10.3 Parole

Parole is a conditional release system that allows offenders to serve part of their sentence in the community under supervision. It involves eligibility requirements, board hearings, and strict conditions. Understanding parole is crucial for grasping how the criminal justice system balances punishment, rehabilitation, and public safety.

Parole differs from probation and faces ongoing controversies. Key issues include inconsistent decision-making, high-profile cases attracting media attention, and calls for reform. These challenges highlight the complex task of reintegrating offenders while maintaining public safety and justice system integrity.

Parole eligibility requirements

• Parole is a conditional release from prison that allows an offender to serve the remainder of their sentence in the community under supervision
• Eligibility for parole varies by jurisdiction and is typically based on a combination of factors related to the offender's sentence, behavior, and rehabilitation efforts

Minimum sentence completion

Top images from around the web for Minimum sentence completion

• 

  9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.10. Restorative Justice – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  United States | The Visual Everything View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.10. Restorative Justice – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Minimum sentence completion

• 

  9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.10. Restorative Justice – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  United States | The Visual Everything View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.2. Intermediate Sanctions – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  9.10. Restorative Justice – SOU-CCJ230 Introduction to the American Criminal Justice System View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Most states require offenders to serve a minimum portion of their sentence before becoming eligible for parole consideration
  • This minimum term is often a percentage of the total sentence (e.g., 25%, 50%, 85%)
  • Some states have abolished parole for certain crimes, requiring offenders to serve their entire sentence in prison
• Offenders sentenced to life imprisonment may become eligible for parole after serving a specified number of years (e.g., 25 years)
• Some jurisdictions have implemented "truth in sentencing" laws that require offenders to serve a substantial portion of their sentence before parole eligibility

Good behavior and rehabilitation

• Inmates who demonstrate good behavior and participate in rehabilitation programs may become eligible for parole earlier or more likely to be granted parole
  • Good behavior includes following prison rules, avoiding disciplinary infractions, and maintaining positive relationships with staff and other inmates
• Rehabilitation efforts may include completing educational programs (GED, vocational training), participating in counseling or therapy (substance abuse treatment, anger management), and engaging in work assignments or community service
• Parole boards often consider an inmate's level of remorse, acceptance of responsibility, and plans for reintegration into society when making release decisions

Parole board hearings

• Parole board hearings are proceedings in which a panel of appointed officials reviews an inmate's case and determines whether to grant parole
• The parole board considers various factors, including the inmate's criminal history, institutional behavior, rehabilitation efforts, and risk to public safety

Inmate interviews and testimony

• During parole hearings, inmates have the opportunity to present their case for release and answer questions from the parole board
  • Inmates may discuss their personal background, the circumstances of their crime, their experiences in prison, and their plans for the future
• Inmates may also present evidence of their rehabilitation, such as certificates of program completion, letters of support from family or community members, and job offers or housing arrangements
• In some cases, inmates may be represented by an attorney who can advocate on their behalf and help them navigate the parole process

Victim impact statements

• Victims of the inmate's crime or their family members may be allowed to provide input during the parole hearing through victim impact statements
  • These statements describe the physical, emotional, and financial harm caused by the crime and express the victim's opinion on whether the inmate should be granted parole
• Parole boards consider victim impact statements to assess the ongoing impact of the crime on the victim and the community
• Some jurisdictions require parole boards to notify victims of upcoming hearings and allow them to attend or submit statements in writing or via video

Risk assessment and public safety

• Parole boards use risk assessment tools to evaluate an inmate's likelihood of reoffending if released on parole
  • These tools consider factors such as the inmate's age, criminal history, substance abuse issues, and social support network to predict their risk level (low, medium, high)
• The parole board weighs the inmate's risk level against their demonstrated rehabilitation and release plan to determine whether they pose a threat to public safety
• In cases involving violent or high-profile crimes, the parole board may prioritize public safety concerns and set stricter release conditions or deny parole altogether

Parole conditions and supervision

• If granted parole, offenders must abide by a set of conditions designed to promote their successful reintegration into society and prevent recidivism
• Parole conditions are tailored to the individual offender and may include restrictions on their activities, associations, and movements

Mandatory check-ins with parole officer

• Parolees are required to report regularly to their assigned parole officer, who monitors their compliance with release conditions and provides guidance and support
  • Check-ins may occur in person, by phone, or through electronic monitoring devices (GPS ankle bracelets)
• Parole officers have the authority to visit parolees' homes or workplaces, administer drug tests, and search their property for contraband
• Failure to report to the parole officer or being dishonest during check-ins can result in a violation of parole and potential return to prison

Substance abuse testing and treatment

• Many parolees have a history of substance abuse, which is often linked to their criminal behavior
  • As a condition of parole, offenders may be required to submit to random drug tests and participate in substance abuse treatment programs (counseling, 12-step meetings)
• Positive drug tests or failure to attend mandated treatment sessions can lead to parole violations and sanctions, such as increased supervision or brief periods of reincarceration
• Successful completion of substance abuse treatment is often a key factor in maintaining parole and avoiding recidivism

Employment and housing restrictions

• Parole conditions may include requirements related to the offender's employment and housing to promote stability and reduce the risk of reoffending
  • Parolees may be required to seek and maintain steady employment or participate in job training programs
  • Some parolees may be prohibited from working in certain industries or positions (e.g., jobs involving children or vulnerable populations)
• Housing restrictions may limit where parolees can live based on the nature of their crime or proximity to victims
  • Sex offenders may be prohibited from living near schools or playgrounds
  • Parolees may be required to live in halfway houses or other transitional housing until they secure permanent residence

Parole revocation and recidivism

• Parole can be revoked if the offender violates the conditions of their release or commits a new crime
• Revocation of parole results in the offender being returned to prison to serve the remainder of their sentence or face new charges

Violation of parole conditions

• Parole officers have the discretion to address minor violations, such as missed check-ins or failed drug tests, through warnings, increased supervision, or brief periods of detention
  • Repeated or serious violations, such as leaving the jurisdiction without permission or associating with known criminals, can result in a revocation hearing before the parole board
• At the revocation hearing, the parole board reviews evidence of the violation and determines whether to revoke parole or modify the conditions of release
• If parole is revoked, the offender is returned to prison to serve the remainder of their sentence, with credit for time served on parole

New criminal charges and convictions

• If a parolee is arrested and charged with a new crime, they face both the revocation of their parole and prosecution for the new offense
  • The parole board may choose to revoke parole based on the new charges, even if the offender has not yet been convicted
• A conviction for a new crime while on parole typically results in the automatic revocation of parole and a return to prison
• In some cases, the sentence for the new crime may be served consecutively with the remainder of the original sentence, resulting in a longer period of incarceration

Reincarceration and sentencing

• Reincarceration following a parole violation or new conviction can have significant consequences for the offender and the criminal justice system
  • Returning parolees to prison contributes to overcrowding and increases the cost of incarceration for taxpayers
• Some states have implemented intermediate sanctions or graduated responses to parole violations to reduce the use of reincarceration for minor or technical violations
  • These sanctions may include increased supervision, electronic monitoring, or short stays in local jails or residential treatment facilities
• Sentencing practices for parole violations and new crimes committed on parole vary by jurisdiction and may be influenced by public safety concerns and political pressures

Parole vs probation

• Parole and probation are both forms of community supervision that allow offenders to serve their sentences outside of prison, but they differ in key ways
• Understanding the similarities and differences between parole and probation is important for offenders, victims, and the general public

Similarities in community supervision

• Both parole and probation involve the offender being supervised by a trained officer who monitors their compliance with release conditions
  • Offenders on parole or probation must report regularly to their supervising officer, maintain employment or attend school, and refrain from criminal activity
• Parole and probation may include similar conditions, such as drug testing, counseling, and restrictions on travel or association with certain individuals
• Violations of parole or probation conditions can result in sanctions, including increased supervision, brief periods of detention, or revocation of release

Key differences in eligibility and revocation

• Parole is granted to offenders who have served a portion of their prison sentence, while probation is typically ordered by a judge as an alternative to incarceration
  • Eligibility for parole is based on factors such as the offender's crime, sentence length, and institutional behavior, while probation eligibility depends on the nature of the offense and the offender's criminal history
• Parole is a discretionary release decision made by a parole board, while probation is a sentencing option available to judges
  • The parole board has the authority to grant or deny parole and set release conditions, while judges determine the length and conditions of probation at sentencing
• Revocation of parole results in the offender being returned to prison to serve the remainder of their sentence, while revocation of probation may lead to the imposition of the original prison sentence or a modified sentence

Controversies surrounding parole

• The parole system has been the subject of ongoing debate and criticism, with concerns raised about inconsistencies in decision-making, high-profile cases, and the need for reform
• Addressing these controversies is important for ensuring public safety, promoting offender rehabilitation, and maintaining the integrity of the criminal justice system

Inconsistencies in parole board decisions

• Parole board decisions have been criticized for lacking transparency and consistency, with similar cases resulting in different outcomes
  • Factors such as the composition of the parole board, political pressures, and public opinion may influence release decisions
• Some states have implemented structured decision-making frameworks or parole guidelines to promote consistency and fairness in the parole process
  • These frameworks provide objective criteria for evaluating an offender's risk and readiness for release, reducing the potential for bias or subjectivity
• Concerns have also been raised about the limited time and resources available for parole hearings, which may hinder the board's ability to thoroughly review each case

High-profile cases and media attention

• High-profile crimes and cases involving controversial parole decisions often attract significant media attention and public outcry
  • The release of offenders convicted of violent or heinous crimes, such as murder or sexual assault, can generate strong emotional responses from victims, their families, and the general public
• Media coverage of these cases may influence public perception of the parole system and create pressure on parole boards to deny release or impose stricter conditions
• Balancing the public's safety concerns with the offender's rights and rehabilitation needs can be a challenging task for parole boards in high-profile cases

Calls for parole system reform

• Critics of the parole system have called for various reforms to address perceived shortcomings and improve outcomes for offenders and society
  • Some advocates argue for the elimination of parole in favor of determinate sentencing, in which offenders serve a fixed term without the possibility of early release
• Others propose reforms to the parole decision-making process, such as increasing transparency, involving victims and community members, and providing greater support for offender reentry
• Efforts to reduce recidivism and promote successful reintegration have led to the development of evidence-based practices in parole supervision, such as risk and needs assessment, targeted interventions, and graduated sanctions
• Addressing racial and socioeconomic disparities in the parole system is another area of focus for reform efforts, as minority and low-income offenders may face additional barriers to release and successful reentry