7.2 Evaluating brand extension opportunities
4 min read•july 18, 2024
Brand extensions can be powerful tools for growth, but they require careful evaluation. Companies must assess the fit between the parent brand and the extension, considering brand image and consumer perceptions. This ensures the extension aligns with the brand's identity and leverages existing equity.
Financial viability is crucial when evaluating brand extensions. Companies analyze costs, project revenues, and assess profitability to determine if the extension makes economic sense. Risk assessment helps identify potential challenges and develop mitigation strategies for successful implementation.
Brand Extension Evaluation
Fit of parent brand and extension
Top images from around the web for Fit of parent brand and extension
Brand Equity Model | Reviewing the Concept of Brand Equity View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: Targeting Strategies and the Marketing Mix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
Brand Positioning and Alignment | Principles of Marketing [Deprecated] View original
Is this image relevant?
Brand Equity Model | Reviewing the Concept of Brand Equity View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: Targeting Strategies and the Marketing Mix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Fit of parent brand and extension
Brand Equity Model | Reviewing the Concept of Brand Equity View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: Targeting Strategies and the Marketing Mix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
Brand Positioning and Alignment | Principles of Marketing [Deprecated] View original
Is this image relevant?
Brand Equity Model | Reviewing the Concept of Brand Equity View original
Is this image relevant?
Reading: Targeting Strategies and the Marketing Mix | Principles of Marketing View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Brand fit
- Evaluates similarity between parent brand and extension category (Coca-Cola extending to energy drinks)
- Ensures consistency with parent brand's image, positioning, and values maintains brand identity (Apple's minimalist design)
- Leverages parent brand's equity and associations to gain consumer trust and recognition (Nike's athletic performance)
- Consumer perception
- Establishes logical connection between parent brand and extension for consumer acceptance (McDonald's offering salads)
- Transfers positive brand attributes and benefits to extension enhances perceived value (Dove's moisturizing properties in hair care)
- Builds credibility of the extension through parent brand's reputation (Bose's audio expertise in soundbars)
- Brand extension strategies
- expands within the same product category offers variety (Colgate's different toothpaste flavors)
- enters a new product category leverages brand strength (Harley-Davidson clothing and accessories)
- moves upward or downward in price and quality targets different market segments (Toyota's luxury brand Lexus)
Cannibalization effects of extensions
- Cannibalization
- Occurs when sales of the extension displace sales of existing products within the brand (iPhone 13 cannibalizing iPhone 12 sales)
- Reduces and revenue of the parent brand if not managed carefully (Gillette's multiple razor brands)
- Factors affecting cannibalization
- Higher similarity between extension and existing products increases cannibalization risk (Pepsi's multiple cola variations)
- Smaller price differential and perceived value difference leads to more cannibalization (Gap and Old Navy)
- Significant target market overlap results in customers switching within the brand (Kindle Fire and Amazon Fire tablets)
- Mitigating cannibalization
- Differentiates extension with unique features, benefits, or positioning minimizes cannibalization (Coca-Cola Zero Sugar vs. Diet Coke)
- Targets distinct consumer segments with specific needs and preferences (Victoria's Secret's PINK line for younger audience)
- Implements careful pricing and distribution strategies to avoid direct competition (Apple's iPhone SE vs. flagship models)
Market demand for brand extensions
- Market research
- Assesses consumer needs, preferences, and purchase intent through surveys and focus groups (Starbucks' market research for Via instant coffee)
- Identifies target market segments and their size to gauge demand (Lululemon's expansion into menswear)
- Conducts concept testing to evaluate extension's appeal and fit with the brand (McDonald's testing McPlant burger)
- Competitive analysis
- Identifies key competitors and their market share in the extension category (Pepsi entering sports drink market dominated by Gatorade)
- Evaluates competitors' strengths, weaknesses, and positioning to find opportunities (Under Armour's performance-focused positioning)
- Assesses the extension's unique selling proposition (USP) to differentiate from competitors (Tesla's electric vehicle technology)
- Market potential
- Estimates market size, growth rate, and future trends to determine viability (Plant-based meat market growth for Beyond Meat)
- Analyzes market saturation and barriers to entry to assess feasibility (Crowded smartphone market for new entrants)
- Determines the extension's market share and sales forecast based on market potential (Nike's projected sales for a new shoe line)
Financial Assessment
Financial viability of extensions
- Cost analysis
- Calculates development and launch costs including R&D, marketing, and distribution (Apple's investment in iPhone development)
- Estimates production and operational costs to determine profitability (McDonald's cost of ingredients and labor)
- Considers economies of scale and learning curve effects to reduce costs over time (Tesla's increasing production efficiency)
- Revenue projection
- Forecasts sales volume and revenue based on market potential and demand (Nike's projected revenue for a new apparel line)
- Estimates market share and growth rate to predict future performance (Amazon's market share in e-commerce)
- Considers pricing strategy and promotional activities to optimize revenue (Apple's premium pricing for iPhones)
- Profitability and ROI
- Calculates gross margin and net profit to assess profitability (Starbucks' high gross margin on coffee sales)
- Determines break-even point and payback period to evaluate investment recovery (Tesla's time to break even on new models)
- Assesses return on investment (ROI) using metrics such as:
- (Coca-Cola's ROI on a new product launch)
- (Nike's NPV for a multi-year brand extension project)
- Risk assessment
- Identifies potential risks and uncertainties such as market shifts or supply chain disruptions (COVID-19 impact on retail brands)
- Conducts sensitivity analysis and scenario planning to prepare for different outcomes (McDonald's planning for economic downturns)
- Develops contingency plans and risk mitigation strategies to minimize potential losses (Toyota's recall management)
Key Terms to Review (17)
Ansoff Matrix: The Ansoff Matrix is a strategic planning tool used by businesses to evaluate and determine growth strategies based on market and product dimensions. It presents four distinct growth options: market penetration, market development, product development, and diversification, helping brands assess risks and opportunities for brand extension initiatives.
Brand dilution: Brand dilution occurs when a brand loses its strength or value due to overextension, inconsistent messaging, or negative associations. This weakening can stem from various factors, including poor brand extensions, inappropriate partnerships, or a failure to maintain quality standards. Understanding how to manage and avoid brand dilution is essential for maintaining a strong brand identity and ensuring long-term success.
Brand Equity: Brand equity refers to the value that a brand adds to a product or service, derived from consumer perceptions, experiences, and associations. It encompasses elements like brand awareness, brand loyalty, and perceived quality, which collectively influence a customer's decision-making process and contribute to the overall financial performance of a brand.
Brand familiarity: Brand familiarity refers to the extent to which consumers recognize and are aware of a brand, as well as their previous experiences with it. This concept is crucial when evaluating opportunities for brand extension, as higher levels of familiarity can lead to greater consumer trust and a higher likelihood of acceptance for new products under the same brand name.
Brand Resonance Model: The Brand Resonance Model is a framework that illustrates the stages of building strong brand relationships, focusing on the emotional connection consumers have with a brand. It emphasizes brand identity, meaning, response, and resonance, highlighting how brands can cultivate loyalty and advocacy through deep engagement and emotional ties with their customers.
Category extension: Category extension is a branding strategy where a company leverages an established brand name to introduce new products in a different category than the original offerings. This approach allows brands to capitalize on existing customer loyalty and brand equity, creating opportunities for growth while also presenting unique challenges in brand perception and market positioning.
Coca-Cola's introduction of Diet Coke: Coca-Cola's introduction of Diet Coke in 1982 was a strategic move to expand its brand portfolio by catering to the growing health-conscious consumer segment. This launch marked one of the most successful brand extensions in beverage history, as it allowed Coca-Cola to leverage its existing brand equity while appealing to consumers looking for a low-calorie alternative to regular soda. By offering a different flavor profile and a distinct identity, Diet Coke became a key player in the diet beverage market.
Customer Loyalty: Customer loyalty refers to a consumer's commitment to repurchase or continue using a brand's products or services over time. This loyalty often stems from positive experiences, perceived value, and emotional connections that consumers develop with the brand.
Google's Entry into Hardware: Google's entry into hardware refers to the company's strategic move to develop and sell physical devices, such as smartphones, smart speakers, and laptops, which began in earnest with the acquisition of Nest Labs in 2014. This shift aimed to create a more integrated ecosystem that connects software and hardware, enhancing user experience and increasing brand visibility in the consumer electronics market.
Ingredient Branding: Ingredient branding is a marketing strategy that emphasizes the brand of a component or ingredient within a final product, aiming to create a distinct identity and value for that ingredient. By associating the ingredient with a well-known brand, companies can enhance consumer perception of quality, create differentiation in the marketplace, and foster loyalty to both the ingredient and the final product.
Line extension: Line extension refers to the strategy of introducing new products that are variations of an existing product line, leveraging the established brand name to target a broader audience or specific market segment. This approach helps optimize brand architecture for growth by utilizing existing brand equity and expanding market presence, leading to a more robust overall brand portfolio.
Market cannibalization: Market cannibalization occurs when a brand introduces a new product that competes with its existing products, leading to a reduction in sales for those original offerings. This phenomenon can undermine overall profitability, as the company may gain sales from the new product at the expense of its established items. Understanding market cannibalization is crucial when evaluating brand extension opportunities, as it can affect not only market share but also consumer perception and brand loyalty.
Market Share: Market share is the portion of a market controlled by a particular company or product, often expressed as a percentage of total sales within that market. Understanding market share helps businesses assess their competitive position and devise strategies to differentiate themselves, enhance brand equity, and optimize growth opportunities.
Misalignment of brand values: Misalignment of brand values occurs when a brand's actions, products, or messaging do not reflect its stated values or the values held by its target audience. This disconnect can lead to consumer distrust and can harm a brand's reputation and market position. Understanding this misalignment is crucial for evaluating brand extension opportunities, as it can impact how new products are perceived by consumers and whether they align with the established brand identity.
Perceived quality: Perceived quality refers to the consumer's perception of a product or service's overall excellence or superiority compared to alternatives. It plays a critical role in shaping brand loyalty, influencing brand equity, and determining a brand's value in the marketplace. When consumers perceive a brand as high quality, it often leads to stronger relationships and can enhance the brand's reputation, making it easier to introduce new products or extensions.
Portfolio Management: Portfolio management refers to the systematic approach of managing a collection of brands, products, or assets to achieve specific business objectives. This includes evaluating the performance of each brand or product within the portfolio and making strategic decisions on resource allocation, investment, and brand positioning. A well-executed portfolio management strategy can help optimize brand architecture, support growth initiatives, and effectively assess opportunities for brand extensions.
Vertical Extension: Vertical extension refers to a brand's strategy of introducing new products or services within the same category but at different price points or quality levels. This approach allows brands to target different market segments, from budget-conscious consumers to premium buyers, enhancing brand reach and customer loyalty.