6.3 Hearings, markups, and reporting bills
4 min read•july 30, 2024
Congressional hearings, markups, and bill reporting are crucial steps in the legislative process. These activities allow committees to gather information, shape legislation, and determine which bills advance to the full chamber for consideration.
During hearings, committees hear from experts and stakeholders. In markups, members debate and amend bills. Reporting bills out of committee is a pivotal moment that can make or break a bill's chances of becoming law.
Congressional Hearings: Purpose and Structure
Information Gathering and Issue Investigation
Top images from around the web for Information Gathering and Issue Investigation
Congressional Hearings - Free of Charge Creative Commons Post it Note image View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The Oversight Function of Congress | Boundless Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
Congressional Hearings - Free of Charge Creative Commons Post it Note image View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Information Gathering and Issue Investigation
Congressional Hearings - Free of Charge Creative Commons Post it Note image View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The Oversight Function of Congress | Boundless Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
Congressional Hearings - Free of Charge Creative Commons Post it Note image View original
Is this image relevant?
Congress: What does legislative procedure look like? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Congressional hearings are formal proceedings used to gather information, investigate issues, and build a legislative record to support or oppose a bill or policy proposal
- Hearings are typically held by congressional committees and subcommittees to receive testimony from expert witnesses (academics, industry professionals), government officials, interest groups, and other stakeholders
- Witnesses provide oral testimony and answer questions from committee members, with the goal of informing legislators and influencing public opinion
- Hearings can be legislative (focused on specific bills such as the Affordable Care Act), oversight (examining the implementation of laws or the performance of government agencies like the Department of Veterans Affairs), or investigative (exploring allegations of wrongdoing, for instance, the Benghazi hearings)
Hearing Structure and Committee Control
- The determines the agenda, selects witnesses, and controls the overall structure and flow of the hearing
- Committee members are allocated time for questioning witnesses based on their seniority and party affiliation
- Minority party members may invite their own witnesses to provide alternative perspectives on the issue being discussed
- Hearings can span multiple days or even weeks, depending on the complexity of the issue and the number of witnesses called to testify
Markup Process: Amending Legislation
Debating and Amending Bills
- Markup is the process by which congressional committees and subcommittees debate, amend, and vote on proposed legislation before reporting it out to the full chamber
- During markup sessions, committee members offer amendments to the bill's language, which are then debated and voted upon
- Amendments can be substantive (altering the bill's content, such as changing funding levels or adding new provisions) or technical (correcting errors or making minor changes)
- Members may propose amendments to strike, insert, or replace specific language in the bill, or to add entirely new sections or provisions
Building Consensus and Shaping Legislation
- The markup process allows committee members to shape legislation and build consensus before the bill moves to the floor for consideration by the full House or Senate
- Committee members may negotiate compromises and incorporate feedback from stakeholders to improve the bill's chances of passage
- Markups are typically open to the public, allowing for transparency and public input, but some sensitive or controversial bills (e.g., those related to national security) may be marked up in closed sessions
- The amended version of the bill that emerges from the markup process becomes the basis for further action in the legislative process
Reporting Bills: Impact on Passage
Advancing Legislation to the Floor
- Reporting a bill out of committee is a crucial step in the legislative process, as it allows the measure to advance to the floor for consideration by the full chamber
- A committee's decision to report a bill favorably indicates that a majority of its members support the legislation and believe it should be debated and voted upon by the entire House or Senate
- Bills reported unfavorably or without recommendation face a more challenging path to passage, as they lack the endorsement of the committee with jurisdiction over the issue
- Once reported, bills are placed on the legislative and can be scheduled for floor action by the chamber's leadership (the Speaker of the House or the Senate Majority Leader)
Factors Influencing Passage
- The chances of a reported bill's passage depend on various factors, including the level of bipartisan support, the priorities of congressional leaders, and the overall political climate
- Bills with strong bipartisan support and the backing of key interest groups are more likely to be scheduled for floor action and ultimately passed
- Controversial or politically charged bills may face obstacles, such as the threat of a in the Senate or opposition from the President
- The timing of a bill's consideration can also impact its chances of passage, as competing priorities and external events may shift legislative focus away from the measure
Strategies in Hearings and Markups
Advancing Policy Goals and Shaping Narratives
- Committee members use hearings and markups to advance their policy goals, build public support for their positions, and shape the narrative surrounding specific issues
- Members may invite witnesses who support their views or challenge those with opposing perspectives to testify at hearings, in order to bolster their arguments and discredit alternative viewpoints
- During markups, committee members may offer amendments designed to strengthen or weaken the bill, depending on their policy objectives and political calculations
- Members may also use hearings and markups to highlight issues that are important to their constituents or to score political points against the opposing party
Influence of Interest Groups and Media Coverage
- Interest groups engage in lobbying efforts to influence the content and outcome of hearings and markups, often by providing expert testimony, submitting written statements, or meeting privately with committee members and staff
- Coalitions of like-minded interest groups may coordinate their strategies to maximize their impact on the legislative process during hearings and markups, such as jointly advocating for specific amendments or mobilizing grassroots support
- Media coverage of high-profile hearings and markups can be used by both committee members and interest groups to shape public opinion and build momentum for their preferred policy outcomes
- Committee members may use media appearances and press conferences to amplify their messages and rally support for their positions, while interest groups may leverage media attention to pressure lawmakers and sway public sentiment
Key Terms to Review (16)
Amendment: An amendment is a formal change or addition proposed to a bill or legislation, aimed at improving or altering its content before it becomes law. Amendments can be introduced during various stages of the legislative process, allowing lawmakers to refine the language, address concerns, or introduce new provisions. They play a crucial role in shaping the final form of legislation as they undergo discussion and debate among legislators.
Appropriations Bill: An appropriations bill is a legislative proposal that authorizes government spending for specific purposes and outlines how much money can be allocated to various government departments and programs. These bills are essential for funding federal operations, ensuring that the government can carry out its functions effectively, and are typically passed by Congress on an annual basis.
Authorization bill: An authorization bill is a legislative proposal that establishes or continues a federal program or agency and specifies the amount of money that can be allocated for its operation. This type of bill sets the legal framework for how federal programs are to be implemented and funded, ensuring accountability and oversight during the budget process.
Calendar: In the context of Congress, a calendar is an official schedule that outlines when bills and resolutions are set for consideration on the floor for debate and voting. It plays a crucial role in managing the legislative process, helping organize the agenda and ensuring that bills receive timely attention based on their priority and urgency.
Committee chair: A committee chair is a member of a legislative body who leads and oversees the activities of a specific committee. This position is crucial as the chairperson organizes meetings, guides discussions, and ensures that the committee effectively carries out its responsibilities, including reporting bills to the floor and conducting hearings and markups.
Conference committee: A conference committee is a temporary panel composed of members from both the House of Representatives and the Senate, formed to reconcile differences in legislation that has passed both chambers. This process ensures that a unified version of a bill is produced before it is sent to the President for approval, highlighting the collaborative nature of the legislative process.
Filibuster: A filibuster is a legislative tactic used in the Senate to delay or obstruct a vote on a bill or nomination by extending debate. This strategy allows minority parties or individual senators to prolong discussions, often to force compromise or to highlight opposition, effectively utilizing their power within the chamber's rules.
Markup session: A markup session is a critical phase in the legislative process where members of a committee review, debate, and make changes to a proposed bill before it is sent to the full chamber for consideration. During this time, amendments can be added or removed, and the overall structure and language of the bill can be altered, ensuring that the legislation reflects the committee's priorities and concerns. This process plays a vital role in shaping the final form of a bill and determining its chances of success in the larger legislative context.
Quorum: Quorum is the minimum number of members required to be present for a legislative body to conduct its business legally. This concept is essential for ensuring that decisions made by Congress represent a sufficient segment of its members, providing legitimacy to legislative actions and preventing a small group from making decisions on behalf of the whole.
Ranking member: A ranking member is a senior member of a congressional committee who belongs to the minority party, serving as the lead voice for that party within the committee. This role is crucial for maintaining balance and representation during the legislative process, particularly during discussions of policy and committee votes.
Reporting out: Reporting out is the process by which committees or subcommittees communicate the results of their deliberations and decisions, often involving recommendations on legislation to the full legislative body. This step is crucial as it transitions the work done in committee into the broader legislative process, allowing the full chamber to consider, debate, and vote on proposed measures.
Rider: A rider is an additional provision added to a bill that may not be directly related to the main subject of the legislation. Riders are often used to secure the passage of controversial measures by attaching them to more popular bills, making it more likely for lawmakers to support the overall legislation. This tactic can significantly influence the legislative process in both the House and Senate.
Select committee: A select committee is a temporary committee established by either the House of Representatives or the Senate to conduct specific investigations or consider particular issues outside the jurisdiction of standing committees. These committees play a crucial role in addressing urgent matters, conducting detailed inquiries, and producing reports that inform legislative action.
Session: A session is a specific period during which Congress meets to conduct its business, including introducing, debating, and voting on legislation. Each session of Congress lasts for one year and is typically divided into two regular sessions, which align with the two-year term of elected members. Sessions are vital as they provide the structured time frame for Congress to fulfill its constitutional duties.
Standing Committee: A standing committee is a permanent committee in Congress that focuses on specific areas of legislation, allowing for detailed examination and discussion of bills and policies. These committees play a crucial role in shaping legislation through their jurisdiction, which determines the types of bills they review, and they are integral to the process of reporting bills to the floor for consideration by the entire chamber.
Subcommittee Hearing: A subcommittee hearing is a formal meeting held by a smaller group within a legislative committee to gather information, discuss specific issues, and evaluate proposed legislation. These hearings are crucial in the legislative process as they allow for in-depth examination of topics, where experts and stakeholders can provide testimony and evidence to inform committee members' decisions on whether to advance a bill or propose amendments.