8.1 Aristotle's political naturalism and the concept of the polis
2 min read•july 25, 2024
Aristotle's posits humans as inherently political beings. This concept emphasizes our innate drive to form communities and engage in collective decision-making, with language and rationality enabling complex social interactions and ethical systems.
The , or city-state, is seen as the highest form of political association. It's viewed as a self-sufficient community that meets all citizens' needs, providing opportunities for virtuous action and balancing unity with diversity.
Aristotle's Political Naturalism
Humans as political animals
Top images from around the web for Humans as political animals
Aristotle - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Science with Aristotle View original
Is this image relevant?
Politics - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Aristotle - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Science with Aristotle View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Humans as political animals
Aristotle - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Science with Aristotle View original
Is this image relevant?
Politics - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Aristotle - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Science with Aristotle View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Humans innately possess social and political tendencies driving them to form communities and engage in collective decision-making (polis)
- Language distinguishes humans enabling complex social interactions and political discourse (rhetoric, debate)
- Rational capacity allows humans to discern justice and form ethical systems governing societies (laws, constitutions)
Polis as highest association
- Polis culminates political organization evolving from families to villages to city-states
- Self-sufficient community meets all citizens' needs (economic, social, political)
- Ideal size facilitates direct political participation and face-to-face interactions (Athens, Sparta)
- Provides opportunities for virtuous action and moral development (public service, military duty)
- Balances unity and diversity allowing for specialization and shared cultural identity
Individual vs polis relationship
- Interdependence characterizes relationship individuals rely on polis for fulfillment polis depends on individual participation
- Citizenship defines individual identity conferring rights and responsibilities (voting, jury duty)
- Exclusion of certain groups from full citizenship shapes social hierarchy (women, slaves, foreigners)
- Good life (eu zen) achieved through active participation in polis affairs (public debates, holding office)
- Balance between private and public life necessary for individual and collective flourishing
Teleology in political communities
- Teleological approach everything has natural end or purpose ()
- Purpose of political communities achieve highest good for citizens facilitate moral and intellectual excellence
- Political institutions function to promote justice and virtue resolve conflicts maintain social order
- Critique of existing systems analyzes constitutions based on ability to achieve telos
- Preference for mixed constitutions balancing different social elements (democracy, , )
Key Terms to Review (20)
Aristocracy: Aristocracy is a form of government in which power is held by the nobility or a privileged class, often justified by notions of hereditary privilege and perceived superiority in virtue or wisdom. This system connects closely to the ideas of virtue, governance, and social structure as it emphasizes rule by the few who are considered the most qualified.
Athenian Democracy: Athenian democracy was a system of direct democracy established in Athens during the 5th century BCE, allowing citizens to participate directly in decision-making and governance. This unique political structure emphasized the role of ordinary citizens in shaping their government, connecting deeply with themes of citizenship, equality, and civic responsibility.
Citizen: A citizen is a legally recognized member of a political community, endowed with rights and responsibilities. In ancient Greece, particularly in Athens, the concept of citizenship was tied to participation in political life, encompassing both the right to vote and the obligation to contribute to the city's governance. Citizenship defined the social structure and was critical for the development of democratic principles.
Corrective justice: Corrective justice refers to the principle that individuals who have been wronged or harmed by the actions of others deserve to be compensated or restored to their prior position. This concept emphasizes restoring balance and addressing wrongs, highlighting the importance of fair treatment and accountability within a community. It is closely tied to notions of fairness in interpersonal relationships and plays a crucial role in political arrangements where justice is a central concern.
Distributive justice: Distributive justice refers to the equitable allocation of resources, benefits, and burdens within a society. It seeks to determine how goods and services should be shared among individuals and groups, aiming for fairness and addressing inequalities. This concept plays a crucial role in understanding social cooperation, individual rights, and the moral responsibilities of citizens within their political community.
Eudaimonia: Eudaimonia is a Greek term often translated as 'happiness' or 'flourishing', representing the highest human good and the ultimate goal of human life. It encompasses living in accordance with virtue and realizing one's potential, connecting deeply to concepts of justice, moral excellence, and the well-being of the individual and the community.
Foreigner: A foreigner is an individual who is not a citizen or national of a particular country or state. In the context of political thought, particularly in relation to Aristotle's views on the polis, foreigners play a critical role in understanding the dynamics of citizenship, belonging, and the functioning of the city-state.
Monarchy: Monarchy is a political system where a single individual, the monarch, holds supreme authority and power, often inherited through a royal lineage. This system can be absolute, where the monarch has unchecked powers, or constitutional, where their powers are limited by laws or a constitution.
Nicomachean Ethics: Nicomachean Ethics is a philosophical work by Aristotle that focuses on the nature of virtue and the path to achieving the good life. It emphasizes the importance of moral character and virtue ethics, asserting that ethical behavior leads to eudaimonia, or human flourishing. The work connects deeply with the principles of political naturalism and the role of the polis in fostering virtuous citizens.
Oligarchy: Oligarchy is a form of government where power is held by a small group of individuals or families, often distinguished by wealth, nobility, or corporate interests. This system contrasts with democracy, where power is distributed among the larger population. Oligarchies can influence the structure and function of the state significantly, shaping political decisions and social norms, while also raising questions about justice and equality.
Peloponnesian War: The Peloponnesian War was a protracted conflict fought between the city-states of Athens and Sparta, along with their respective allies, from 431 to 404 BCE. This war had significant impacts on the political landscape of Ancient Greece, influencing the evolution of democracy, political thought, and the structure of power among city-states.
Plato: Plato was a foundational figure in Western philosophy, particularly known for his writings on politics, ethics, and epistemology. His dialogues often feature Socratic questioning and explore concepts like justice, virtue, and the ideal state, which connect deeply to the evolution of political thought in ancient Greece.
Polis: The term 'polis' refers to a city-state in ancient Greece, which was a central hub of political, social, and cultural life. Each polis functioned independently with its own government, laws, and customs, and the concept is deeply tied to citizenship and community identity, as well as broader philosophical ideas about the good life and governance.
Political naturalism: Political naturalism is the philosophical approach that views political structures and institutions as arising from the natural order of human beings, emphasizing that society and politics are fundamentally rooted in human nature. This perspective suggests that the organization of political life should align with human inclinations and social behaviors, advocating for a framework that reflects natural human tendencies. Political naturalism connects deeply with concepts like the polis, where the ideal city-state is seen as a natural extension of human social needs and relationships.
Politics: Politics is the process by which groups of people make collective decisions, typically involving the governance of a community or society. In ancient Greek thought, politics encompasses the organization of power, the role of the citizen, and the pursuit of the common good, often examined through various philosophical lenses to understand justice, authority, and civic responsibility.
Polity: A polity refers to a form or process of political organization, encompassing the structures, institutions, and practices through which a community governs itself. It embodies various systems of governance and reflects the political identity of a society, connecting to ideas of citizenship, rights, and collective decision-making.
Slave: A slave is an individual who is legally and forcibly owned by another person, being deprived of personal freedom and compelled to work for their owner. In the context of political thought, especially in Aristotle's work, slaves are often seen as integral to the functioning of the household and, by extension, the polis. Aristotle argued that some individuals are naturally suited to be slaves due to a perceived lack of rational capability, which raised ethical and philosophical debates about the nature of freedom, justice, and the role of human agency within society.
Socrates: Socrates was an ancient Greek philosopher credited as one of the founders of Western philosophy, known for his contributions to ethics and epistemology. His method of inquiry and dialogue laid the groundwork for future philosophical thought, particularly regarding the nature of knowledge and virtue.
Telos: Telos refers to the ultimate purpose, aim, or end of a thing, especially in the context of its nature and function. Understanding telos is crucial because it helps define the essence of an entity's existence, guiding its actions and decisions toward achieving fulfillment. This concept connects deeply with ideas about justice, virtue, and the good life, as well as the natural order and political structure of society.
Tyranny: Tyranny is a form of government where a single ruler wields absolute power, often unjustly and oppressively, without regard for the welfare of the populace. This concept is closely linked to discussions about political power dynamics and the structure of governance in ancient Greek thought, where tyranny often emerged as a reaction against oligarchies or democracies that failed to address the needs of citizens.