5.4 Homology modeling
7 min read•august 21, 2024
Homology modeling is a crucial technique in bioinformatics that predicts 3D protein structures using known structures of related proteins. It's based on the principle that proteins with similar sequences often have similar structures, allowing scientists to infer unknown structures from known ones.
This method involves several key steps: template selection, , , refinement, and evaluation. Each step presents unique challenges and requires careful consideration to produce accurate and reliable models for various applications in structural biology and drug discovery.
Fundamentals of homology modeling
- Homology modeling predicts three-dimensional protein structures using known structures of related proteins
- Crucial technique in bioinformatics for understanding protein function and interactions
- Relies on the principle that proteins with similar sequences often have similar structures
Definition and basic principles
Top images from around the web for Definition and basic principles
Frontiers | Repeat-swap homology modeling of secondary active transporters: updated protocol and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Protein homology modelling and its use in South Africa View original
Is this image relevant?
Protein Homology Modelling View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Repeat-swap homology modeling of secondary active transporters: updated protocol and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Protein homology modelling and its use in South Africa View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Definition and basic principles
Frontiers | Repeat-swap homology modeling of secondary active transporters: updated protocol and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Protein homology modelling and its use in South Africa View original
Is this image relevant?
Protein Homology Modelling View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Repeat-swap homology modeling of secondary active transporters: updated protocol and ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Protein homology modelling and its use in South Africa View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Process of constructing an atomic-resolution model of a target protein from its amino acid sequence
- Uses experimentally determined structure of a related homologous protein as a template
- Based on the observation that protein structure is more conserved than sequence
- Involves steps sequence alignment, backbone generation, loop modeling, and side chain placement
Applications in bioinformatics
- Facilitates structure-based by providing 3D models of drug targets
- Aids in understanding protein-protein interactions and complex formation
- Enables of newly sequenced proteins
- Supports protein engineering efforts by predicting effects of mutations
Limitations and challenges
- Accuracy depends on the quality and similarity of the template structure
- Difficulty in modeling proteins with low sequence identity to known structures (< 30%)
- Struggles with modeling flexible regions and intrinsically disordered proteins
- Cannot reliably predict novel folds or structures without suitable templates
Template selection
- Critical step in homology modeling determines the overall quality of the final model
- Involves searching protein structure databases (PDB) for suitable templates
- Requires balancing sequence similarity, structural quality, and experimental conditions
Sequence similarity thresholds
- High sequence identity (> 50%) typically yields reliable models
- Moderate identity (30-50%) can produce useful models with careful refinement
- Low identity (< 30%) enters the "twilight zone" where modeling becomes challenging
- Sequence similarity assessed using tools like BLAST or HHpred
Multiple vs single templates
- Single template approach uses the best-matching structure for the entire model
- Multiple template method combines information from several related structures
- Multi-template approach can improve model quality, especially for diverse protein families
- Requires careful alignment and weighting of template contributions
Template quality assessment
- Evaluates experimental resolution and R-factors for X-ray crystallography structures
- Considers NMR ensemble quality and restraint violations for NMR-derived templates
- Assesses template coverage of the target sequence to minimize gaps
- Examines physiological relevance (ligand-bound vs unbound, pH, temperature)
Sequence alignment
- Crucial step establishes correspondence between target and template residues
- Determines which structural elements will be copied from the template
- Quality of alignment directly impacts the accuracy of the final model
Pairwise vs multiple alignments
- Pairwise alignment compares target sequence directly to a single template
- (MSA) incorporates information from related sequences
- MSA can improve alignment accuracy, especially for distant homologs
- Tools like Clustal Omega or MUSCLE commonly used for generating MSAs
Alignment algorithms
- Global alignment algorithms (Needleman-Wunsch) align entire sequences
- Local alignment methods (Smith-Waterman) identify regions of high similarity
- Profile-based methods (PSI-BLAST, HHalign) use position-specific scoring matrices
- Structural alignment algorithms (DALI, TM-align) incorporate 3D information
Handling insertions and deletions
- Insertions in target sequence modeled as loops between conserved structural elements
- Deletions require careful adjustment of template structure to close gaps
- Specialized loop modeling techniques often applied to these variable regions
- Alignment editing may be necessary to optimize placement of insertions/deletions
Model building
- Process of constructing the 3D structure based on the template-target alignment
- Involves generating backbone coordinates, placing side chains, and modeling loops
- Iterative process often requiring manual intervention and refinement
Backbone generation
- Copies backbone coordinates (N, Cα, C, O) from aligned template residues
- Conserved elements (α-helices, β-sheets) typically well-preserved
- Backbone torsion angles (φ, ψ) may be adjusted based on Ramachandran plot statistics
- Techniques like rigid-body assembly or segment matching used for multi-template models
Side chain placement
- Predicts positions of side chain atoms based on backbone coordinates
- Uses rotamer libraries derived from high-resolution protein structures
- Considers steric clashes, hydrogen bonding, and electrostatic interactions
- Methods include dead-end elimination, Monte Carlo sampling, or machine learning approaches
Loop modeling techniques
- Addresses regions without template coverage or with low sequence similarity
- Ab initio methods generate loop conformations from scratch (Rosetta, )
- Database methods search for similar loop structures in known proteins
- Molecular dynamics simulations can refine loop conformations
Model refinement
- Aims to improve the initial homology model's accuracy and physical realism
- Iterative process often combining multiple techniques
- Balance between improving model quality and introducing artifacts
Energy minimization
- Reduces unfavorable interactions and improves overall model geometry
- Uses molecular mechanics force fields (CHARMM, AMBER) to calculate energies
- Gradient-based methods (steepest descent, conjugate gradient) optimize atomic positions
- Typically applied in stages, starting with hydrogen atoms and gradually including all atoms
Molecular dynamics simulations
- Simulates atomic motions to explore conformational space and relax strained regions
- Can reveal dynamic properties and potential alternative conformations
- Requires careful equilibration and sufficient simulation time (nanoseconds to microseconds)
- Computationally intensive, often performed on GPU-accelerated systems or supercomputers
Knowledge-based scoring functions
- Evaluates model quality based on statistical analysis of known protein structures
- Assesses features like packing density, hydrogen bonding patterns, and residue environments
- Examples include DOPE (Discrete Optimized Protein Energy) and OPUS-PSP
- Often used in combination with physics-based energy terms for model selection
Model evaluation
- Critical step assesses the reliability and potential usefulness of the homology model
- Combines multiple metrics to provide a comprehensive quality assessment
- Helps identify regions of high confidence and areas requiring further refinement
Stereochemical quality checks
- Evaluates basic geometric properties of the protein model
- Examines bond lengths, bond angles, and dihedral angles
- Assesses Ramachandran plot distributions for backbone torsion angles
- Tools like PROCHECK or MolProbity commonly used for stereochemical validation
Statistical potential methods
- Assess model quality based on likelihood of observed residue interactions
- Compare model features to distributions derived from high-quality experimental structures
- Methods include DOPE (Discrete Optimized Protein Energy) and
- Provide both global and per-residue quality scores
Comparison with experimental structures
- Calculates (Root Mean Square Deviation) between model and known structures
- Uses global superposition or local structural alignment techniques
- Evaluates conservation of functionally important residues and binding sites
- Considers differences in experimental conditions (ligands, pH, crystal contacts)
Homology modeling tools
- Wide range of software available for different stages of the modeling process
- Choice of tool depends on specific requirements, expertise level, and computational resources
- Integration with other bioinformatics tools enhances overall workflow
Popular software packages
- MODELLER integrates all stages of homology modeling with Python scripting
- provides automated modeling with a user-friendly web interface
- Rosetta offers advanced modeling capabilities, including loop refinement and design
- YASARA combines molecular dynamics with homology modeling for iterative refinement
Web-based servers
- Phyre2 performs rapid modeling with fold recognition capabilities
- I-TASSER integrates threading and ab initio modeling for challenging targets
- SWISS-MODEL automated pipeline requires minimal user input
- HHpred combines sensitive sequence searching with modeling functionality
Integration with other bioinformatics tools
- Sequence analysis tools (BLAST, HMMer) aid in template identification
- Visualization software (PyMOL, Chimera) enables model inspection and analysis
- Molecular docking programs (AutoDock, HADDOCK) utilize models for interaction studies
- Workflow management systems (Galaxy, Taverna) facilitate integration of multiple tools
Applications in structural biology
- Homology models provide valuable insights when experimental structures are unavailable
- Enable hypothesis generation and guide experimental design
- Complement other structural biology techniques (X-ray crystallography, cryo-EM, NMR)
Protein-ligand interactions
- Predicts binding sites and modes for small molecules and natural ligands
- Supports virtual screening efforts in drug discovery pipelines
- Enables analysis of substrate specificity in enzyme families
- Guides design of site-directed mutagenesis experiments
Protein engineering
- Predicts effects of mutations on protein structure and stability
- Aids in designing proteins with enhanced or novel functions
- Supports efforts to improve enzyme activity or substrate specificity
- Facilitates the design of protein-protein interfaces for synthetic biology applications
Drug discovery applications
- Provides 3D models of drug targets for structure-based drug design
- Enables virtual screening of large compound libraries against modeled targets
- Supports lead optimization by predicting effects of chemical modifications
- Aids in understanding mechanisms of drug resistance in rapidly evolving targets (HIV protease)
Challenges and future directions
- Ongoing research aims to address limitations and expand applicability of homology modeling
- Integration with experimental techniques and other computational methods
- Leveraging increasing amounts of structural data and computational power
Modeling membrane proteins
- Challenges include limited availability of membrane protein templates
- Requires consideration of lipid bilayer environment and protein-lipid interactions
- Specialized tools (MEMOIR, MEDELLER) developed for membrane protein modeling
- Integration with molecular dynamics simulations in membrane environments
Intrinsically disordered regions
- Difficult to model using traditional homology-based approaches
- Requires ensemble representations rather than single static structures
- Methods like DISOPRED or IUPred help identify disordered regions
- Integration of disorder prediction with structured domain modeling
Integration with machine learning
- Deep learning approaches (AlphaFold, RoseTTAFold) revolutionizing protein
- Neural networks can improve template selection and alignment quality
- Machine learning methods enhance side chain placement and loop modeling
- Potential for end-to-end learning of the entire homology modeling pipeline
Key Terms to Review (18)
Conserved residues: Conserved residues are specific amino acids in protein sequences that remain unchanged across different species or within homologous proteins due to their crucial role in maintaining the structure and function of the protein. These residues are often critical for biochemical activity, and their conservation suggests evolutionary importance, indicating that alterations could disrupt protein function or stability.
Crystal Structures: Crystal structures refer to the orderly and repeating arrangement of atoms, ions, or molecules within a crystalline solid. This geometric arrangement is crucial for understanding the physical properties of materials, including their stability and reactivity. In bioinformatics, crystal structures play an essential role in determining the three-dimensional shapes of biological macromolecules, such as proteins and nucleic acids, which are vital for understanding their functions and interactions.
Drug design: Drug design is the process of discovering and developing new medications based on the biological target of the disease. It involves understanding the structure and function of biological molecules to create compounds that can interact with these targets, leading to effective treatments. The technique often utilizes computational methods, including homology modeling, to predict how potential drugs will bind to their target proteins.
Functional Annotation: Functional annotation is the process of assigning biological meaning to genomic or proteomic data, helping researchers understand the roles and relationships of genes and proteins within an organism. This process involves linking sequences to known functions, pathways, and interactions, providing insights into how genetic information translates into biological function. It plays a crucial role in various bioinformatics analyses, enhancing our understanding of genetics, evolution, and disease mechanisms.
Homologous proteins: Homologous proteins are proteins that share a common ancestry, which is reflected in their similar sequences and structures. These similarities arise from evolutionary processes and can provide insights into functional relationships among different species. Understanding homologous proteins is crucial for predicting protein function and for applications in fields like homology modeling, where the structure of a target protein is inferred based on known structures of homologous proteins.
Model building: Model building refers to the process of creating a mathematical or computational representation of a biological system, often to predict how that system behaves under various conditions. This technique is crucial in bioinformatics for understanding complex biological phenomena, such as protein structures and interactions, through the use of existing data and known relationships.
Model validation: Model validation is the process of ensuring that a computational model accurately represents the real-world system it is intended to simulate. It involves evaluating the model's performance and reliability through various methods, which may include comparing predicted outcomes with observed data or using statistical measures to quantify uncertainty. In the context of homology modeling, model validation is crucial for assessing how well a modeled protein structure corresponds to its template and how accurately it can predict biological function.
Modeller: A modeller is a computational tool or software used to predict the three-dimensional structures of biological macromolecules, primarily proteins, based on known structures of related homologous proteins. It plays a vital role in various fields, such as drug discovery and structural biology, by providing insights into protein function and interactions through modeling techniques. Modellers utilize algorithms and statistical methods to refine these predicted structures, making them essential for understanding biological processes at a molecular level.
Multiple sequence alignment: Multiple sequence alignment is a method used to arrange three or more biological sequences, such as DNA, RNA, or proteins, in a way that highlights similarities and differences among them. This technique is essential for understanding evolutionary relationships, identifying conserved sequences, and inferring structural and functional properties across different species.
Phylogenetic tree: A phylogenetic tree is a diagram that represents the evolutionary relationships among various biological species or entities based on their genetic characteristics. It visually illustrates how different species are related through common ancestry, allowing for the comparison of genetic sequences and the inference of evolutionary history.
Qmean: qmean is a scoring function used in the evaluation of protein structure models, particularly in the context of homology modeling. It helps assess the quality of a model by providing a quantitative measure of its accuracy compared to a reference structure. The qmean score combines different structural features, such as local and global geometry, to determine how well the model approximates the true protein structure.
Rmsd: Root Mean Square Deviation (RMSD) is a measure used to quantify the difference between two sets of data, particularly in the context of molecular structures. It calculates the average distance between the atoms of superimposed proteins or other molecular structures, making it a crucial metric for assessing how closely related or similar these structures are. By analyzing RMSD, researchers can evaluate the accuracy of models in homology modeling, assess structural alignments, and monitor changes in molecular dynamics simulations over time.
Secondary structure: Secondary structure refers to the local folding patterns of a protein that are stabilized by hydrogen bonds between the backbone atoms. Common types of secondary structures include alpha helices and beta sheets, which play crucial roles in determining the overall shape and function of proteins, impacting their interactions and biological activities.
Sequence Alignment: Sequence alignment is a method used to arrange sequences of DNA, RNA, or protein to identify regions of similarity that may indicate functional, structural, or evolutionary relationships. This technique is fundamental in various applications, such as comparing genomic sequences to study evolution, identifying genes, or predicting protein structures.
Structure Prediction: Structure prediction refers to the computational methods used to predict the three-dimensional structure of a biological macromolecule, such as proteins or nucleic acids, based on its amino acid or nucleotide sequence. Accurate predictions are vital for understanding biological functions and interactions, and they often utilize techniques from computational biology, statistics, and physics. The effectiveness of structure prediction can vary widely depending on the method used and the quality of available data.
Swiss-model: The swiss-model is a widely used computational tool for homology modeling of protein structures, allowing researchers to predict the three-dimensional conformation of proteins based on their sequence similarity to known structures. This method is crucial for understanding protein function and interaction, providing a structural framework that can aid in drug design and functional analysis.
Template-based modeling: Template-based modeling is a computational technique used in structural biology and bioinformatics to predict the three-dimensional structure of a protein based on known structures of similar proteins. This method relies on aligning the target protein sequence with one or more homologous sequences that have a resolved structure, allowing researchers to build a model that retains the functional and structural characteristics of the template proteins.
Tertiary structure: Tertiary structure refers to the overall three-dimensional shape of a protein that is formed by the folding of its secondary structures, such as alpha helices and beta sheets, into a compact, functional form. This structure is crucial because it determines how the protein interacts with other molecules and performs its biological functions, linking it to aspects like protein function prediction and structure databases.