11.4 Employment discrimination lawsuits

Employment discrimination lawsuits are a crucial aspect of workplace rights. These legal actions protect employees from unfair treatment based on protected characteristics like race, gender, age, or disability. Understanding the types, elements, and procedures involved is essential for both employers and employees.

Discrimination claims involve complex legal frameworks, including burden-shifting and various defenses. Key aspects include proving membership in a protected class, adverse employment action, and a causal link. Employers must navigate these issues carefully to avoid liability and maintain fair workplace practices.

Types of employment discrimination

• Employment discrimination occurs when an employer treats an employee or job applicant unfavorably based on certain protected characteristics
• Two main types of employment discrimination are disparate treatment and disparate impact, which differ in how the discrimination is manifested and proven

Disparate treatment vs disparate impact

Top images from around the web for Disparate treatment vs disparate impact

• 

  Stereotypes, Prejudice, and Discrimination | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bias and Protections in Hiring – General Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Coping With Stigma in the Workplace: Understanding the Role of Threat Regulation ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stereotypes, Prejudice, and Discrimination | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bias and Protections in Hiring – General Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Disparate treatment vs disparate impact

• 

  Stereotypes, Prejudice, and Discrimination | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bias and Protections in Hiring – General Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Frontiers | Coping With Stigma in the Workplace: Understanding the Role of Threat Regulation ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Stereotypes, Prejudice, and Discrimination | Introduction to Sociology View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Bias and Protections in Hiring – General Psychology View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Disparate treatment discrimination involves intentionally treating an individual differently based on their membership in a protected class (race, gender)
• Requires showing that the employer acted with discriminatory intent or motive
• Disparate impact discrimination occurs when a facially neutral policy or practice has a disproportionately negative effect on a protected class
• Does not require proof of discriminatory intent, but rather focuses on the discriminatory consequences of the employer's actions

Protected classes under federal law

• Federal anti-discrimination laws prohibit employment discrimination based on certain protected characteristics
• Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, and national origin
• Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) protects individuals 40 years and older from age discrimination
• Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) prohibits discrimination against qualified individuals with disabilities

Additional protected classes by state

• Many states have enacted their own anti-discrimination laws that provide protection for additional characteristics beyond those covered by federal law
• Examples of additional protected classes in some states include:
  • Sexual orientation and gender identity
  • Marital status
  • Military or veteran status
  • Political affiliation
• Employers must comply with both federal and applicable state anti-discrimination laws

Elements of a discrimination claim

• To establish a prima facie case of employment discrimination, an employee must prove several key elements
• These elements vary slightly depending on the type of discrimination alleged and the specific facts of the case

Membership in a protected class

• The employee must show that they belong to a protected class covered by anti-discrimination laws (race, gender, age, disability)
• Membership in the protected class is an essential element of any discrimination claim

Adverse employment action

• The employee must have suffered an adverse employment action, such as termination, demotion, failure to hire, or denial of benefits
• The action must be materially adverse and affect the terms, conditions, or privileges of employment

Causal link between membership and action

• The employee must demonstrate a causal connection between their membership in the protected class and the adverse employment action
• This can be shown through direct evidence (discriminatory statements) or circumstantial evidence (preferential treatment of similarly situated employees outside the protected class)

Employer's legitimate non-discriminatory reason

• Once the employee establishes a prima facie case, the burden shifts to the employer to articulate a legitimate, non-discriminatory reason for the adverse action
• The employer must provide a credible and specific explanation for the action taken

Pretext for discrimination

• If the employer provides a legitimate reason, the employee must then prove that the stated reason is a pretext (cover-up) for discrimination
• This can be done by showing that the employer's explanation is false, inconsistent, or otherwise unworthy of credence
• The ultimate burden of persuasion remains with the employee to prove that discrimination was the true reason for the adverse action

Burden of proof in discrimination cases

• Employment discrimination cases follow a three-step burden-shifting framework known as the McDonnell Douglas analysis
• This framework allocates the burdens of proof between the employee and the employer at different stages of the case

Prima facie case by employee

• The employee must first establish a prima facie case of discrimination by proving the essential elements (protected class, adverse action, causal link)
• The prima facie case creates a presumption of discrimination and shifts the burden to the employer to provide a legitimate reason for the action

Burden shifting to employer

• If the employee establishes a prima facie case, the burden of production shifts to the employer to articulate a legitimate, non-discriminatory reason for the adverse action
• The employer's burden is one of production, not persuasion, and can be satisfied by providing a credible explanation

Ultimate burden of persuasion

• If the employer provides a legitimate reason, the burden shifts back to the employee to prove that the stated reason is a pretext for discrimination
• The ultimate burden of persuasion remains with the employee throughout the case to prove that discrimination was the true motivating factor
• The employee must present sufficient evidence to allow a reasonable factfinder to conclude that the employer's stated reason is false and that discrimination occurred

Defenses to discrimination claims

• Employers have several potential defenses available to counter discrimination claims, depending on the specific circumstances of the case
• These defenses can justify otherwise discriminatory actions or policies if certain requirements are met

Bona fide occupational qualification (BFOQ)

• The BFOQ defense allows employers to discriminate based on certain protected characteristics if the characteristic is reasonably necessary for the normal operation of the business
• The BFOQ defense is narrow and applies only to discrimination based on sex, religion, or national origin (not race or color)
• Examples: hiring only female guards for women's prisons, requiring airline pilots to retire at a certain age for safety reasons

Business necessity

• The business necessity defense applies to disparate impact claims and justifies a policy or practice that has a discriminatory effect if it is job-related and consistent with business necessity
• The employer must show that the challenged policy or practice is necessary for safe and efficient job performance and that no alternative practice would serve the same purpose with less discriminatory impact

Job-relatedness of selection criteria

• Employers can defend against discrimination claims by showing that the selection criteria used for hiring, promotion, or other employment decisions are job-related and consistent with business necessity
• The criteria must be validated as predictive of successful job performance and not have a disparate impact on protected classes

Reasonable accommodation and undue hardship

• Under the ADA, employers must provide reasonable accommodations to qualified individuals with disabilities unless doing so would impose an undue hardship on the business
• Reasonable accommodations are modifications or adjustments that enable the individual to perform the essential functions of the job
• Undue hardship is a significant difficulty or expense that would fundamentally alter the nature or operation of the business
• Employers can defend against failure-to-accommodate claims by showing that the requested accommodation would impose an undue hardship

Retaliation for discrimination complaints

• Retaliation occurs when an employer takes adverse action against an employee for engaging in protected activity related to discrimination
• Anti-discrimination laws prohibit retaliation against employees who oppose unlawful discrimination, participate in discrimination proceedings, or request accommodations

Elements of a retaliation claim

• To establish a prima facie case of retaliation, an employee must prove three elements:
  1. The employee engaged in protected activity (filed a complaint, testified in an investigation)
  2. The employer took adverse action against the employee (termination, demotion)
  3. There is a causal connection between the protected activity and the adverse action

Adverse action after protected activity

• The adverse action must occur after the employee engaged in protected activity and be materially adverse, meaning it would dissuade a reasonable employee from engaging in protected activity
• Examples of adverse actions include termination, demotion, reduction in pay or benefits, and undesirable work assignments

Causal connection between activity and action

• The employee must show that the protected activity was a but-for cause of the adverse action, meaning the action would not have occurred in the absence of the protected activity
• Causation can be proven through direct evidence (retaliatory statements) or circumstantial evidence (temporal proximity, differential treatment of similarly situated employees)

Remedies for employment discrimination

• Employees who prevail in employment discrimination lawsuits are entitled to various remedies to compensate for the harm suffered and deter future discrimination
• The available remedies depend on the specific anti-discrimination law and the type of discrimination proven

Back pay and front pay

• Back pay is a monetary award that compensates the employee for lost wages and benefits from the time of the discriminatory action until the date of judgment
• Front pay is a monetary award that compensates the employee for future lost wages and benefits if reinstatement is not feasible due to hostility or other factors

Compensatory and punitive damages

• Compensatory damages are awarded to compensate the employee for emotional distress, pain and suffering, and other non-economic harm caused by the discrimination
• Punitive damages are awarded to punish the employer for particularly egregious or malicious discrimination and to deter future misconduct
• Compensatory and punitive damages are subject to statutory caps based on the employer's size

Reinstatement or promotion

• Reinstatement is an equitable remedy that restores the employee to their former position as if the discrimination had not occurred
• If the former position is no longer available, the court may order the employee to be placed in a comparable position
• The court may also order the employee to be promoted to a position they would have obtained absent the discrimination

Attorneys' fees and costs

• Prevailing employees are entitled to recover reasonable attorneys' fees and litigation costs from the employer
• The purpose of fee-shifting is to encourage attorneys to take on discrimination cases and to deter employers from engaging in unlawful discrimination
• The amount of attorneys' fees awarded is based on the reasonable hours expended and the prevailing market rate for comparable legal services

Procedural requirements for lawsuits

• Employees who wish to file a discrimination lawsuit must first exhaust administrative remedies and comply with certain procedural requirements
• These requirements are designed to provide notice to the employer and an opportunity for the parties to resolve the dispute before litigation

Exhaustion of administrative remedies

• Before filing a lawsuit under federal anti-discrimination laws, an employee must first file a charge of discrimination with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)
• The charge must be filed within 180 days of the discriminatory act (or 300 days in states with fair employment agencies)
• The EEOC will investigate the charge and attempt to resolve the dispute through conciliation

Timely filing of EEOC charge

• The timely filing of an EEOC charge is a prerequisite to filing a lawsuit under federal anti-discrimination laws
• If the employee fails to file a charge within the applicable 180 or 300-day deadline, the claim may be barred by the statute of limitations

Right-to-sue letter from EEOC

• If the EEOC is unable to resolve the dispute through conciliation, it will issue a right-to-sue letter to the employee
• The right-to-sue letter authorizes the employee to file a lawsuit in federal court within 90 days of receipt of the letter
• If the employee fails to file suit within the 90-day window, the claim may be barred by the statute of limitations

Statute of limitations for lawsuit

• The statute of limitations for filing a discrimination lawsuit under federal law is typically 90 days from receipt of the EEOC right-to-sue letter
• Some state anti-discrimination laws have longer statutes of limitations for filing lawsuits (2-3 years)
• Employees must be mindful of the applicable deadlines and file their claims within the required time period to preserve their rights

Alternative dispute resolution (ADR)

• Alternative dispute resolution refers to methods of resolving discrimination claims outside of traditional litigation, such as mediation and arbitration
• ADR can offer faster, less expensive, and more confidential resolution of disputes compared to lawsuits

Mediation of discrimination claims

• Mediation is a voluntary process in which a neutral third party facilitates settlement negotiations between the employee and the employer
• The mediator does not make a decision but helps the parties reach a mutually acceptable resolution
• Mediation can be initiated by the parties or ordered by the court as part of the litigation process
• Settlements reached in mediation are binding and enforceable contracts

Arbitration agreements in employment

• Arbitration is a private process in which a neutral third party (arbitrator) hears evidence and renders a binding decision on the discrimination claim
• Many employers require employees to sign arbitration agreements as a condition of employment, waiving the right to file a lawsuit in court
• Arbitration agreements are generally enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act, with some exceptions for unconscionability or other contract defenses

Pros and cons of ADR

• Advantages of ADR include:
  • Faster resolution than litigation
  • Lower costs and attorneys' fees
  • Greater confidentiality and privacy
  • More flexible and creative solutions
• Disadvantages of ADR include:
  • Limited discovery and formal procedures
  • No jury trial or public record
  • Potential bias of arbitrators toward employers
  • Limited judicial review of arbitration awards
• Employees should carefully consider the pros and cons of ADR before agreeing to mediation or signing an arbitration agreement