issue fee to obtain the granted patent
- If the examiner maintains the rejections after the applicant's response, a final rejection is issued
- Applicants can file a request for continued examination (RCE) or appeal the rejection
Appeal process
- Applicants can appeal a final rejection to the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB)
- The PTAB reviews the case and issues a decision affirming or reversing the examiner's rejections
- Further appeals can be made to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
Patent rights and ownership
- A granted patent confers certain exclusive rights to the patent owner for a limited time
- Understanding these rights and how they can be transferred is crucial for entrepreneurs and startups
Exclusive rights granted
- Right to make, use, sell, offer for sale, and import the patented invention
- Right to exclude others from making, using, selling, offering for sale, or importing the invention
- Right to license or assign the patent to others
Patent term and expiration
- Utility and plant patents: 20 years from the filing date of the earliest non-provisional application
- Design patents: 15 years from the date of grant
- Patents expire at the end of their term, after which the invention enters the public domain
Selling or licensing patents
- Patent owners can monetize their patents by selling or licensing them to others
- can be exclusive (granted to a single licensee) or non-exclusive (granted to multiple licensees)
- Royalties, upfront payments, and milestone payments are common compensation structures in licensing agreements
- Startups can use patent licensing to generate revenue, establish partnerships, or access complementary technologies
Patent infringement
- Patent infringement occurs when someone makes, uses, sells, offers for sale, or imports a patented invention without the patent owner's permission
- Identifying and addressing infringement is essential for protecting a startup's
Types of infringement
- : Making, using, selling, offering for sale, or importing the patented invention
-
- Contributory infringement: Supplying components of a patented invention that have no substantial non-infringing use
- Induced infringement: Actively encouraging or aiding another party to infringe a patent
Enforcement strategies
- Cease and desist letters: Formal notices demanding that the alleged infringer stop the infringing activity
- Licensing negotiations: Offering a license to the alleged infringer to resolve the dispute and generate revenue
- : Filing a lawsuit against the alleged infringer in federal court to seek an injunction and damages
Damages and remedies
- Reasonable royalties: Compensation based on the royalty rate that would have been agreed upon in a hypothetical negotiation
- Lost profits: Compensation for profits lost due to the infringement, if the patent owner can prove they would have made the sales
- Injunctions: Court orders prohibiting the infringer from continuing the infringing activity
- Enhanced damages: Up to triple damages for willful infringement
International patent protection
- Patents are territorial rights, meaning they only provide protection in the countries where they are granted
- Startups should consider international patent protection if they plan to enter global markets
Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT)
- International patent filing system that allows applicants to seek patent protection in multiple countries through a single application
- PCT applications do not result in a granted patent but provide a 30-month window to enter national or regional phase in the desired countries
Foreign filing requirements
- Applicants must file separate patent applications in each country or region where protection is sought
- Translation requirements, fees, and local patent laws vary by country
- Deadlines for entering national or regional phase are typically 30 months from the priority date (earliest filing date)
Regional patent offices
- Some regions have centralized patent offices that grant patents valid in multiple countries
- : Grants European patents valid in up to 38 member states
- African Regional Intellectual Property Organization (ARIPO): Grants patents valid in up to 19 member states
- Eurasian Patent Organization (EAPO): Grants Eurasian patents valid in 8 member states
Patent strategy for startups
- Developing a comprehensive patent strategy is crucial for startups to protect their innovations and create a competitive advantage
- Key considerations include timing, costs, and portfolio management
Timing of filing
- Early filing can establish priority and protect against competitors, but may not allow sufficient time to refine the invention
- Later filing provides more time for development but risks losing priority to earlier disclosures or filings by others
- Provisional applications can be a useful tool to establish an early priority date while allowing time for further development
Cost-benefit analysis
- Patent filing and , as well as attorney fees, can be substantial for startups with limited resources
- Startups should prioritize patenting key innovations that provide a significant competitive advantage
- Consider the potential market value, licensing opportunities, and defensive value of each invention when deciding whether to pursue patent protection
Portfolio management
- Startups should regularly review and assess their patent portfolio to ensure it aligns with their business strategy
- Pruning less valuable or irrelevant patents can help reduce maintenance costs
- Identifying gaps in protection and pursuing additional patents can strengthen the startup's market position and attract investors
- Aligning patent strategy with product development, marketing, and partnership efforts is essential for maximizing the value of the startup's intellectual property
Key Terms to Review (21)
Design patent: A design patent is a type of intellectual property protection granted to the ornamental design of a functional item. It covers the visual characteristics of a product, allowing the owner exclusive rights to the design for a period of 15 years. This protection encourages innovation by preventing others from making, using, or selling a product that closely resembles the patented design.
Direct infringement: Direct infringement occurs when an individual or entity uses, makes, sells, or distributes a patented invention without the permission of the patent holder. This concept is critical in patent law as it establishes a clear violation of the exclusive rights granted to the patent owner. Understanding direct infringement is essential to grasp how patents protect innovations and ensure that inventors can benefit from their creations.
European Patent Office (EPO): The European Patent Office (EPO) is an intergovernmental organization that provides a centralized patent granting procedure for its member states. It allows inventors and businesses to obtain patent protection across multiple European countries through a single application process, making it more efficient and cost-effective compared to filing individual patents in each country.
Indirect infringement: Indirect infringement refers to a legal concept where a party is held liable for infringing on a patent not by directly using or selling the patented invention, but by contributing to or encouraging someone else to do so. This can occur through actions like providing components for a patented invention or inducing another party to use the invention without authorization. Indirect infringement is crucial for protecting patent rights and ensuring that all parties involved in the production and distribution of an invention are held accountable.
Intellectual Property: Intellectual property refers to the legal rights that protect creations of the mind, such as inventions, literary and artistic works, designs, symbols, and names used in commerce. These rights enable creators to control and benefit from their innovations and creativity, fostering an environment where new ideas can flourish. Understanding intellectual property is essential for entrepreneurs as it affects how they can protect their products and services, maintain competitive advantages, and fulfill roles within their business structures.
Licensing Agreements: Licensing agreements are legal contracts where one party grants another party permission to use their intellectual property, such as patents, trademarks, or copyrights, under specified conditions. These agreements can be crucial for businesses as they allow the licensee to leverage established brands or technologies without the need for extensive investment in development or manufacturing, while the licensor benefits from royalties or fees without relinquishing ownership.
Maintenance fees: Maintenance fees are periodic payments required to keep a patent in force, ensuring that the patent holder retains exclusive rights to their invention. These fees are typically due at regular intervals, such as annually or every few years, and serve as a way to discourage hoarding of patents and promote active innovation. Failing to pay these fees can lead to the expiration of the patent rights, allowing others to use the invention without permission.
Non-obviousness: Non-obviousness is a key requirement for obtaining a patent, indicating that an invention must not be obvious to someone skilled in the relevant field at the time it was created. This means that the invention should involve an inventive step that is not readily deducible from prior art. A successful demonstration of non-obviousness can set an invention apart from existing products or processes, making it a critical aspect in the patent application process.
Novelty: Novelty refers to the uniqueness or originality of an invention or idea, which is essential in determining its eligibility for patent protection. An invention must demonstrate novelty to ensure that it is not already known or used by others before the patent application is filed, making it a critical aspect in the patenting process. The concept of novelty helps distinguish new inventions from existing knowledge, thereby promoting innovation and creativity in various fields.
Patent application: A patent application is a formal request filed with a patent office to obtain exclusive rights to an invention for a specific period of time. This document outlines the details of the invention, including its purpose, how it works, and the claims being made about its novelty and usefulness. The application process is crucial for entrepreneurs seeking to protect their intellectual property and gain a competitive edge in the market.
Patent litigation: Patent litigation refers to the legal process of resolving disputes over patent rights, typically involving claims of infringement or challenges to the validity of a patent. It plays a crucial role in the protection of intellectual property, allowing patent holders to enforce their rights against unauthorized use and ensuring that innovations are legally recognized and compensated. This process often involves complex legal arguments, extensive documentation, and can lead to significant financial consequences for both the patent holder and the alleged infringer.
Patent prosecution: Patent prosecution is the process of obtaining a patent from a patent office, involving the preparation and submission of patent applications and negotiating with the patent examiner to address any issues that arise. This process includes responding to rejections, making amendments to claims, and ensuring compliance with legal requirements, ultimately aiming for the grant of patent rights that protect an invention or innovation.
Patent Term: The patent term refers to the duration of time during which a patent holder has exclusive rights to their invention, preventing others from making, using, or selling the patented product or process without permission. Typically, the standard patent term is 20 years from the filing date of the patent application, but this can vary based on certain factors such as extensions or specific regulations in different jurisdictions.
Patentability: Patentability refers to the ability of an invention to meet specific legal criteria in order to qualify for a patent. This concept is essential because it determines whether an inventor can secure exclusive rights to their invention, protecting it from being made, used, or sold by others without permission. To be patentable, an invention must typically be novel, non-obvious, and useful, which aligns with the underlying principles of intellectual property law.
Plant Patent: A plant patent is a form of intellectual property protection granted to an inventor or discoverer of a new and distinct variety of plant, allowing them exclusive rights to propagate, sell, and distribute that plant variety. This type of patent encourages innovation in horticulture and agriculture by protecting the rights of breeders and incentivizing the development of unique plant species, hybrids, or cultivars.
Prior Art: Prior art refers to any evidence that your invention or idea has already been disclosed to the public before the filing of a patent application. It includes everything from earlier patents and publications to products that have been sold or publicly demonstrated. Understanding prior art is crucial because it can determine whether an invention is novel and non-obvious, which are key requirements for patentability.
Steve Jobs: Steve Jobs was an influential American entrepreneur and co-founder of Apple Inc., known for revolutionizing the technology industry with innovative products like the iPhone, iPad, and MacBook. His visionary approach to design and user experience has left a lasting impact on ideation techniques, emphasizing the importance of understanding consumer needs and creating products that blend functionality with aesthetics. Additionally, Jobs' focus on intellectual property helped shape the patent landscape in the tech industry, pushing for strong protections for groundbreaking inventions.
Thomas Edison: Thomas Edison was an American inventor and businessman who is best known for developing many devices that greatly influenced life around the world, including the phonograph, the motion picture camera, and the electric light bulb. His extensive work in creating and patenting inventions highlights the importance of intellectual property rights and the role of patents in fostering innovation and entrepreneurship.
United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO): The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) is a federal agency responsible for granting patents and registering trademarks in the United States. It plays a crucial role in protecting intellectual property rights, ensuring that inventors and businesses can secure their innovations and brands from unauthorized use. The USPTO not only examines applications but also helps to educate the public about the importance of intellectual property in fostering innovation and economic growth.
Usefulness: Usefulness refers to the practical value or benefit that an invention or idea provides to society, particularly in terms of its ability to solve problems or improve existing processes. In the context of patents, usefulness is a crucial criterion that determines whether an invention qualifies for patent protection, as it ensures that the patented invention has real-world applications and contributes positively to the advancement of technology and society.
Utility patent: A utility patent is a form of intellectual property protection granted for new and useful inventions, processes, machines, or compositions of matter. This type of patent gives the inventor exclusive rights to make, use, sell, or distribute their invention for a period of 20 years from the filing date. It is essential for entrepreneurs to understand utility patents as they provide legal protection against unauthorized use of their inventions and can significantly enhance a business's competitive advantage.