8.4 Reporting bills to the floor
5 min read•july 30, 2024
Reporting bills to the floor is a crucial step in the legislative process. After a committee approves a bill, it's sent to the full chamber with a comprehensive report explaining its provisions, findings, and arguments for and against it. This report shapes the upcoming .
Committees can report bills favorably, unfavorably, or without recommendation. They may also draft original bills or clean up existing ones. Once reported, bills move to the floor for debate and voting, setting the stage for potential passage and advancement to the other chamber.
Committee Reports and Floor Debate
The Committee Report: A Comprehensive Document
Top images from around the web for The Committee Report: A Comprehensive Document
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Committee Reports - Federal Legislative History - Research Guides at Florida State University ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Documents - Federal Legislative History - Research Guides at Florida State University College of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Committee Reports - Federal Legislative History - Research Guides at Florida State University ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for The Committee Report: A Comprehensive Document
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Committee Reports - Federal Legislative History - Research Guides at Florida State University ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Documents - Federal Legislative History - Research Guides at Florida State University College of ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
Committee Reports - Federal Legislative History - Research Guides at Florida State University ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- The is a comprehensive document that accompanies a bill when it is reported out of committee
- Includes an explanation of the bill's provisions, the committee's findings, and arguments for and against the measure
- Serves as a valuable resource for members of Congress and their staff, providing insight into the committee's deliberations and the intent behind the legislation
- Can help shape the floor debate by highlighting key issues and guiding the discussion
- Minority views, if any, are also included in the committee report
- These dissenting opinions provide an opportunity for committee members who oppose the bill to express their concerns and propose alternative approaches
Significance of Committee Reports in Shaping Floor Debate
- Committee reports play a crucial role in informing and influencing the floor debate on a bill
- Provide a detailed analysis of the bill's provisions, background information, and the committee's rationale for its recommendations
- Offer guidance to members of Congress on the key issues and points of contention surrounding the legislation
- Help structure the floor debate by identifying the main arguments for and against the bill
- Serve as a reference point for members and their staff during the debate, providing a foundation for discussion and decision-making
- For example, members may cite the committee report to support their positions or challenge the committee's findings
Options for Committee Reports
Reporting Bills Favorably, Unfavorably, or Without Recommendation
- After considering a bill, a committee will hold a mark-up session to debate, amend, and vote on the measure
- If a majority of the committee agrees to report the bill, it is sent to the full chamber for consideration
- Committees have three options when reporting a bill: favorably, unfavorably, or without recommendation
- A favorable report indicates the committee's endorsement of the bill and its recommendation for passage
- An unfavorable report suggests the committee's opposition to the bill and its recommendation against passage
- Reporting a bill without recommendation means the committee is neutral on the measure and does not take a position on its passage
- If a bill is reported favorably or without recommendation, it is typically placed on the appropriate for floor consideration
- For example, in the House, bills affecting revenue or appropriations are placed on the Union Calendar
- Bills reported unfavorably are usually not considered further, although they can still be brought up on the floor through special procedures
Reporting Original Bills and Clean Bills
- In addition to reporting introduced bills, committees have the option to report original bills or clean bills
- An original bill is a measure that is drafted and introduced by the committee itself, rather than being referred to the committee
- This allows the committee to initiate legislation on a specific issue within its jurisdiction
- Clean bills are introduced bills that have been extensively revised by the committee during the mark-up process
- The committee may choose to report a clean bill to incorporate the amendments and present a more cohesive and refined version of the legislation
- Committees may also report a bill with amendments, which are changes made to the original text of the measure during the mark-up session
- These amendments can range from minor technical corrections to substantial policy changes
- For example, a committee may adopt an to modify the eligibility criteria for a grant program established in the bill
Reporting Bills Out of Committee
Implications of Reporting a Bill Out of Committee
- When a bill is reported out of committee, it is a significant milestone in the legislative process
- Indicates that the measure has gained the support of a majority of the committee members and is ready for consideration by the full chamber
- The bill is then placed on the appropriate calendar, which determines the order in which bills will be considered on the floor
- In the House, reported bills are typically considered under one of three procedures: the regular order, the suspension of the rules, or a special rule reported by the Rules Committee
- In the Senate, reported bills are usually considered under the regular order, which allows for extensive debate and amendment
- Reporting a bill out of committee sets the stage for the next phase of the legislative process: floor consideration and debate
Next Steps in the Legislative Process
- Once a bill is reported out of committee, it moves to the floor of the respective chamber for consideration
- In the House, the Rules Committee plays a key role in determining how the bill will be considered on the floor
- The Rules Committee may report a special rule that sets the parameters for debate, including time limits and amendment opportunities
- In the Senate, the bill is typically considered under the regular order, which allows for unlimited debate and amendment
- However, the Senate may choose to invoke cloture to limit debate or use unanimous consent agreements to structure the floor proceedings
- During floor consideration, members engage in debate on the bill, offer amendments, and ultimately vote on its passage
- If the bill passes one chamber, it is sent to the other chamber for consideration, where the process begins anew with committee referral and potential amendments
- If both chambers pass identical versions of the bill, it is sent to the President for signature or veto
- If the chambers pass different versions, a may be appointed to reconcile the differences and produce a final bill for approval by both chambers
Key Terms to Review (19)
Amendment: An amendment is a formal change or addition proposed to a bill or legislation, aimed at improving or altering its content before it becomes law. Amendments can be introduced during various stages of the legislative process, allowing lawmakers to refine the language, address concerns, or introduce new provisions. They play a crucial role in shaping the final form of legislation as they undergo discussion and debate among legislators.
Bill sponsorship: Bill sponsorship refers to the process where a member of Congress formally introduces a proposed piece of legislation, advocating for its consideration and support within the legislative body. This role is crucial as sponsors help to outline the purpose of the bill, garner co-sponsors, and guide it through various stages of the legislative process, including committee review and potential floor debate.
Calendar: In the context of Congress, a calendar is an official schedule that outlines when bills and resolutions are set for consideration on the floor for debate and voting. It plays a crucial role in managing the legislative process, helping organize the agenda and ensuring that bills receive timely attention based on their priority and urgency.
Closed rule: A closed rule is a procedural mechanism in the legislative process that restricts or eliminates the ability of members to amend a bill during debate on the floor. This rule allows for a more expedited consideration of legislation by limiting discussion to the bill as it was reported out of committee, thus preventing additional changes or alterations by other members.
Committee chair: A committee chair is a member of a legislative body who leads and oversees the activities of a specific committee. This position is crucial as the chairperson organizes meetings, guides discussions, and ensures that the committee effectively carries out its responsibilities, including reporting bills to the floor and conducting hearings and markups.
Committee report: A committee report is a formal document produced by a legislative committee that outlines the findings, conclusions, and recommendations regarding a specific bill or issue. This report serves as a crucial step in the legislative process, summarizing the committee's discussions, proposed amendments, and the rationale behind their recommendations to help inform other members of the legislature before they vote on the bill.
Conference committee: A conference committee is a temporary panel composed of members from both the House of Representatives and the Senate, formed to reconcile differences in legislation that has passed both chambers. This process ensures that a unified version of a bill is produced before it is sent to the President for approval, highlighting the collaborative nature of the legislative process.
Discharge petition: A discharge petition is a formal request in the House of Representatives that enables members to bring a bill out of committee and onto the floor for consideration, bypassing the committee's authority. This mechanism empowers the majority of the House to force action on legislation that may be stalled in committee, ensuring that important issues can be addressed without delay. The use of discharge petitions highlights the tension between committee leadership and the broader membership's desire to see specific bills debated and voted upon.
Fast-tracking: Fast-tracking is a legislative procedure that allows certain bills to be expedited through the legislative process, bypassing standard procedures and timelines. This method is often used to quickly move critical legislation, especially when there is a consensus among lawmakers or urgent national needs, ensuring that the bill reaches the floor for debate and voting more swiftly than usual.
Floor debate: Floor debate refers to the stage in the legislative process where members of a legislative body discuss, argue, and negotiate the merits of a bill before it is voted on. This occurs after a bill has been reported out of committee and signifies the opportunity for lawmakers to express their opinions, propose amendments, and influence the final outcome of legislation.
Floor leader: A floor leader is a party member in Congress who is responsible for managing the party's legislative agenda on the floor. They play a crucial role in coordinating party strategy, facilitating communication among members, and ensuring that party priorities are advanced during debates and votes. Floor leaders are key figures in reporting bills to the floor and in navigating the complexities of conference committees and reconciliation processes.
Majority Leader: The majority leader is the head of the majority party in either the House of Representatives or the Senate, responsible for leading party strategy, managing legislative priorities, and coordinating the efforts of party members. This role is crucial for guiding legislation through Congress and ensuring that the party's agenda is advanced.
Markup: Markup refers to the process by which committees or subcommittees in Congress review, amend, and revise proposed legislation before it is sent to the full chamber for consideration. This stage is critical as it allows for detailed scrutiny of the bill, leading to changes that reflect the interests of various stakeholders and parties involved in the legislative process.
Minority leader: The minority leader is the head of the minority party in either chamber of Congress, responsible for organizing opposition to the majority party and advocating for the interests of their party. This role is crucial for shaping legislative strategies and fostering unity among party members, especially when the minority party seeks to influence or obstruct the majority's agenda.
Open rule: An open rule is a type of procedural guideline in the legislative process that allows any member of the legislative body to propose amendments to a bill when it is being considered on the floor. This flexibility can lead to extensive debate and alterations of the original legislation, making it more dynamic but also potentially more contentious as it opens up the bill to various changes.
Order of Business: Order of business refers to the established sequence in which legislative business is conducted within a legislative body, such as Congress. This structure is crucial for ensuring that discussions and votes on bills, resolutions, and other matters proceed in an organized manner, allowing lawmakers to focus on one issue at a time and maintain clarity in the legislative process.
Quorum: Quorum is the minimum number of members required to be present for a legislative body to conduct its business legally. This concept is essential for ensuring that decisions made by Congress represent a sufficient segment of its members, providing legitimacy to legislative actions and preventing a small group from making decisions on behalf of the whole.
Standing Committee: A standing committee is a permanent committee in Congress that focuses on specific areas of legislation, allowing for detailed examination and discussion of bills and policies. These committees play a crucial role in shaping legislation through their jurisdiction, which determines the types of bills they review, and they are integral to the process of reporting bills to the floor for consideration by the entire chamber.
Whip: A whip is a member of a political party in Congress whose primary role is to ensure party discipline, manage party strategy, and facilitate communication between the leadership and other members. Whips play a vital role in gathering votes for legislation and are key to maintaining party cohesion, especially when reporting bills to the floor, coordinating efforts during conference committees, and managing committee assignments.