10.1 Key performance indicators for disruptive innovations
5 min read•august 16, 2024
Key performance indicators (KPIs) are crucial for measuring the success of disruptive innovations. They help track customer adoption, market performance, and innovation progress. By focusing on metrics like user engagement, revenue growth in new markets, and product improvement rates, companies can gauge their innovation's impact.
Setting targets for disruptive innovation KPIs requires balancing ambition with realism. It's important to benchmark against other disruptive innovations rather than traditional competitors. Using a and regularly adjusting goals based on market feedback helps maintain flexibility in an uncertain landscape.
KPIs for Disruptive Innovations
Customer-Focused Metrics
Top images from around the web for Customer-Focused Metrics
FIGURE 15.5 Innovation Adoption Curve | This illustration is… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Free Product Adoption Curve PowerPoint Template - Free PowerPoint Templates - SlideHunter.com View original
Is this image relevant?
Technology and Innovation | Boundless Management View original
Is this image relevant?
FIGURE 15.5 Innovation Adoption Curve | This illustration is… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Free Product Adoption Curve PowerPoint Template - Free PowerPoint Templates - SlideHunter.com View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Customer-Focused Metrics
FIGURE 15.5 Innovation Adoption Curve | This illustration is… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Free Product Adoption Curve PowerPoint Template - Free PowerPoint Templates - SlideHunter.com View original
Is this image relevant?
Technology and Innovation | Boundless Management View original
Is this image relevant?
FIGURE 15.5 Innovation Adoption Curve | This illustration is… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Free Product Adoption Curve PowerPoint Template - Free PowerPoint Templates - SlideHunter.com View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- measures market acceptance of disruptive innovations
- Tracks percentage of target market using the innovation over time
- Example: Percentage of smartphone users adopting a new mobile payment system
- indicate innovation's ability to solve customer problems
- Include metrics like daily active users, time spent using product, or feature utilization
- Example: Average daily time spent on a new social media platform
- demonstrate accessibility and affordability improvements
- Track decreases in production costs or end-user prices
- Example: Reduction in cost-per-gigabyte for cloud storage services
Market Performance Indicators
- in new or underserved markets signals value creation
- Measures percentage increase in revenue from target segments
- Example: Year-over-year revenue growth from entry-level electric vehicles
- tracks innovation's penetration into new markets
- Calculates percentage of market captured over time
- Example: Increasing market share of online streaming services vs traditional cable TV
- indicate creation of new market or value network
- Measure number of complementary products, services, or partnerships
- Example: Number of third-party apps developed for a new smart home platform
Innovation Performance Metrics
- in product performance or capabilities over time
- Tracks enhancements in key features or specifications
- Example: Annual improvements in battery life for electric vehicles
- reveal agility of innovation process
- Measure duration from concept to product launch
- Example: Months required to release new features in a software-as-a-service product
- show adaptability to market feedback
- Track frequency of product updates or new version releases
- Example: Number of significant updates to a mobile app per quarter
Setting Targets for Disruptive Innovations
Benchmarking and Target Setting Approaches
- Balance ambition and realism when setting targets for disruptive innovation KPIs
- Consider unique challenges and opportunities of the innovation
- Example: Setting aggressive but achievable user acquisition targets for a new fintech app
- Focus on comparing performance to other disruptive innovations or future market states
- Avoid benchmarking against traditional competitors
- Example: Comparing electric vehicle adoption rates to historical smartphone adoption curves
- Utilize for progressive target setting
- Account for typical adoption patterns of disruptive innovations
- Example: Setting escalating market share targets based on expected technology maturation
Target Structure and Flexibility
- Implement tiered target system to accommodate uncertainty
- Include minimum viable targets, stretch goals, and breakthrough objectives
- Example: Setting baseline, target, and stretch goals for customer acquisition costs
- Incorporate short-term and long-term targets to balance immediate progress and future potential
- Set quarterly milestones alongside multi-year objectives
- Example: Balancing monthly active user growth with five-year market penetration goals
- Regularly review and adjust targets based on market feedback and landscape changes
- Conduct quarterly or semi-annual target assessments
- Example: Adjusting revenue targets based on unexpected shifts in consumer preferences
- Use scenario planning techniques for flexible target setting
- Develop targets for multiple potential market outcomes
- Example: Creating different growth targets for optimistic, realistic, and pessimistic market scenarios
Leading vs Lagging Indicators
Characteristics and Examples
- signal future success of disruptive innovations
- Include predictive metrics like customer interest levels or prototype feedback
- Example: Number of pre-orders for a new product as a leading indicator of sales
- measure actual outcomes of disruptive innovations
- Include metrics like revenue, market share, or customer satisfaction scores
- Example: as a lagging indicator of product satisfaction
- Time lag between leading and lagging indicators may be longer for disruptive innovations
- Requires patience and long-term perspective in evaluation
- Example: Lag between early adopter feedback and mainstream market adoption
Indicator Relationships and Analysis
- Leading indicators often focus on early adopters and niche markets
- Track metrics relevant to initial target segments
- Example: Engagement rates among tech enthusiasts for a new augmented reality device
- Lagging indicators reflect broader market acceptance and financial performance
- Measure overall market impact and business results
- Example: Total revenue and profitability of a new business model innovation
- Balance use of leading and lagging indicators for comprehensive innovation management
- Enables proactive adjustments and performance validation
- Example: Combining product usage metrics (leading) with customer lifetime value (lagging)
- Analyze evolving correlation between leading and lagging indicators as innovation matures
- Requires ongoing interpretation and adjustment of metrics
- Example: Tracking changes in relationship between user acquisition cost and long-term retention rates
Effectiveness of KPIs for Disruptive Value
Alignment with Value Proposition
- Effective KPIs should closely align with innovation's unique
- Reflect potential to create new markets or value networks
- Example: Measuring reduction in transaction costs for a blockchain-based financial service
- Assess KPIs' ability to capture current performance and future potential
- Include metrics that indicate both short-term traction and long-term impact
- Example: Combining current user growth rate with total addressable market penetration projections
- Evaluate how well KPIs reflect service to unserved or underserved customer segments
- Track metrics specific to target demographics or use cases
- Example: Measuring adoption rates among previously unbanked populations for a mobile banking app
Comprehensive Impact Assessment
- Consider KPIs' capacity to measure impact on industry structure and business models
- Include metrics that capture disruption to existing value chains
- Example: Tracking shift in revenue distribution among industry players after introduction of a platform innovation
- Analyze KPIs' sensitivity to changes in innovation performance and market acceptance
- Ensure metrics can detect and quantify incremental improvements
- Example: Measuring changes in user retention rates in response to product feature updates
- Assess balance between quantitative and qualitative KPIs for holistic view
- Combine numerical metrics with qualitative assessments
- Example: Pairing customer satisfaction scores with in-depth user feedback analysis
- Regularly review and update KPIs to maintain relevance as innovation evolves
- Conduct periodic assessments of metric effectiveness
- Example: Annually evaluating and adjusting KPI set based on changing market dynamics and product maturity
Key Terms to Review (17)
Ambition and realism balance: Ambition and realism balance refers to the ability to set high aspirations while maintaining a grounded understanding of the resources, capabilities, and limitations that exist. This balance is crucial in the context of disruptive innovations, where it is essential to push boundaries while also ensuring that goals are achievable based on current market conditions and technological feasibility.
Comprehensive impact assessment: A comprehensive impact assessment is a systematic process used to evaluate the potential effects of a proposed innovation or project across various dimensions, including economic, social, and environmental factors. This assessment helps organizations understand how disruptive innovations will affect not only their operations but also their stakeholders and the broader community, allowing for informed decision-making and strategic planning.
Cost reduction metrics: Cost reduction metrics are quantitative measures used to evaluate and track the effectiveness of strategies aimed at lowering operational costs within an organization. These metrics help assess how well a business is achieving cost efficiency, which is crucial for maintaining competitiveness, especially in disruptive innovation contexts where new entrants can challenge established firms.
Customer adoption rate: Customer adoption rate is the percentage of potential customers who begin using a new product or service during a specific time frame. This metric is crucial for understanding how well an innovation resonates with its target audience and indicates the overall success of the product in the market.
Ecosystem development metrics: Ecosystem development metrics are quantitative and qualitative measures used to assess the health, performance, and growth of an ecosystem that supports disruptive innovations. These metrics help in understanding how various elements within the ecosystem, such as startups, established firms, research institutions, and investors, interact and contribute to innovation outcomes. By analyzing these metrics, stakeholders can make informed decisions about resource allocation, collaboration opportunities, and areas needing improvement.
Iteration speed metrics: Iteration speed metrics are measurements used to assess the pace at which a company can develop, test, and launch new iterations of a product or service. These metrics are essential for evaluating the efficiency of innovation processes and can indicate how quickly a company can respond to market changes and customer feedback, ultimately impacting its competitive edge.
Lagging Indicators: Lagging indicators are metrics that reflect the outcomes of past performance and are used to measure the effectiveness of a strategy or innovation after it has already been implemented. They provide insights into the results of actions taken, helping organizations understand how successful their disruptive innovations have been over time. These indicators are crucial for assessing overall business health and can validate or challenge earlier decisions regarding disruptive strategies.
Leading indicators: Leading indicators are measurable factors that are used to predict future trends and outcomes in a business or economic context. They provide early signals of potential changes in performance, allowing organizations to proactively adjust strategies and operations to better align with anticipated market shifts. These indicators are crucial for assessing the potential impact of disruptive innovations on a company's success.
Market share expansion: Market share expansion refers to the process of increasing a company's portion of total sales within a specific market, often through strategies that outperform competitors and attract more customers. This growth can be achieved by innovative products, superior marketing tactics, or improved customer experiences, all aimed at capturing a larger segment of the market. Understanding how to measure and achieve market share expansion is crucial for businesses aiming for sustainable growth and long-term success.
Net Promoter Score: Net Promoter Score (NPS) is a metric used to measure customer loyalty and satisfaction by assessing the likelihood that customers would recommend a company's products or services to others. This score helps businesses gauge customer perception, identify areas for improvement, and drive growth by focusing on customer feedback. A high NPS indicates strong customer loyalty, which is critical for designing compelling value propositions and evaluating performance metrics related to disruptive innovations.
Rate of improvement: The rate of improvement refers to the speed at which a product or service evolves and enhances its performance over time. This metric is crucial in assessing how quickly a disruptive innovation can meet or exceed the performance of established products, which ultimately impacts market adoption and competitive advantage.
Revenue Growth Rate: Revenue growth rate is a key financial metric that measures the percentage increase in a company’s sales over a specific period, typically expressed on an annual basis. This figure is crucial for assessing how well a company is expanding its market presence and driving sales, which is particularly significant for businesses involved in disruptive innovations where rapid growth can indicate successful market penetration and acceptance.
S-curve model: The s-curve model is a graphical representation that illustrates the life cycle of a product or technology, showing its growth, maturity, and decline phases. This model helps understand how innovations progress over time and highlights the relationship between performance improvements and market adoption. By analyzing the s-curve, businesses can evaluate industry value chains, measure key performance indicators for innovations, and anticipate emerging trends and disruptions in their markets.
Tiered Target System: A tiered target system is a strategic framework that categorizes customers or market segments into different levels based on specific criteria such as potential revenue, strategic importance, or willingness to adopt new innovations. This approach enables companies to prioritize resources and tailor their strategies to effectively engage each tier, maximizing their chances of successful disruptive innovation.
Time-to-market metrics: Time-to-market metrics refer to the measurements that assess the time it takes for a product to move from the initial concept stage to being available for sale in the market. These metrics are crucial for evaluating the efficiency of the innovation process, helping organizations understand how quickly they can respond to market demands and capitalize on new opportunities.
User engagement metrics: User engagement metrics are quantitative measures that assess how users interact with a product or service. These metrics help to evaluate user behavior, satisfaction, and overall engagement levels, providing insights into the effectiveness of a product and informing future improvements or innovations.
Value Proposition: A value proposition is a clear statement that explains how a product or service solves a customer's problem, fulfills their needs, or improves their situation, while also highlighting the unique benefits that differentiate it from competitors. It connects to various aspects of business strategy by addressing customer needs, market segments, and industry dynamics.