5.3 New Comedy: Menander and domestic themes
3 min read•august 9, 2024
New Comedy, exemplified by , marked a shift in Greek theater. It moved away from political satire to focus on everyday life and relatable characters. This style influenced Roman comedy and laid the groundwork for modern sitcoms and romantic comedies.
Menander's plays, like "," featured realistic dialogue and nuanced characters. He explored themes of love, family, and social issues, using and plot devices that would become staples of comedy for centuries to come.
Menander and His Works
Menander's Life and Influence
Top images from around the web for Menander's Life and Influence
Bust of Menander Roman Bronze 1-25 CE | Photographed at the … | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Menander - Vicipaedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Bust of the Greek playwright Menander modled after a Greek… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Bust of Menander Roman Bronze 1-25 CE | Photographed at the … | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Menander - Vicipaedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Menander's Life and Influence
Bust of Menander Roman Bronze 1-25 CE | Photographed at the … | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Menander - Vicipaedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Bust of the Greek playwright Menander modled after a Greek… | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Bust of Menander Roman Bronze 1-25 CE | Photographed at the … | Flickr View original
Is this image relevant?
Menander - Vicipaedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Menander lived from 342-290 BCE in Athens during the
- Wrote over 100 comedies, though only one complete play survives (Dyskolos)
- Considered the best representative of New Comedy, influencing later Roman playwrights (Plautus, Terence)
- Focused on realistic portrayals of everyday life and human nature
- Developed more nuanced and psychologically complex characters than Old Comedy
Dyskolos: A Landmark in New Comedy
- Dyskolos (The Grouch) rediscovered in 1957, providing insights into Menander's style
- Revolves around a misanthropic farmer and his daughter's romantic entanglements
- Showcases Menander's skill in blending humor with social commentary
- Employs subtle characterization and realistic dialogue to engage audiences
- Utilizes a five-act structure, setting a template for future comedic plays
Character-Driven Comedy Techniques
- Emphasized character development over political satire or fantastical elements
- Created relatable protagonists facing everyday challenges and moral dilemmas
- Used soliloquies and asides to reveal characters' inner thoughts and motivations
- Employed dramatic to heighten comedic tension and audience engagement
- Balanced humor with moments of pathos to create more emotionally resonant stories
Plot Elements and Themes
Romantic Plots and Relationship Dynamics
- Centered storylines around young lovers overcoming obstacles to be together
- Explored themes of parental opposition, differences, and misunderstandings
- Incorporated elements of chance and coincidence to drive plot twists (unexpected reunions, revelations of true identities)
- Utilized stock plot devices like the "recognition scene" where long-lost relatives are reunited
- Concluded plays with resolutions that often involved marriages or reconciliations
Domestic Themes and Social Commentary
- Focused on family dynamics, generational conflicts, and household management
- Addressed social issues such as marriage customs, inheritance laws, and citizen rights
- Explored the tensions between traditional values and changing social norms
- Depicted the lives of ordinary Athenians, including slaves and working-class characters
- Used domestic settings to comment on broader societal issues and human nature
Mistaken Identity and Dramatic Irony
- Employed confusion over characters' true identities as a central plot device
- Created comedic situations through characters' misunderstandings and false assumptions
- Used disguises, twins, or separated siblings to generate plot complications
- Gradually revealed hidden information to characters and audience for dramatic effect
- Resolved identity-based conflicts in satisfying ways that tied up loose plot threads
Character Types
Stock Characters and Their Functions
- Developed a set of recurring character types that became standard in New Comedy
- Young Lover: passionate but often naive protagonist pursuing romantic interests
- Stern Father: obstacle to the young lover's desires, often softens by the play's end
- Clever Slave: witty servant who aids the young lover and often drives the plot forward
- Boastful Soldier: pompous military man, often a rival for the young lover's affections
- Courtesan: complex female character, sometimes with a heart of gold
- Parasite: sycophantic character who flatters others for food and favors
- Used stock characters as familiar touchstones while adding individual quirks and depth
Evolution of Character Complexity
- Moved beyond simple stereotypes to create more nuanced and realistic personalities
- Explored characters' motivations, fears, and inner conflicts through dialogue and actions
- Allowed characters to grow and change over the course of the play
- Blended traits from different stock types to create more complex and unpredictable characters
- Used minor characters to provide contrast and highlight aspects of main characters' personalities
Key Terms to Review (18)
Athenian Society: Athenian society was a complex social structure in ancient Athens characterized by its democratic principles, cultural achievements, and economic development during the 5th to 4th centuries BCE. This society was marked by a unique blend of citizenship, gender roles, and class divisions, which heavily influenced the art, philosophy, and theater of the time, especially in the context of New Comedy and domestic themes.
Character motivation: Character motivation refers to the reasons behind a character's actions, desires, and decisions within a narrative. It serves as a driving force that shapes the plot and influences interactions among characters, allowing audiences to connect with their journeys and understand their conflicts. In the context of New Comedy, particularly in the works of Menander, character motivation often revolves around domestic themes like love, family, and social status, making these elements relatable and engaging for the audience.
Conflict resolution: Conflict resolution refers to the methods and processes involved in facilitating the peaceful ending of conflict and retribution. It involves various strategies aimed at resolving disagreements, disputes, or tensions between individuals or groups, often through dialogue, negotiation, and compromise. In the context of New Comedy, particularly in the works of Menander, conflict resolution is prominently featured as characters navigate personal relationships, societal expectations, and family dynamics.
Contrast with Old Comedy: Contrast with Old Comedy refers to the significant differences between Old Comedy, primarily represented by playwrights like Aristophanes, and New Comedy, notably exemplified by Menander. While Old Comedy often employed broad satire, political commentary, and fantastical elements, New Comedy shifted its focus to everyday life, domestic issues, and realistic character development. This transformation reflects a societal change from public life to private concerns, moving away from direct political engagement to exploring human relationships and social dynamics.
Domestic life: Domestic life refers to the daily experiences, relationships, and responsibilities that occur within a household or family setting. This concept plays a significant role in the portrayal of personal interactions, social structures, and cultural values, especially within the framework of New Comedy, where characters often navigate their domestic relationships and conflicts amidst humorous scenarios.
Dyskolos: Dyskolos, which translates to 'The Bad-Tempered Man,' is a comedic play written by Menander, a prominent figure in New Comedy. The play showcases domestic themes by focusing on the complexities of family dynamics and social relationships within a household. It emphasizes the comedic potential of misunderstandings and the often humorous conflicts that arise from the characters' interactions in a domestic setting.
Everyday settings: Everyday settings refer to the common, familiar environments where people interact and experience daily life. In the context of New Comedy, these settings play a crucial role in showcasing domestic themes and the dynamics of personal relationships, highlighting the humor and drama found in ordinary situations.
Hellenistic Period: The Hellenistic Period refers to the era from the death of Alexander the Great in 323 BCE to the rise of the Roman Empire around 31 BCE. It is characterized by the spread of Greek culture across a vast region that included parts of Europe, Asia, and Africa, resulting in a fusion of Greek and Eastern elements that influenced various aspects of art, literature, and philosophy.
Impact on Renaissance Drama: The impact on Renaissance drama refers to the significant influences that various cultural, literary, and philosophical movements had on the development of theatrical works during the Renaissance period. This impact was characterized by a revival of classical themes, the exploration of humanism, and the incorporation of new dramatic forms that emphasized individual character and complex narratives.
Influence on Roman Comedy: Influence on Roman Comedy refers to the impact that earlier comedic traditions, particularly Greek New Comedy, had on the development of Roman theatrical works. This influence is characterized by the adoption of specific themes, character types, and plot structures that were prevalent in Greek plays, notably those by Menander, which shifted focus towards domestic life and everyday situations.
Irony: Irony is a rhetorical device or figure of speech in which the intended meaning of words is different from their literal meaning, often creating a humorous or poignant effect. It involves a contrast between expectation and reality, allowing for a deeper commentary on human experience and societal norms. This can manifest in various forms, such as verbal irony, situational irony, and dramatic irony, each providing unique layers of meaning and engagement in literary works.
Menander: Menander was a prominent ancient Greek playwright who is best known for his contributions to New Comedy, particularly in the 4th century BCE. His works often focused on domestic themes, relationships, and everyday life, setting the stage for modern comedic storytelling. Menander's influence can be seen in the evolution of theatrical traditions that followed, making him a central figure in the history of comedy.
Philemon: Philemon refers to a prominent playwright of New Comedy in ancient Greece, particularly known for his influence on domestic themes and character-driven narratives. His works often explored everyday life and the complexities of family relationships, making him a significant figure in shaping the comedic landscape during this period. He is often contrasted with Menander, another key playwright of the time, whose themes also revolved around domesticity and social issues.
Samia: Samia refers to a specific comedic form in New Comedy that originated in ancient Greece, characterized by its focus on domestic themes and everyday life. It often revolves around family dynamics, romantic entanglements, and social issues, reflecting the lives of ordinary people. This genre was pivotal in shaping the development of character-driven narratives and comedic situations that are relatable and accessible.
Situational Comedy: Situational comedy, often referred to as sitcom, is a genre of comedy that revolves around a fixed set of characters in a consistent setting, typically facing humorous challenges and conflicts in their daily lives. This style often highlights relatable situations, misunderstandings, and the dynamics of relationships, making it appealing to a broad audience. The genre's roots can be traced back to classical traditions, which evolved through time, influencing the works of playwrights like Menander who focused on domestic themes and character-driven narratives.
Social class: Social class refers to a division of society based on social and economic status. It is a system that categorizes individuals or groups based on factors such as wealth, education, occupation, and social prestige. The concept plays a crucial role in understanding the dynamics of power, privilege, and access to resources within a community.
Stock characters: Stock characters are archetypal figures that are easily recognizable and often recur in various works of literature, particularly in comedy and drama. These characters typically embody specific traits or roles, such as the clever servant or the naive young lover, which makes them instantly relatable to audiences. Their predictable nature helps to advance the plot and establish themes, especially in the context of New Comedy, where everyday situations and domestic themes are explored.
Tragedy elements: Tragedy elements refer to the essential components that define a tragic narrative, typically including features such as a tragic hero, a fatal flaw, the concept of fate, and the evocation of pity and fear in the audience. In the context of New Comedy, especially with playwrights like Menander, these elements transform as the focus shifts from grand themes of fate and moral dilemmas to more relatable domestic situations and personal conflicts. While the dramatic intensity of traditional tragedy may wane, the underlying emotional impact remains significant as characters navigate their flaws in everyday settings.