10.2 The Great Firewall and internet governance in China
3 min read•august 9, 2024
China's is a massive internet censorship system. It blocks foreign websites, filters content, and monitors online activity. This creates a distinct Chinese internet ecosystem separate from the global network.
The government justifies this control as protecting and . It promotes "" internationally, challenging the idea of a globally open internet. This shapes China's approach to .
Internet Censorship in China
The Great Firewall and Golden Shield Project
Top images from around the web for The Great Firewall and Golden Shield Project
Great Firewall of China | The Chinese government has blocked… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
The Evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 Years of Censorship · Global Voices View original
Is this image relevant?
The Evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 Years of Censorship · Global Voices View original
Is this image relevant?
Great Firewall of China | The Chinese government has blocked… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
The Evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 Years of Censorship · Global Voices View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for The Great Firewall and Golden Shield Project
Great Firewall of China | The Chinese government has blocked… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
The Evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 Years of Censorship · Global Voices View original
Is this image relevant?
The Evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 Years of Censorship · Global Voices View original
Is this image relevant?
Great Firewall of China | The Chinese government has blocked… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
The Evolution of China’s Great Firewall: 21 Years of Censorship · Global Voices View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Great Firewall functions as China's primary internet censorship and surveillance system
- Implemented in the late 1990s as part of the
- Golden Shield Project encompasses broader technological initiatives for domestic security
- Employs advanced filtering techniques to block access to foreign websites and content
- Restricts information flow between China's domestic internet and the global network
Content Filtering and Keyword Blocking Mechanisms
- analyzes and blocks websites, social media posts, and online communications
- Utilizes sophisticated algorithms to detect and censor sensitive topics or criticism of the government
- targets specific words, phrases, or combinations related to political dissent
- Dynamically updates blocked terms based on current events and emerging sensitive issues
- Employs machine learning to improve detection of circumvention attempts
Impact and Effectiveness of Internet Censorship
- Creates a distinct Chinese internet ecosystem separate from the global internet
- Limits Chinese citizens' access to foreign news sources, social media platforms, and information
- Fosters development of domestic alternatives to popular international websites and services
- Challenges foreign companies operating in China to comply with censorship regulations
- Raises concerns about freedom of expression and access to information within China
Technical Mechanisms of the Great Firewall
DNS Poisoning and IP Blocking
- manipulates Domain Name System responses to redirect or block access to websites
- Intercepts DNS queries for blocked domains and returns false IP addresses or error messages
- prevents connections to specific IP addresses associated with banned content
- Combines DNS poisoning with IP blocking to create a multi-layered censorship approach
- Regularly updates blocked IP addresses to counteract attempts to circumvent restrictions
VPN Usage and Countermeasures
- Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) encrypt internet traffic and route it through servers outside China
- Allows users to bypass the Great Firewall and access blocked content
- Chinese government actively works to detect and block VPN connections
- Implements deep packet inspection to identify and disrupt VPN protocols
- Requires VPN providers to obtain government licenses, limiting availability of unrestricted services
Emerging Technologies and Censorship Evolution
- Employs machine learning algorithms to improve detection of censorship circumvention attempts
- Utilizes traffic pattern analysis to identify and block encrypted connections
- Implements SSL/TLS interception to inspect encrypted HTTPS traffic
- Adapts to new circumvention tools and techniques, creating an ongoing "cat and mouse" game
- Explores blockchain and AI technologies to enhance censorship capabilities
China's Stance on Internet Governance
Cyber Sovereignty and National Security
- Cyber sovereignty asserts China's right to regulate its domestic internet space
- Emphasizes national security and social stability as justifications for internet control
- Promotes the concept of "" aligned with national boundaries
- Advocates for increased government control over internet infrastructure and content
- Challenges the notion of a globally open and interconnected internet
International Advocacy and Policy Influence
- Pushes for recognition of cyber sovereignty in international forums (United Nations, ITU)
- Seeks to shape global internet governance norms and standards
- Collaborates with like-minded countries to promote state-centric internet control models
- Opposes Western-dominated internet governance structures (ICANN, IETF)
- Proposes alternative governance frameworks centered on national authority and control
Domestic Internet Industry Development
- Encourages growth of domestic tech giants (Baidu, Alibaba, Tencent) within controlled environment
- Implements data localization requirements for foreign companies operating in China
- Promotes indigenous technology development to reduce reliance on foreign internet infrastructure
- Balances economic benefits of internet industry with political control objectives
- Leverages market access as a bargaining chip in negotiations with foreign tech companies
Key Terms to Review (26)
2019 Hong Kong protests: The 2019 Hong Kong protests were a series of demonstrations and civil unrest that began in March 2019, primarily in response to a proposed extradition bill that would allow individuals to be sent to mainland China for trial. The protests grew to encompass broader demands for democracy, police accountability, and the protection of Hong Kong's autonomy under the 'one country, two systems' framework. This significant movement highlighted the complexities of internet governance and the use of technology in organizing protests in an era where censorship and surveillance are prevalent.
Content filtering: Content filtering refers to the practice of restricting access to certain online information or websites based on predefined criteria. This process is often utilized by governments and organizations to control what information can be accessed, ensuring that only approved content is available to users. In the context of internet governance, it plays a significant role in shaping online discourse and influencing public opinion.
Cyber diplomacy: Cyber diplomacy refers to the use of diplomatic methods to manage international relations and conflicts in cyberspace, focusing on issues such as cybersecurity, internet governance, and the regulation of digital technologies. It involves countries engaging in discussions, negotiations, and collaborations to address the challenges posed by the digital realm, including cyberattacks and data privacy. This form of diplomacy is increasingly important as nations navigate the complexities of a connected world, particularly with regard to their own internet policies and regulations.
Cyber sovereignty: Cyber sovereignty refers to the principle that a state has the authority to govern its own cyberspace without external interference, emphasizing control over the internet and digital resources within its borders. This concept highlights the importance of national security, political stability, and cultural integrity in the digital realm, allowing governments to establish regulations, censorship, and surveillance mechanisms to protect their interests.
Digital authoritarianism: Digital authoritarianism refers to the use of digital technologies by governments to monitor, control, and suppress political dissent and social movements. This approach leverages the internet and advanced surveillance tools to enforce state control over information, limit free expression, and manipulate public opinion, thus allowing regimes to maintain power in the digital age.
Digital Divide: The digital divide refers to the gap between individuals and communities that have access to modern information and communication technology and those that do not. This disparity can lead to significant inequalities in education, economic opportunity, and social engagement, highlighting critical issues in a rapidly digitizing world.
Dns poisoning: DNS poisoning, also known as DNS spoofing, is a cyber attack that manipulates the Domain Name System (DNS) data to redirect users from legitimate websites to malicious ones. This tactic exploits the way DNS translates human-readable domain names into IP addresses, effectively misleading users and enabling cybercriminals to intercept sensitive information or distribute malware.
Golden Shield Project: The Golden Shield Project is an extensive state-run initiative in China aimed at establishing a sophisticated surveillance and censorship system to monitor and control internet usage. This project underpins the broader internet governance strategy in China, facilitating the Great Firewall, which blocks or restricts access to foreign websites and information deemed undesirable by the government.
Governance through technology: Governance through technology refers to the use of digital tools and platforms by governments to manage, monitor, and interact with their citizens. This approach often aims to enhance efficiency, transparency, and control over information flows. In the context of internet governance in China, it embodies how the government utilizes technology to enforce regulations, restrict access to information, and facilitate surveillance.
Great Firewall: The Great Firewall refers to China's extensive system of internet censorship and surveillance that blocks access to selected foreign websites and regulates internet traffic. This mechanism serves to control the flow of information within China, shaping public opinion and limiting exposure to outside influences, which is a significant challenge in the contemporary political landscape.
Information Sovereignty: Information sovereignty refers to a nation's control over its own digital data, communications, and internet infrastructure, asserting its right to govern and regulate information flow within its borders. This concept emphasizes a country’s authority to establish laws and policies concerning data management, cybersecurity, and internet access, which is especially significant in the context of global digital communication. It reflects the intersection of national security, political autonomy, and economic interests.
Internet borders: Internet borders refer to the invisible boundaries that separate different national jurisdictions and dictate how online content is accessed and controlled. These borders are shaped by various factors, including national laws, regulations, and government policies, which affect what information can be accessed and shared across the internet within a specific country.
Internet freedom advocacy: Internet freedom advocacy refers to the efforts and initiatives aimed at promoting open access to the internet, protecting online rights, and resisting censorship. This advocacy is particularly crucial in contexts where governments impose strict controls on digital information, limiting citizens' access to knowledge and stifling free expression. In regions like China, internet freedom advocacy confronts challenges from significant state-led censorship efforts, such as the Great Firewall, which restricts access to certain foreign websites and monitors online activities.
Internet governance: Internet governance refers to the development and application of shared principles, norms, rules, and decision-making procedures that shape the evolution and use of the internet. It encompasses a wide range of issues, including regulation, security, privacy, and the management of internet resources. In the context of China, internet governance is largely characterized by the state's control and censorship mechanisms, most notably the Great Firewall, which influences how information is accessed and disseminated online.
Ip blocking: IP blocking is a method used to prevent specific internet protocol addresses from accessing a network or website. This technique is a crucial aspect of internet governance, especially in restrictive regimes like China, where it plays a significant role in controlling the flow of information and limiting access to foreign websites.
Keyword blocking: Keyword blocking is a technique used in internet censorship where specific words or phrases are filtered and blocked from being accessed on the internet. This method is part of a broader strategy to control online content, limit freedom of expression, and suppress dissent by preventing users from finding information related to sensitive topics.
Lu wei: Lu wei refers to the system of Chinese internet censorship and surveillance that prioritizes state control over online content and information dissemination. This approach encompasses various techniques and technologies designed to restrict access to certain websites and regulate the flow of information, thereby influencing public discourse in China. By maintaining a tight grip on the internet, the government aims to uphold social stability and prevent the spread of dissenting views or political opposition.
National security: National security refers to the protection and defense of a nation's sovereignty, territorial integrity, and citizens from threats, including military aggression, terrorism, and espionage. It encompasses a range of policies and measures that governments implement to safeguard their nation from both external and internal dangers, often prioritizing stability and order. In the context of internet governance, national security plays a crucial role in shaping regulations and practices aimed at controlling digital information flow and protecting against cyber threats.
Network Governance: Network governance refers to a collaborative framework where multiple stakeholders, including government, private sector, and civil society, work together to achieve common goals and address complex societal issues. This approach emphasizes the importance of interconnectedness and shared responsibilities among various actors, enhancing coordination and efficiency in policy implementation. In particular, network governance plays a crucial role in local government structures and the management of internet governance, where different levels of authority and organizations interact to navigate challenges.
Network surveillance: Network surveillance refers to the monitoring and collection of data transmitted over digital networks, typically carried out by governments or organizations to track online activities. This practice is a significant aspect of internet governance, particularly in contexts where authorities aim to control information flow and maintain social order. It raises concerns regarding privacy, censorship, and human rights as state actors increasingly utilize surveillance technologies to monitor citizens' online behaviors.
Self-censorship: Self-censorship is the practice of individuals or organizations limiting their own expression, often due to fear of repercussions or societal pressure. It arises in environments where external censorship is prevalent, influencing the media and public discourse. This behavior can lead to a chilling effect, where people avoid discussing certain topics or sharing opinions that might be deemed controversial or unacceptable.
Social credit system: The social credit system is a nationwide initiative in China that aims to assess and rank the trustworthiness of individuals, businesses, and organizations based on their behavior and social interactions. It utilizes data from various sources, including financial transactions, online activity, and social behavior, to create a comprehensive profile that can influence access to services, employment opportunities, and public resources.
Social Stability: Social stability refers to the condition in which a society maintains order, cohesion, and continuity, minimizing social unrest and conflict. In the context of governance, it is seen as crucial for fostering economic development, political legitimacy, and national unity. A stable society is characterized by strong institutions that respond effectively to public grievances, maintain social harmony, and promote the welfare of citizens.
Tiananmen Square Censorship: Tiananmen Square censorship refers to the strict suppression and control of information surrounding the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests in China, where pro-democracy demonstrations were violently quelled by the government. This censorship is a key component of China's broader strategy to manage public discourse, particularly through digital platforms and traditional media, preventing any discussion or acknowledgment of the events of June 4th. It highlights the extent of state control over narratives and the lengths to which the government will go to maintain its authority and prevent dissent.
Vpn usage: VPN usage refers to the practice of utilizing Virtual Private Networks to create a secure connection over the internet. This technology allows users to mask their IP address and encrypt their online activities, making it particularly important for individuals seeking to bypass restrictions imposed by governmental censorship, such as the Great Firewall in China, while enhancing their privacy and security online.
Xi Jinping: Xi Jinping is the General Secretary of the Communist Party of China and the President of the People's Republic of China, having assumed power in 2012. His leadership is characterized by a strong emphasis on consolidating power, promoting economic reform, and asserting China's role on the global stage.