4.5 Rational points on curves

Rational points on curves are a cornerstone of arithmetic geometry, bridging number theory and algebraic geometry. These points, with coordinates expressed as fractions, provide insights into Diophantine equations and the structure of algebraic curves.

Understanding rational points helps solve ancient mathematical puzzles and drives modern cryptography. From Pythagorean triples to elliptic curve cryptography, these points showcase how abstract math concepts find real-world applications.

Rational points definition

• Rational points form a crucial concept in arithmetic geometry connecting algebraic geometry with number theory
• These points play a central role in studying the arithmetic properties of algebraic varieties defined over number fields
• Understanding rational points helps in solving Diophantine equations and exploring the structure of algebraic curves

Coordinates in rational numbers

Top images from around the web for Coordinates in rational numbers

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Coordinates in rational numbers

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Graph rational functions | College Algebra View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Rational points have coordinates expressed as fractions of integers (p/q where p and q are integers and q ≠ 0)
• Represent solutions to polynomial equations with coefficients in $\mathbb{Q}$ (the field of rational numbers)
• Closed under addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division (except division by zero)
• Form a dense subset of the real numbers, meaning between any two rational numbers there exists another rational number

Geometric interpretation

• Visualize rational points as intersections of a curve with a grid representing rational coordinates in the plane
• Correspond to points on algebraic varieties that can be described using only rational numbers
• Rational points on the unit circle $x^2 + y^2 = 1$ relate to Pythagorean triples (3/5, 4/5)
• Studying the distribution of rational points provides insights into the geometry and arithmetic of algebraic varieties

Curves and their equations

• Curves serve as fundamental objects of study in arithmetic geometry, bridging algebra, geometry, and number theory
• The interplay between curves and their equations allows for both algebraic and geometric approaches to problem-solving
• Understanding curves and their equations is essential for analyzing rational points and solving Diophantine problems

Algebraic curves

• Defined by polynomial equations in two variables (F(x, y) = 0)
• Classified by their degree: lines (degree 1), conics (degree 2), cubics (degree 3)
• Singularities occur at points where both partial derivatives vanish simultaneously
• Rational points on algebraic curves correspond to rational solutions of their defining equations

Projective vs affine curves

• Affine curves exist in the standard coordinate plane (x, y)
• Projective curves reside in projective space, using homogeneous coordinates [X : Y : Z]
• Projective curves offer advantages in studying rational points at infinity
• Transformation between affine and projective: (x, y) → [x : y : 1] and [X : Y : Z] → (X/Z, Y/Z) when Z ≠ 0
• Projective curves often exhibit more symmetry and simplify certain theoretical considerations

Rational point counting

• Counting rational points on curves provides insights into their arithmetic properties and structure
• The process of enumeration connects to various areas of number theory and algebraic geometry
• Understanding rational point counting techniques is crucial for solving Diophantine equations and studying curve properties

Finite vs infinite sets

• Rational points on curves can form finite or infinite sets depending on the curve's properties
• Finite sets of rational points occur on curves of genus greater than 1 (###Faltings'_Theorem_0###)
• Infinite sets of rational points appear on curves of genus 0 or 1 with at least one rational point
• The finiteness or infinitude of rational points relates to the curve's arithmetic complexity

Methods for enumeration

• Brute force search involves systematically checking all possible rational points up to a certain height
• Descent methods use group structures on curves to generate new points from known ones
• Local-global principles examine solutions modulo primes to infer information about rational solutions
• Height bounds provide upper limits on the size of coordinates for rational points
• Sieving techniques filter out potential solutions based on congruence conditions

Diophantine equations

• Diophantine equations form a central object of study in number theory and arithmetic geometry
• These equations provide a concrete realization of the interplay between algebra, geometry, and number theory
• Solving Diophantine equations often requires sophisticated techniques from various mathematical disciplines

Connection to rational points

• Diophantine equations in two variables directly correspond to finding rational points on curves
• Solutions to Diophantine equations $F(x, y) = 0$ equate to rational points (x, y) on the curve defined by F
• Studying rational points on curves provides geometric insights into Diophantine equation solutions
• Techniques for analyzing rational points often translate to methods for solving Diophantine equations

Historical significance

• Ancient Greek mathematicians studied Diophantine equations (Pythagorean triples)
• Fermat's Last Theorem, a Diophantine equation unsolved for centuries, spurred significant mathematical developments
• Hilbert's tenth problem, concerning the solvability of Diophantine equations, led to advances in computability theory
• The resolution of various Diophantine equations has driven progress in algebraic number theory and arithmetic geometry

Mordell's theorem

• Mordell's theorem represents a landmark result in the study of rational points on elliptic curves
• This theorem connects the arithmetic of elliptic curves to their geometric properties
• Understanding Mordell's theorem provides insights into the structure of rational points on higher genus curves

Statement and implications

• States that the group of rational points on an elliptic curve over $\mathbb{Q}$ is finitely generated
• Implies that rational points on elliptic curves can be described by a finite set of generators
• Generalizes to abelian varieties over number fields (Mordell-Weil theorem)
• Suggests a potential finiteness property for rational points on higher genus curves

Proof outline

• Utilizes the method of infinite descent, introduced by Fermat
• Employs the weak Mordell-Weil theorem to establish a finite index subgroup
• Involves the study of 2-descent and Selmer groups
• Requires careful analysis of the height function on rational points
• Concludes by showing that the quotient group of rational points modulo twice rational points is finite

Height of rational points

• The height function plays a crucial role in the study of rational points on algebraic varieties
• Heights provide a measure of arithmetic complexity for rational points
• Understanding heights is essential for various aspects of arithmetic geometry and Diophantine approximation

Definition and properties

• Height of a rational point measures the size of its coordinates
• Logarithmic height of p/q (in lowest terms) defined as $H(p/q) = \max(\log |p|, \log |q|)$
• Satisfies the product formula: $H(ab) \leq H(a) + H(b)$ for rational numbers a and b
• Extends to projective spaces and algebraic varieties
• Invariant under certain geometric transformations

Bounds on heights

• Northcott's theorem states that there are finitely many rational points of bounded height and degree
• Height bounds often crucial in proving finiteness results for rational points
• Vojta's conjecture relates heights to geometric invariants of varieties
• Effective height bounds used in algorithms for finding rational points
• Mumford's gap principle provides lower bounds on heights of rational points in certain cases

Local-global principle

• The local-global principle connects local properties (over p-adic fields) to global properties (over $\mathbb{Q}$)
• This principle serves as a powerful tool in arithmetic geometry for studying rational points
• Understanding the local-global principle and its limitations provides insights into the arithmetic of curves

Hasse principle

• States that if an equation has solutions in all completions of $\mathbb{Q}$ (real and p-adic), it has a solution in $\mathbb{Q}$
• Holds for quadratic forms in at least three variables (Hasse-Minkowski theorem)
• Applies to certain classes of curves, including conics
• Fails for some higher degree equations and more complex varieties

Counterexamples for curves

• Selmer's cubic curve $3x^3 + 4y^3 + 5z^3 = 0$ violates the Hasse principle
• Genus 1 curves (elliptic curves) can provide counterexamples (Lind-Reichardt curve)
• Brauer-Manin obstruction explains some failures of the Hasse principle
• Study of counterexamples led to the development of descent theory and étale cohomology

Rational points over finite fields

• Studying rational points over finite fields provides insights into the behavior of curves in characteristic p
• Techniques for analyzing points over finite fields often inform methods for rational points over number fields
• Understanding rational points over finite fields is crucial for applications in cryptography and coding theory

Hasse-Weil bound

• Provides an upper bound for the number of rational points on a smooth projective curve over a finite field
• States that $|N - (q + 1)| \leq 2g\sqrt{q}$, where N is the number of points, q is the field size, and g is the genus
• Generalizes to higher-dimensional varieties (Weil conjectures)
• Tight in many cases, with equality achieved for certain curves (maximal curves)

Applications to cryptography

• Elliptic curves over finite fields form the basis of elliptic curve cryptography
• Point counting algorithms crucial for selecting secure elliptic curves for cryptographic use
• Discrete logarithm problem on elliptic curves over finite fields underlies the security of many cryptosystems
• Supersingular curves and their properties play a role in pairing-based cryptography

Elliptic curves

• Elliptic curves represent a fundamental object of study in arithmetic geometry and number theory
• These curves exhibit rich algebraic and geometric properties, making them ideal for various applications
• Understanding elliptic curves is crucial for many areas of modern mathematics and cryptography

Rational points on elliptic curves

• Form an abelian group with the point at infinity as the identity element
• Group law derived from geometric chord-and-tangent construction
• Torsion points (points of finite order) play a significant role in the study of elliptic curves
• Mordell-Weil theorem describes the structure of rational points on elliptic curves over number fields

Group structure

• Rational points form a finitely generated abelian group (Mordell-Weil theorem)
• Group structure decomposed into torsion subgroup and free part: $E(\mathbb{Q}) \cong E(\mathbb{Q})_{tors} \oplus \mathbb{Z}^r$
• Rank r represents the number of independent infinite order generators
• Torsion subgroup always finite (Mazur's theorem bounds its structure over $\mathbb{Q}$)
• Group law enables efficient algorithms for point addition and scalar multiplication

Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture

• The Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer (BSD) conjecture represents one of the most important open problems in mathematics
• This conjecture connects the arithmetic of elliptic curves to their analytic properties
• Understanding the BSD conjecture provides insights into the deep relationships between different areas of mathematics

Statement of the conjecture

• Relates the rank of an elliptic curve E over $\mathbb{Q}$ to the order of vanishing of its L-function at s = 1
• Predicts that $\text{rank}(E(\mathbb{Q})) = \text{ord}_{s=1}L(E,s)$, where L(E,s) is the L-function of E
• Provides a conjectural formula for the leading coefficient of the Taylor expansion of L(E,s) at s = 1
• Involves various arithmetic invariants of the elliptic curve (Tamagawa numbers, regulator, Tate-Shafarevich group)

Evidence and implications

• Numerical evidence supports the conjecture for many elliptic curves
• Partial results known: rank 0 and 1 cases proven (Coates-Wiles, Gross-Zagier, Kolyvagin)
• Connections to other conjectures in number theory (Tate conjecture, Beilinson conjectures)
• Resolution would have profound implications for understanding rational points on elliptic curves
• Generalizations to higher-dimensional varieties and other number fields proposed

Computational aspects

• Computational methods play a crucial role in studying rational points on curves
• Algorithms for finding and analyzing rational points inform theoretical developments in arithmetic geometry
• Understanding computational aspects is essential for practical applications and for generating conjectures

Algorithms for finding points

• Naive search methods involve checking points with small height
• Sieving techniques filter potential solutions based on local information
• Descent methods use group structure to generate new points from known ones
• Elliptic curve method (ECM) for factorization can be adapted to find rational points
• LLL algorithm used for finding small solutions to Diophantine equations

Complexity considerations

• Point counting on elliptic curves over finite fields: polynomial time algorithms available (Schoof's algorithm)
• Finding rational points of bounded height: exponential in the height bound
• Determining whether a curve has rational points (in general): undecidable problem
• Complexity of computing the rank of an elliptic curve: no known polynomial-time algorithm
• Trade-offs between time complexity and space complexity in various algorithms

Applications in number theory

• The study of rational points on curves has far-reaching applications throughout number theory
• These applications demonstrate the power of geometric methods in solving arithmetic problems
• Understanding these applications provides insights into the interconnectedness of different areas of mathematics

Fermat's last theorem

• States that $x^n + y^n = z^n$ has no non-trivial integer solutions for n > 2
• Proof by Andrew Wiles relied heavily on the theory of elliptic curves and modular forms
• Frey curve associated to a hypothetical solution led to the study of semistable elliptic curves
• Modularity theorem (Taniyama-Shimura-Weil conjecture) played a crucial role in the proof

Other Diophantine problems

• Rational points on higher genus curves related to solving various Diophantine equations
• Congruent number problem solved using elliptic curves and L-functions
• ABC conjecture connected to the distribution of rational points on curves
• Rational points on K3 surfaces studied using similar techniques to those for curves
• Diophantine approximation problems often formulated in terms of rational points on varieties