14.1 Examining High-Profile Crisis Management Failures
3 min read•july 25, 2024
Real-world crises offer valuable lessons in crisis management. BP's oil spill, Volkswagen's emissions scandal, and United Airlines' passenger removal incident highlight common pitfalls: delayed responses, poor communication, and ethical lapses.
These cases reveal the devastating impact of mishandled crises. Organizations faced financial losses, reputational damage, and increased scrutiny. Leadership played a crucial role, with visible, ethical leaders setting the tone for effective and recovery.
Crisis Management Case Studies
Crisis management case studies
Top images from around the web for Crisis management case studies
'Surprised, No. Disgusted, Yes': Study Shows Deepwater Horizon Oil Spread Much Further Than ... View original
Is this image relevant?
The Oil Drum | BP's Deepwater Oil Spill - What Research Reports were Saying - and Open Thread View original
Is this image relevant?
BP Oil Spill: Extensive Collection of Ledes, Excerpts and Links – April 30 through May 7 | the ... View original
Is this image relevant?
'Surprised, No. Disgusted, Yes': Study Shows Deepwater Horizon Oil Spread Much Further Than ... View original
Is this image relevant?
The Oil Drum | BP's Deepwater Oil Spill - What Research Reports were Saying - and Open Thread View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Crisis management case studies
'Surprised, No. Disgusted, Yes': Study Shows Deepwater Horizon Oil Spread Much Further Than ... View original
Is this image relevant?
The Oil Drum | BP's Deepwater Oil Spill - What Research Reports were Saying - and Open Thread View original
Is this image relevant?
BP Oil Spill: Extensive Collection of Ledes, Excerpts and Links – April 30 through May 7 | the ... View original
Is this image relevant?
'Surprised, No. Disgusted, Yes': Study Shows Deepwater Horizon Oil Spread Much Further Than ... View original
Is this image relevant?
The Oil Drum | BP's Deepwater Oil Spill - What Research Reports were Saying - and Open Thread View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- (2010) delayed response downplayed incident severity led to public outrage
- Poor communication with Gulf Coast communities heightened mistrust and anger
- Inadequate preparation for worst-case scenarios left BP scrambling to contain spill
- (2015) initial denial attempted cover-up damaged brand credibility
- Slow admission of wrongdoing lacked transparency eroded consumer trust
- Inconsistent messaging across markets (US vs Europe) confused stakeholders
- (2017) mishandled situation on aircraft sparked viral outrage
- Inadequate initial response blamed victim fueled public backlash
- Failure to address root cause of overbooking exposed systemic issues
Key missteps in crisis response
- Lack of preparedness left organizations vulnerable
- Insufficient crisis management plans failed to anticipate scenarios
- Inadequate training for staff and spokespersons led to poor communication
- Communication failures amplified negative impact
- Delayed or inconsistent messaging created information vacuum
- Failure to address stakeholder concerns promptly increased frustration
- Ethical lapses undermined trust
- Attempts to cover up or minimize issues backfired when truth emerged
- Prioritizing short-term finances over reputation had long-term consequences
- Leadership shortcomings exacerbated crises
- Absence of visible, accountable leadership during crisis left power vacuum
- Failure to take responsibility and show empathy alienated stakeholders
Impact of failures on organizations
- Short-term financial consequences hit hard
- Stock price drops (BP shares fell 55% post-spill)
- Loss of customers and market share (VW sales declined 15% in US)
- Fines and legal settlements (BP paid $65 billion in penalties)
- Long-term reputational damage lingered
- Erosion of brand trust and loyalty took years to rebuild
- Negative media coverage and public perception persisted
- Difficulty attracting and retaining talent impacted operations
- Regulatory scrutiny increased industry-wide
- Government oversight and regulations tightened (offshore drilling moratorium)
- Ripple effects impacted related sectors (automotive emissions testing)
- Recovery costs strained resources
- Crisis management and PR efforts drained budgets
- Investments in rebuilding reputation and trust required long-term commitment
Leadership role in crisis mishandling
- Visible, engaged leadership sets tone for response
- Demonstrates accountability and transparency to stakeholders
- Absence of leadership (BP CEO's "I want my life back" comment) worsens perception
- Decision-making under pressure requires balance
- Short-term vs long-term considerations must be weighed
- Diverse perspectives and expert input crucial for informed choices
- Communication responsibilities fall on leaders
- Clear, consistent messaging needed across all channels
- Addressing stakeholder concerns directly and empathetically builds trust
- prioritizes values over expediency
- Fosters culture of integrity and responsibility throughout organization
- Sets example for employees and stakeholders (VW's initial denial backfired)
- Learning and adaptation essential post-crisis
- Thorough analysis identifies systemic weaknesses
- Implementing changes prevents future crises, demonstrates commitment to improvement
Key Terms to Review (17)
BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill: The BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill, also known as the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, was a catastrophic event that occurred in April 2010 when an offshore drilling rig, operated by BP, experienced a blowout, resulting in one of the largest marine oil spills in history. This disaster not only caused severe environmental damage but also raised significant concerns about corporate accountability, crisis management, and regulatory oversight.
Business continuity planning: Business continuity planning (BCP) is the process of creating a strategy to ensure that an organization can continue operating during and after a crisis or disaster. It involves identifying potential risks, developing plans to mitigate those risks, and establishing protocols for maintaining critical operations in the face of disruptions. BCP is essential for resilience, allowing organizations to recover quickly from various incidents, including technological failures and natural disasters.
Crisis Communication: Crisis communication is the strategic approach to managing communication before, during, and after a crisis to minimize damage and protect an organization's reputation. It plays a crucial role in shaping public perception, facilitating transparency, and maintaining trust during turbulent times.
Crisis response: Crisis response refers to the actions and strategies implemented by organizations and individuals to address, manage, and mitigate the effects of a crisis. It encompasses communication efforts, decision-making processes, and operational activities aimed at stabilizing the situation, preserving reputation, and ensuring the safety of stakeholders. Effective crisis response is crucial for minimizing damage and restoring trust, highlighting the importance of preparation and adaptability in unpredictable situations.
Crisis Team: A crisis team is a group of individuals assembled to respond to and manage crises effectively, ensuring timely communication, decision-making, and resource allocation. This team plays a vital role in identifying key issues, coordinating responses, and communicating with stakeholders to mitigate the impact of a crisis on the organization. A well-structured crisis team is essential for organizations facing high-stakes situations and can greatly influence the outcome of crisis management efforts.
Ethical leadership: Ethical leadership is the practice of leading based on established principles of right and wrong, focusing on values such as honesty, integrity, fairness, and accountability. This approach emphasizes the importance of making decisions that reflect ethical standards and promoting a culture of trust and respect within organizations. In times of crisis, ethical leadership can significantly impact the effectiveness of communication and decision-making processes.
Image Restoration Theory: Image restoration theory is a framework that describes how organizations and individuals can manage their reputations and restore public trust after a crisis or negative event. This theory emphasizes the strategic communication approaches that can be employed to repair damage to an entity's image, focusing on different tactics depending on the nature of the crisis and the stakeholders involved.
Media briefing: A media briefing is a structured communication session where an organization presents information to the media, often during a crisis, to ensure accurate reporting and to control the narrative. This format allows organizations to share essential updates, address concerns, and answer questions from journalists. Effective media briefings are crucial for managing public perception and maintaining trust during challenging times.
Message control: Message control refers to the strategic management of communication during a crisis to ensure that the intended messages are conveyed accurately and consistently to the target audience. This concept is crucial in high-pressure situations where misinformation can easily spread, and maintaining a clear narrative is essential for restoring public trust and confidence.
Post-crisis evaluation: Post-crisis evaluation is the systematic process of assessing a crisis response after it has occurred to identify strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for improvement. This process is crucial for refining crisis management strategies and ensuring that organizations learn from their experiences to better prepare for future incidents.
Pre-crisis: Pre-crisis refers to the phase before a crisis occurs, focusing on preparedness and planning to mitigate potential impacts. This stage involves identifying risks, creating communication strategies, and training personnel to respond effectively if a crisis arises. Engaging stakeholders and establishing protocols during this time is crucial for successful management when an actual crisis strikes.
Reputation management: Reputation management is the practice of influencing and controlling an individual's or organization's public perception and image. This involves strategic communication efforts, including addressing crises effectively and maintaining positive stakeholder relationships to shape how a brand is viewed during and after adverse events.
Situational Crisis Communication Theory: Situational Crisis Communication Theory (SCCT) is a framework developed to help organizations understand how to communicate effectively during crises. This theory emphasizes the importance of matching communication strategies with the type of crisis and the organization's level of responsibility in that crisis, guiding responses that can protect reputation and maintain stakeholder trust.
Social media monitoring: Social media monitoring is the process of tracking and analyzing online conversations and engagement on social media platforms to gain insights into public sentiment and trends. This practice helps organizations respond effectively to real-time feedback, manage their reputation, and inform communication strategies during crises. By observing what is being said about a brand or situation, organizations can craft timely and relevant public information materials that address audience concerns.
Stakeholder Engagement: Stakeholder engagement is the process of involving individuals, groups, or organizations that have an interest or stake in a particular issue or project. It aims to foster collaboration, communication, and understanding between stakeholders and organizations, especially during crises, to ensure that diverse perspectives are considered and addressed.
United Airlines Passenger Removal Incident: The United Airlines Passenger Removal Incident refers to a controversial event that occurred on April 9, 2017, when a passenger, Dr. David Dao, was forcibly removed from an overbooked flight to make room for crew members. This incident sparked widespread outrage and highlighted significant issues related to customer service, crisis communication, and corporate responsibility in the airline industry.
Volkswagen emissions scandal: The Volkswagen emissions scandal refers to the revelation in 2015 that the car manufacturer Volkswagen had installed defeat devices in diesel vehicles, which enabled them to pass emissions tests while actually emitting pollutants far above legal limits. This scandal raises significant legal and ethical questions, showcasing the responsibilities companies have during crises and the consequences of failing to uphold these obligations.