8.3 Subcommittee and full committee consideration
4 min read•july 30, 2024
Subcommittees play a crucial role in Congress, focusing on specific policy areas within full committees. They hold , draft legislation, and make recommendations, allowing for and efficient handling of a large volume of bills.
The legislative process in committees involves scheduling hearings, selecting witnesses, and conducting markups. Committees debate and amend bills before voting to report them to the full chamber, with reports providing context and analysis for lawmakers and stakeholders.
Subcommittees in the Legislative Process
Role and Relationship to Full Committees
Top images from around the web for Role and Relationship to Full Committees
Chapter 46: Strategies of Organized Interests – Attenuated Democracy View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: The Legislative Process – American Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 46: Strategies of Organized Interests – Attenuated Democracy View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Role and Relationship to Full Committees
Chapter 46: Strategies of Organized Interests – Attenuated Democracy View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: The Legislative Process – American Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Chapter 46: Strategies of Organized Interests – Attenuated Democracy View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Subcommittees are specialized units within full committees that focus on specific policy areas or issues under the jurisdiction of the (agriculture, education)
- Subcommittees are responsible for conducting hearings, investigating issues, drafting legislation, and providing recommendations to the full committee
- Subcommittees have their own chairs, ranking members, and staff, who are typically members or staff of the full committee (House Judiciary on Immigration and Citizenship)
- Subcommittee membership is determined by the full committee chair, often in consultation with the and party leadership
Legislative Workflow
- Legislation is typically referred first to a subcommittee for consideration before being taken up by the full committee
- Subcommittees may hold hearings, markups, and votes on legislation before reporting it to the full committee (House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health)
- Full committees may choose to further amend, approve, or reject legislation reported by subcommittees
- Subcommittees allow for specialization and division of labor within Congress, enabling members to develop expertise in specific policy areas (healthcare, national security) and handle a larger volume of legislation
Scheduling and Conducting Committee Hearings
Scheduling and Witness Selection
- Committee hearings are formal proceedings where committees gather information and expert testimony on specific issues or legislation
- The committee chair, in consultation with the ranking member, is responsible for scheduling hearings and determining the agenda
- Hearings may be called to investigate issues, gather information, or consider specific legislation (House Committee hearings on government waste)
- Witnesses, including government officials, experts, stakeholders, and members of the public, may be invited or subpoenaed to testify at hearings (Cabinet secretaries, academic experts)
Hearing Format and Transparency
- Committees typically allow each witness to provide an opening statement, followed by questioning from committee members
- Questioning is typically conducted in rounds, with each committee member allotted a specific amount of time (5-minute rounds)
- Members may use their questioning time to gather information, clarify positions, or advance political arguments
- Hearings are typically open to the public and media, although committees may hold closed hearings for sensitive or classified matters (intelligence committee hearings)
- Transcripts of hearings are typically made available to the public, serving as an official record of the proceedings
Committee Markups and Amendments
Markup Process
- Committee markups are formal meetings where committees consider, debate, and amend legislation before voting to report it to the full chamber
- Markups typically begin with opening statements from the committee chair and ranking member, followed by consideration of amendments
- Amendments may be offered by any committee member and are typically considered in the order specified by the committee's rules
- Amendments may be adopted by unanimous consent, voice , or recorded vote, depending on the committee's rules and the preferences of members (roll call votes)
Amendment Management
- The committee chair manages the , recognizing members to offer amendments and controlling debate
- The chair may rule amendments out of order if they are not germane to the legislation or violate other procedural rules (amendments outside the committee's jurisdiction)
- The minority party is typically guaranteed the right to offer a certain number of amendments, even if they are not adopted (motion to recommit)
- Once all amendments have been considered, the committee votes on whether to report the legislation to the full chamber, either with or without a favorable recommendation
- Committees may also hold markups to consider and approve committee reports, which accompany legislation and provide additional context and analysis
Committee Reports and Minority Views
Purpose and Content of Committee Reports
- Committee reports are official documents that accompany legislation reported out of committee and provide additional context, analysis, and justification for the committee's actions
- Reports typically include a summary of the legislation, an explanation of its purpose and provisions, and a section-by-section analysis
- Reports may also include cost estimates from the Congressional Budget Office, as well as statements from relevant executive branch agencies (Office of Management and Budget)
- The committee chair is responsible for preparing and filing the committee report, although staff typically draft the actual document
Significance in Legislative Interpretation
- Committee reports are used by members, staff, and outside stakeholders to understand the intent and implications of legislation
- Reports may be cited in floor debates, legal briefs, and court opinions as evidence of congressional intent (Supreme Court cases)
- Reports are typically considered persuasive, but not binding, in interpreting the meaning of legislation
- Minority views, authored by the ranking member or other dissenting committee members, may be included in committee reports to express disagreement or alternative perspectives
- Minority views may critique the legislation, offer alternative proposals, or raise procedural objections to the committee's actions
- Including minority views in committee reports is a way for the minority party to formally register its dissent and shape the legislative record (dissenting opinions)
Key Terms to Review (18)
Agenda-setting: Agenda-setting is the process through which certain issues are prioritized and emphasized in public discourse, influencing which topics are seen as important by policymakers and the public. This concept plays a critical role in shaping legislative priorities, determining what gets debated in committees, and guiding media coverage, thus affecting the broader political landscape.
Amendment process: The amendment process refers to the formal procedure through which changes or additions can be made to a constitution or legislative document. This process is crucial in shaping laws and policies, allowing for flexibility and adaptation over time, while ensuring a structured approach to significant alterations. It typically involves multiple stages, including proposal and ratification, which require broad consensus among lawmakers and the public.
Chairperson: A chairperson is the leader of a committee or organization responsible for guiding meetings, facilitating discussions, and ensuring that the group stays on task and follows established procedures. This role is vital for effective decision-making and organization, especially when it comes to the referral of legislation to committees and managing the workflow of subcommittees and full committees.
Cloture: Cloture is a procedural mechanism in the U.S. Senate used to end a filibuster and bring a debate to a close, allowing the Senate to move forward with voting on a bill or nomination. This process is crucial for maintaining order and efficiency in legislative proceedings, especially when dealing with controversial issues that could lead to prolonged debates.
Conference report: A conference report is a formal document that outlines the final agreements and compromises reached during a conference committee's deliberations on proposed legislation. This report is crucial because it represents the collaborative efforts of both chambers of Congress to reconcile differences in their versions of a bill. Once approved by both the House and Senate, the conference report is sent to the President for approval or veto.
Floor debate: Floor debate refers to the stage in the legislative process where members of a legislative body discuss, argue, and negotiate the merits of a bill before it is voted on. This occurs after a bill has been reported out of committee and signifies the opportunity for lawmakers to express their opinions, propose amendments, and influence the final outcome of legislation.
Full committee: A full committee is a group within a legislative body, such as Congress, that consists of all its members and is responsible for reviewing legislation and overseeing specific areas of policy. This committee plays a crucial role in the legislative process, as it evaluates and debates proposed bills, holds hearings, and can amend legislation before it is sent to the entire legislative body for a vote. The full committee acts after the subcommittees have done their initial work and represents a broader view of the interests and concerns of the legislative body.
Gatekeeping: Gatekeeping refers to the process through which information, legislation, or decisions are filtered and controlled by individuals or groups in positions of authority. This concept is crucial in legislative settings as it determines which bills progress through the legislative process and which are stalled or dismissed, influencing the outcome of policymaking and resource allocation.
Hearings: Hearings are formal sessions held by committees in Congress where they gather information, question witnesses, and discuss proposed legislation or issues of public concern. These sessions serve as a vital part of the legislative process, enabling both subcommittees and full committees to examine evidence and receive testimony that informs their decisions on legislation or oversight activities.
Majority report: A majority report is a document that reflects the views and recommendations of the majority of members within a committee or subcommittee in Congress regarding a proposed piece of legislation. This report outlines the rationale for the majority's position, including supporting arguments and proposed amendments, which guides the full chamber's discussion and decision-making process.
Markup: Markup refers to the process by which committees or subcommittees in Congress review, amend, and revise proposed legislation before it is sent to the full chamber for consideration. This stage is critical as it allows for detailed scrutiny of the bill, leading to changes that reflect the interests of various stakeholders and parties involved in the legislative process.
Oversight: Oversight refers to the process by which Congress monitors and evaluates the actions and operations of the executive branch, ensuring that laws are implemented effectively and that federal agencies are held accountable. This function is critical for maintaining a system of checks and balances, as it empowers Congress to investigate, review, and influence executive actions.
Quorum: Quorum is the minimum number of members required to be present for a legislative body to conduct its business legally. This concept is essential for ensuring that decisions made by Congress represent a sufficient segment of its members, providing legitimacy to legislative actions and preventing a small group from making decisions on behalf of the whole.
Ranking member: A ranking member is a senior member of a congressional committee who belongs to the minority party, serving as the lead voice for that party within the committee. This role is crucial for maintaining balance and representation during the legislative process, particularly during discussions of policy and committee votes.
Reporting out: Reporting out is the process by which committees or subcommittees communicate the results of their deliberations and decisions, often involving recommendations on legislation to the full legislative body. This step is crucial as it transitions the work done in committee into the broader legislative process, allowing the full chamber to consider, debate, and vote on proposed measures.
Specialization: Specialization refers to the process by which individuals or groups focus on a specific area of expertise or task, enabling them to perform their roles more efficiently and effectively. In the context of legislative bodies, this concept allows committees and subcommittees to concentrate on particular issues, fostering deeper knowledge and informed decision-making regarding proposed legislation.
Subcommittee: A subcommittee is a smaller, specialized group formed within a larger committee in the legislative process. These smaller groups focus on specific areas of legislation or oversight, allowing for more detailed examination and discussion of issues before they are presented to the full committee. The establishment of subcommittees enhances efficiency and ensures that members can concentrate on particular topics relevant to their expertise or interest.
Vote: A vote is a formal expression of preference or decision, typically within a democratic context, where individuals indicate their choice regarding a proposal, candidate, or policy. Voting serves as a fundamental mechanism for public participation in governance, allowing citizens to influence legislation and leadership through their selections. It is a critical aspect of the legislative process, especially during subcommittee and full committee consideration, as votes determine the fate of bills and policies before they reach the larger legislative body.