8.3 Permissioned vs. permissionless blockchains
3 min read•july 18, 2024
Blockchain networks come in two main flavors: permissionless and permissioned. Each type has unique characteristics that shape their use cases and adoption. Permissionless networks like offer and , while permissioned ones like provide controlled access and known identities.
The choice between permissionless and permissioned blockchains involves trade-offs in , scalability, and privacy. Permissionless networks prioritize and , while permissioned ones focus on compliance and . Understanding these differences is key to selecting the right blockchain for specific applications.
Types of Blockchain Networks
Characteristics of blockchain types
Top images from around the web for Characteristics of blockchain types
Introduction — hyperledger-fabricdocs master documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Identity — Hyperledger Fabric Docs main documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Peers — hyperledger-fabricdocs master documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Introduction — hyperledger-fabricdocs master documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Identity — Hyperledger Fabric Docs main documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Characteristics of blockchain types
Introduction — hyperledger-fabricdocs master documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Identity — Hyperledger Fabric Docs main documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Peers — hyperledger-fabricdocs master documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Introduction — hyperledger-fabricdocs master documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
Identity — Hyperledger Fabric Docs main documentation View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Permissionless blockchains
- Open and decentralized networks allow anyone to join and participate without prior approval (Bitcoin, Ethereum)
- Participants maintain anonymity or pseudonymity through the use of public-private key cryptography
- Consensus mechanisms (Proof-of-Work, Proof-of-Stake) ensure network security and prevent double-spending
- Transactions are validated by a distributed network of nodes, ensuring immutability and
- Permissioned blockchains
- Restricted access and centralized control require participants to obtain approval from a central authority to join (Hyperledger Fabric, R3 Corda)
- Identities of participants are known and verified through and identity management systems
- Consensus mechanisms (Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance, ) are more efficient due to the trusted nature of participants
- Customizable privacy settings allow for selective disclosure of transaction details and data confidentiality
Permissioned vs permissionless blockchains
- Permissionless blockchains
- Advantages
- Decentralization and censorship resistance ensure that no single entity can control or manipulate the network
- Open to innovation and development, allowing anyone to build and deploy decentralized applications (dApps)
- Trustless environment eliminates the need for intermediaries and enables peer-to-peer transactions
- Disadvantages
- Slower transaction due to the need for global consensus among a large number of nodes
- Higher energy consumption associated with Proof-of-Work consensus mechanisms (Bitcoin mining)
- Potential for 51% attacks if a single entity or group controls a majority of the network's computing power
- Advantages
- Permissioned blockchains
- Advantages
- Faster transaction processing due to the smaller number of trusted nodes and more efficient consensus mechanisms
- Lower energy consumption as Proof-of-Work is not required in a trusted environment
- Compliance with regulations and industry standards is easier to achieve due to the known identities of participants
- Customizable privacy settings enable selective disclosure of transaction details and data confidentiality
- Disadvantages
- Centralized control and potential for censorship, as the central authority can restrict access or modify the network
- Limited decentralization and trust, as participants must rely on the central authority for network governance
- Restricted innovation and development, as the central authority controls the network's rules and smart contract deployment
- Advantages
Identity management in permissioned blockchains
- Identity management
- Participants are required to verify their identities through a trusted third-party identity provider or a decentralized identity system
- Digital certificates (X.509) are used to authenticate users and establish secure communication channels between nodes
- Ensures accountability and prevents unauthorized access by linking actions to verified identities
- Access control
- Defines roles and permissions for participants based on their verified identities and organizational roles
- Restricts access to sensitive data and based on the principle of least privilege
- Enables compliance with regulations (GDPR, HIPAA) by enforcing granular access controls and audit trails
Scalability of blockchain systems
- Scalability
- Permissionless blockchains face scalability challenges due to the need for global consensus among a large number of nodes (Bitcoin's 7 transactions per second)
- Permissioned blockchains can achieve higher transaction throughput by using more efficient consensus mechanisms and a smaller number of trusted nodes (Hyperledger Fabric's 3,500 transactions per second)
- Performance
- Permissionless blockchains prioritize decentralization and security over performance, resulting in slower transaction confirmation times
- Permissioned blockchains prioritize performance over decentralization, enabling faster transaction processing and lower
- Trade-offs
- Permissionless blockchains sacrifice performance for decentralization and security, ensuring a trustless and censorship-resistant environment
- Permissioned blockchains sacrifice decentralization for performance and compliance, enabling faster transaction processing and easier integration with existing systems
Key Terms to Review (30)
Anonymity: Anonymity refers to the state of being not identifiable within a set of users, allowing individuals to act without revealing their identities. In the context of blockchain technology, anonymity is crucial as it empowers users to interact and transact without fear of being traced or monitored, which can enhance privacy and security while influencing how trust is established within different types of blockchains.
Bitcoin: Bitcoin is a decentralized digital currency that allows peer-to-peer transactions over the internet without the need for intermediaries. Its significance lies in its underlying technology, which influences various aspects like network types, security measures, governance protocols, consensus mechanisms, and applications in different industries.
Censorship resistance: Censorship resistance is the characteristic of a system that prevents any single party from controlling or restricting access to information or transactions within that system. This feature is crucial for maintaining the integrity and trust of decentralized networks, allowing users to freely participate without fear of censorship from authorities or other entities. It also connects closely with the idea of open participation and transparency in blockchain technology.
Centralized governance: Centralized governance refers to a system where decision-making authority and control are concentrated in a single central entity or organization. In the context of blockchains, this model contrasts with decentralized systems, as it can limit transparency and trust among users, particularly in permissioned blockchains where access and participation are restricted. Centralized governance typically involves fewer participants who have the power to enforce rules and manage the network, impacting the overall structure and trust of the blockchain.
Community Governance: Community governance refers to a decentralized approach where stakeholders within a network, such as a blockchain community, participate in decision-making processes that affect their shared resources and collective future. This concept fosters transparency, accountability, and collaboration among participants, allowing them to influence policies and operational guidelines that affect the ecosystem. It is closely tied to the mechanics of platforms and the distinction between open and closed systems.
Consensus Mechanism: A consensus mechanism is a protocol used in blockchain networks to achieve agreement among participants on the validity of transactions and the state of the distributed ledger. This process ensures that all nodes in the network agree on a single version of the truth, enabling trust and security without a central authority. Different consensus mechanisms address issues like scalability, decentralization, and energy efficiency, impacting how blocks are added to the chain and how transactions are validated.
Customization: Customization refers to the ability to modify or tailor a blockchain's features and functionalities to meet specific needs or requirements of users or organizations. This flexibility allows different blockchains to cater to diverse use cases, whether they are permissioned, which restrict access to certain users, or permissionless, which allow anyone to participate in the network. Customization plays a crucial role in determining how a blockchain operates, including its consensus mechanisms, data privacy levels, and governance structures.
Data privacy: Data privacy refers to the protection of personal and sensitive information from unauthorized access, use, or disclosure. It is crucial in ensuring that individuals maintain control over their own data, particularly in a world where digital transactions and interactions are commonplace. The significance of data privacy extends across various blockchain implementations, where the handling of personal information can either be more secure or more vulnerable, depending on whether a blockchain is permissioned or permissionless.
Decentralization: Decentralization refers to the distribution of authority, control, and decision-making away from a central authority to multiple entities or nodes. This concept is fundamental to blockchain technology, as it enhances security, promotes transparency, and allows participants to have greater control over their data and transactions, fostering trust in a system without relying on a single point of failure.
Digital Certificates: Digital certificates are electronic credentials that validate the identity of individuals, organizations, or devices in the digital world. They are used to establish secure communications by linking public keys with the identities of their owners, allowing users to verify authenticity and trustworthiness in transactions. Digital certificates are essential in the realms of public key cryptography and digital signatures, as well as in managing access and permissions within both permissioned and permissionless blockchain systems.
Enterprise Solutions: Enterprise solutions refer to software systems and technologies designed to meet the complex needs of large organizations, streamlining processes and enhancing productivity. These solutions often integrate various business functions, such as finance, human resources, supply chain management, and customer relationship management, facilitating efficient information flow and decision-making. In the context of permissioned and permissionless blockchains, enterprise solutions can leverage the security and transparency of blockchain technology while providing controlled access and governance tailored to organizational requirements.
Federated Consensus: Federated consensus is a consensus mechanism where a group of pre-selected nodes, known as validators or trusted entities, come together to reach an agreement on the state of a blockchain. This method allows for quicker and more efficient decision-making since it doesn’t require every participant in the network to validate every transaction, making it particularly useful in permissioned blockchains where participants are known and trusted. By establishing a set of validators, federated consensus improves scalability and reduces energy consumption compared to traditional consensus methods like proof-of-work.
Hyperledger Fabric: Hyperledger Fabric is an open-source blockchain framework designed for enterprise use, allowing organizations to create and manage permissioned blockchain networks. It supports modular architecture, enabling customizable consensus mechanisms and flexible smart contract execution, which are crucial for various business applications across industries.
Identity Verification: Identity verification is the process of confirming an individual's identity through various means, ensuring that they are who they claim to be. This process is critical in maintaining security and trust in both digital and physical interactions, particularly when it comes to sensitive transactions. With the rise of blockchain technology, identity verification can be enhanced through decentralized systems that provide greater control and privacy for users.
Incentive Structures: Incentive structures are systems designed to motivate participants to act in certain ways, often by rewarding desirable behaviors or outcomes. In the context of blockchain, these structures play a crucial role in maintaining network integrity, encouraging participation, and ensuring that stakeholders align their interests with the overall goals of the blockchain ecosystem. Properly designed incentive structures can help address issues related to trust and cooperation among participants, especially in both permissioned and permissionless environments.
Innovation: Innovation refers to the process of creating and implementing new ideas, products, or methods that improve efficiency, effectiveness, or overall functionality. In the realm of blockchain technology, innovation plays a crucial role in developing new blockchain models, enhancing security, and optimizing performance, especially when comparing permissioned and permissionless systems.
Latency: Latency refers to the time delay experienced in a system, particularly the time taken for a transaction to be processed and confirmed in a blockchain. This delay can be influenced by various factors such as network congestion, block size, and the consensus mechanism used. Understanding latency is crucial as it affects the speed and efficiency of transactions, ultimately impacting user experience and the overall performance of different types of blockchain systems.
Open Access: Open access refers to the unrestricted online availability of research outputs, including publications, data, and other educational resources. This concept emphasizes the removal of financial, legal, and technical barriers to accessing information, promoting knowledge sharing and collaboration among researchers and the public. In the context of blockchain technology, open access is significant as it relates to the transparency and inclusivity of data and systems, particularly in distinguishing between permissioned and permissionless blockchains.
Permissioned blockchain: A permissioned blockchain is a type of blockchain network that restricts access and controls who can participate in the network, allowing only authorized users to view, submit, or validate transactions. This model enhances security and privacy, making it suitable for enterprises and organizations that require strict governance over their data and transactions.
Permissionless Blockchain: A permissionless blockchain is a type of blockchain network that allows anyone to participate in the network without needing approval or permission from a central authority. This openness encourages a decentralized and inclusive environment, where anyone can contribute to the blockchain by validating transactions or creating new blocks. The absence of restrictions makes permissionless blockchains ideal for public use, fostering innovation and collaboration among users.
Permissionless blockchain: A permissionless blockchain is a type of distributed ledger technology that allows anyone to participate in the network without needing permission from a central authority. This openness promotes transparency and inclusivity, enabling anyone to validate transactions and contribute to the maintenance of the blockchain. This architecture is essential for decentralized applications, as it ensures that they can operate freely and are not controlled by a single entity.
Private transactions: Private transactions refer to exchanges or dealings between parties that are conducted in a confidential manner, where the details are not publicly visible on the blockchain. This concept is particularly significant in the context of blockchains, as it addresses concerns around privacy and security while still allowing for verification of transactions. The ability to perform private transactions is a key feature that differentiates permissioned blockchains from permissionless ones, as permissioned blockchains often provide enhanced privacy controls for users.
Public Cryptocurrency Networks: Public cryptocurrency networks are decentralized platforms that allow anyone to participate in the network by sending, receiving, and validating transactions without needing permission from a central authority. These networks operate on open-source protocols, enabling transparency and security through consensus mechanisms, such as proof of work or proof of stake, which ensure that all transactions are verified by multiple participants.
Public ledgers: Public ledgers are decentralized databases that store transaction records in a transparent and immutable manner, accessible to anyone on the network. They serve as the foundational technology behind many cryptocurrencies and blockchains, providing a means for multiple parties to verify and audit transactions without needing a central authority.
Raft: Raft is a consensus algorithm used in distributed systems to ensure that multiple nodes agree on a single source of truth, particularly in blockchain environments. It focuses on maintaining a reliable and fault-tolerant network by electing a leader and allowing the rest of the nodes to replicate changes based on the leader’s decisions. This mechanism helps in achieving consistency and reliability across the network, which is crucial for both permissioned and permissionless blockchains.
Regulatory compliance: Regulatory compliance refers to the adherence to laws, regulations, guidelines, and specifications relevant to business processes. In the context of blockchain technology, it plays a critical role in ensuring that various blockchain implementations meet legal and regulatory standards, affecting network types, permission settings, enterprise applications, supply chain transparency, and implementation challenges.
Smart contracts: Smart contracts are self-executing contracts with the terms of the agreement directly written into code, stored, and replicated on a blockchain. They automatically enforce and execute the terms when predetermined conditions are met, eliminating the need for intermediaries and ensuring trust and transparency in transactions.
Throughput: Throughput refers to the number of transactions or operations that a blockchain network can process within a given time frame. It's a crucial metric for evaluating the efficiency and performance of a blockchain, impacting everything from transaction lifecycle and validation processes to consensus mechanisms and the scalability of various blockchain types. Understanding throughput helps in assessing how well a blockchain can handle increased loads, which is essential for both permissioned and permissionless networks.
Transaction fees: Transaction fees are costs paid by users to facilitate transactions on a blockchain network. These fees are essential for incentivizing validators and miners to include transactions in blocks, ensuring the efficient processing and confirmation of transactions. Transaction fees can vary based on network congestion, transaction size, and the chosen consensus mechanism, impacting how quickly a transaction is confirmed.
Transparency: Transparency in the context of blockchain refers to the openness and accessibility of transaction data on a distributed ledger, allowing all participants to view and verify transactions without needing a trusted intermediary. This characteristic builds trust among users, promotes accountability, and enhances security by providing a clear audit trail for all activities within the network.