10.2 Field testing and performance evaluation
4 min read•july 30, 2024
Field testing is crucial for validating airborne wind energy systems. It involves careful planning, site selection, and data collection to assess real-world performance. These tests help engineers understand how their designs behave in actual conditions and identify areas for improvement.
Performance evaluation is key to determining the viability of airborne wind energy technologies. By analyzing power output, efficiency, and in various environments, researchers can refine designs and assess economic feasibility. This process is essential for advancing the field toward commercial readiness.
Field testing campaigns for airborne wind energy
Planning and preparation
Top images from around the web for Planning and preparation
Practical Experiences With a Torsion Based Rigid Blade Rotary Airborne Wind Energy System With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
WES - Method for airborne measurement of the spatial wind speed distribution above complex terrain View original
Is this image relevant?
WES - Improving mesoscale wind speed forecasts using lidar-based observation nudging for ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Practical Experiences With a Torsion Based Rigid Blade Rotary Airborne Wind Energy System With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
WES - Method for airborne measurement of the spatial wind speed distribution above complex terrain View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Planning and preparation
Practical Experiences With a Torsion Based Rigid Blade Rotary Airborne Wind Energy System With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
WES - Method for airborne measurement of the spatial wind speed distribution above complex terrain View original
Is this image relevant?
WES - Improving mesoscale wind speed forecasts using lidar-based observation nudging for ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Practical Experiences With a Torsion Based Rigid Blade Rotary Airborne Wind Energy System With ... View original
Is this image relevant?
WES - Method for airborne measurement of the spatial wind speed distribution above complex terrain View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Comprehensive planning involves site selection, equipment preparation, and safety protocol development
- Define test objectives, determine required measurements, and establish success criteria for the campaign
- Ensure regulatory compliance and obtain necessary permits for airborne wind energy system testing
- Conduct risk assessment and develop mitigation strategies to protect personnel and equipment
- Coordinate with local authorities, landowners, and air traffic control as needed (depending on test location and system characteristics)
- Document test procedures, equipment configurations, and environmental conditions for reproducibility and data validation
- Prepare for multiple phases including pre-test preparation, system deployment, data collection, and post-test analysis
Execution and management
- Deploy airborne wind energy system according to established protocols
- Implement safety measures and continuously monitor for potential hazards
- Collect data using pre-calibrated sensors and data acquisition systems
- Maintain clear communication channels between ground crew and system operators
- Adjust testing parameters based on real-time observations and environmental conditions
- Troubleshoot and resolve technical issues that may arise during the testing campaign
- Regularly review collected data to ensure quality and completeness
Site selection for performance evaluation
Environmental considerations
- Assess wind resource quality using historical data and on-site measurements
- Evaluate terrain characteristics impact on wind patterns and system performance (hills, valleys, coastlines)
- Consider atmospheric stability and its influence on vertical wind profiles
- Account for seasonal variations in wind patterns and other meteorological conditions
- Identify potential extreme weather events (hurricanes, severe thunderstorms) that could affect testing
- Analyze turbulence intensity and its impact on system behavior and component stress
- Evaluate air density variations due to altitude and temperature changes
Logistical and operational factors
- Ensure site accessibility for equipment transportation and personnel
- Assess proximity to essential infrastructure (power grid connections, communication networks)
- Evaluate potential conflicts with other land uses or airspace restrictions
- Consider geological hazards that may impact ground station stability (soil conditions, seismic activity)
- Analyze local wildlife patterns to minimize environmental impact
- Assess availability of local resources for maintenance and repairs
- Evaluate site suitability for long-term testing campaigns (lease agreements, community acceptance)
Data acquisition for field testing
Sensor systems and measurements
- Deploy wind measurement devices (anemometers, LiDAR, SODAR) for accurate wind profiling
- Install force sensors to measure tether tension and loads on airborne components
- Utilize GPS and inertial measurement units (IMUs) for precise position and orientation tracking
- Implement power output sensors to measure electricity generation
- Deploy environmental sensors for temperature, humidity, and atmospheric pressure monitoring
- Use strain gauges to measure structural loads on key components
- Install cameras for visual monitoring and analysis of system behavior
Data management and quality control
- Implement telemetry systems for real-time data transmission from airborne components
- Establish robust data storage and backup strategies to prevent data loss
- Calibrate and synchronize all sensors and data logging equipment for accuracy
- Develop data validation algorithms to identify and flag anomalous measurements
- Integrate weather forecasting data with the monitoring system for enhanced decision-making
- Implement redundant measurements for critical parameters to ensure data reliability
- Establish a centralized data management system for easy access and analysis
Performance assessment of airborne wind energy
Power output and efficiency analysis
- Calculate key performance metrics (power output, , overall system efficiency)
- Analyze power curves across various wind speeds and environmental conditions
- Compare field test results with theoretical models and wind tunnel data
- Apply statistical analysis techniques to account for environmental variability
- Evaluate energy harvest by calculating total energy produced over time
- Compare actual energy production to theoretical maximum based on available wind resources
- Assess power quality parameters (frequency stability, voltage fluctuations)
System reliability and economic assessment
- Evaluate component failure rates and identify potential weak points in the system
- Analyze maintenance requirements and downtime frequency
- Calculate mean time between failures (MTBF) for critical components
- Perform cost of energy calculations incorporating capital and operational expenses
- Assess the impact of environmental factors on system longevity and performance degradation
- Evaluate the scalability of the system based on field test results
- Analyze the potential for performance improvements through design optimizations
Key Terms to Review (18)
Altitude performance: Altitude performance refers to how well airborne wind energy systems operate at different heights above ground level. This concept is critical in evaluating the efficiency and effectiveness of these systems, as performance can vary significantly with changes in altitude due to factors like wind speed, turbulence, and atmospheric conditions. Understanding altitude performance is essential for optimizing designs and ensuring successful field testing and performance evaluation.
Atmospheric conditions: Atmospheric conditions refer to the state of the atmosphere at a given time and place, characterized by factors such as temperature, pressure, humidity, wind speed, and cloud cover. These conditions play a crucial role in determining the performance and efficiency of airborne wind energy systems, influencing their ability to harness wind energy effectively.
AWEA Guidelines: The AWEA Guidelines are a set of recommended practices and standards established by the American Wind Energy Association specifically for the field testing and performance evaluation of airborne wind energy systems. These guidelines aim to ensure consistency, reliability, and safety during testing, while also facilitating the comparison of different systems and technologies in the airborne wind energy sector.
Capacity Factor: Capacity factor is a measure of how efficiently a power generation system operates, defined as the ratio of actual output over a specified period to the maximum possible output if it operated at full capacity for the same period. Understanding capacity factor helps compare different energy systems and their performance in real-world conditions.
Control Algorithms: Control algorithms are computational methods that guide the behavior of systems to achieve desired outcomes, often through feedback loops and optimization techniques. In airborne wind energy systems, these algorithms are critical for adjusting system parameters in real-time, enhancing efficiency, stability, and performance across various operational scenarios.
Durability Testing: Durability testing is the process of evaluating how well a system or component can withstand prolonged use and adverse conditions without failure. This type of testing is crucial for assessing the long-term reliability and performance of airborne wind energy systems, as it ensures that they can endure harsh environmental factors like wind, temperature fluctuations, and mechanical stress over time.
Dynamic stability: Dynamic stability refers to the ability of a system to return to its original state after being disturbed, especially in the context of movement and forces acting on an object. In airborne wind energy systems, this concept is crucial as it ensures that a kite or wing maintains its desired flight path and performance despite changing conditions such as wind gusts or tension in the tether. The design of the structure, whether rigid or flexible, directly affects its dynamic stability, which influences energy harvesting efficiency and performance during different phases of operation.
Energy yield: Energy yield refers to the amount of energy produced by a system relative to the energy input, essentially measuring the efficiency of energy conversion in airborne wind energy systems. It is crucial for understanding how well a system can harness and convert kinetic energy from the wind into usable electrical energy. Energy yield is affected by several factors, including flight patterns, harvesting techniques, and system design.
IEC Standards: IEC standards refer to the International Electrotechnical Commission standards, which are globally recognized benchmarks that provide guidelines for electrical and electronic technologies. These standards ensure safety, efficiency, and interoperability across various systems, making them crucial for the development and implementation of technologies like airborne wind energy systems. By adhering to these standards, manufacturers and developers can address safety concerns and promote compatibility with existing grid infrastructures.
Kite systems: Kite systems are airborne wind energy devices that utilize tethered kites or wings to capture wind energy at high altitudes. These systems are designed to generate electricity by converting the kinetic energy of the wind into usable power, often operating at heights where wind speeds are more consistent and stronger. Kite systems can optimize energy yield and reduce costs associated with traditional wind turbines.
Power Extraction Efficiency: Power extraction efficiency refers to the effectiveness of a system in converting wind energy into usable electrical power, measured as a percentage of the total available wind energy. This efficiency is critical for evaluating the performance of airborne wind energy systems, as it directly impacts the amount of energy that can be harnessed and utilized in real-world applications. Higher power extraction efficiency indicates better performance, leading to increased energy output and cost-effectiveness for renewable energy solutions.
Prototype testing: Prototype testing is the process of evaluating a preliminary version of a product to assess its functionality, performance, and overall viability before full-scale production. This crucial phase allows designers and engineers to identify potential issues, gather user feedback, and make necessary adjustments, ultimately aiding in the refinement of the design. Effective prototype testing is essential in understanding how concepts evolve over time and plays a significant role in the advancement of airborne wind energy systems.
Reliability: Reliability refers to the consistency and dependability of a system or product to perform its intended function under specified conditions for a specific period of time. In the context of performance evaluation, reliability is crucial as it ensures that an airborne wind energy system can consistently generate energy and operate safely over time, making it a key factor in assessing the viability and efficiency of such systems.
Resource assessment: Resource assessment is the process of evaluating the availability and quality of natural resources in a specific area, which is crucial for determining the feasibility and efficiency of energy generation systems. This evaluation involves collecting and analyzing data on wind patterns, solar irradiance, or other environmental factors to optimize energy production and minimize costs. By understanding resource potential, developers can make informed decisions regarding site selection, design, and technology deployment for renewable energy projects.
Site assessment: Site assessment is the process of evaluating a specific location for its suitability to deploy energy generation systems, particularly in the context of airborne wind energy. This evaluation involves analyzing various environmental, geographical, and technical factors that impact energy yield and system performance, ultimately guiding decision-making for optimal site selection and system design.
Tether material strength: Tether material strength refers to the capacity of the tether used in airborne wind energy systems to withstand various forces without breaking or deforming. This characteristic is crucial for ensuring the reliability and efficiency of these systems, especially during field testing and performance evaluations where tethers are subject to dynamic loads and environmental conditions. Understanding tether material strength helps in selecting appropriate materials and designs that enhance safety and performance in real-world applications.
Tethered drones: Tethered drones are unmanned aerial vehicles connected to a stationary base by a cable that provides power and data transmission. This connection allows them to stay aloft for extended periods while also improving safety and control, making them a unique alternative to traditional wind energy technologies.
Wind Profile: A wind profile describes the variation of wind speed and direction with height above the ground. This profile is essential for understanding how wind interacts with structures, such as tethered systems in airborne wind energy, and provides valuable insights during field testing to evaluate performance. By analyzing wind profiles, engineers can determine optimal operating conditions and design strategies that maximize energy capture.