3.4 Kanban metrics and continuous improvement
5 min read•august 13, 2024
Kanban metrics are crucial for measuring workflow efficiency and driving continuous improvement. , , and provide insights into process performance, while visualizing these metrics helps teams identify trends and bottlenecks.
Using these metrics, teams can make data-driven decisions to optimize their workflow. By setting performance targets, conducting root cause analysis, and prioritizing improvements, Kanban fosters a culture of continuous improvement where teams collaborate to enhance their processes over time.
Key Kanban Metrics
Measuring Workflow Efficiency and Effectiveness
Top images from around the web for Measuring Workflow Efficiency and Effectiveness
Kanban - Praxis Framework View original
Is this image relevant?
Kanban, Flow and Cadence | AvailAgility View original
Is this image relevant?
Throughput vs Lead Time | AllAboutLean.com View original
Is this image relevant?
Kanban - Praxis Framework View original
Is this image relevant?
Kanban, Flow and Cadence | AvailAgility View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Measuring Workflow Efficiency and Effectiveness
Kanban - Praxis Framework View original
Is this image relevant?
Kanban, Flow and Cadence | AvailAgility View original
Is this image relevant?
Throughput vs Lead Time | AllAboutLean.com View original
Is this image relevant?
Kanban - Praxis Framework View original
Is this image relevant?
Kanban, Flow and Cadence | AvailAgility View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Kanban uses specific metrics to quantitatively measure the efficiency and effectiveness of the workflow process
- The three key Kanban metrics are lead time, cycle time, and throughput
- Lead time measures the total time it takes for a work item to move through the entire Kanban system from the commitment point to the delivery point and is a measure of the end-to-end customer experience
- Cycle time measures the amount of time a work item spends as work-in-progress from the moment work actually starts on the item until it is ready for delivery and is a measure of the team's process capability
- Throughput measures the total amount of work delivered in a certain time period and is calculated by counting the number of work items that exit the system over a certain period of time (week, month, quarter)
Visualizing Key Metrics
- Work in progress (WIP) is the number of work items started but not finished
- Limiting WIP is a key practice of Kanban to prevent bottlenecks and optimize flow
- Too much WIP leads to context switching, increased cycle times, and reduced quality
- Cumulative flow diagrams are used to visualize the three key metrics over time to identify trends and areas for improvement in the workflow
- They show the amount of work in each state of the workflow (backlog, in progress, completed) over time
- Ideal cumulative flow diagrams have smooth, parallel lines indicating a steady flow of work through the system
Measuring Workflow Performance
Using Metrics for Continuous Improvement
- Kanban metrics provide actionable data that teams can use to identify opportunities for optimizing their workflow and processes through continuous improvement
- Reducing lead times improves customer satisfaction and enables faster time-to-market
- Teams should identify ways to eliminate waste and delays in the end-to-end workflow (handoffs, waiting, defects)
- Shortening cycle times increases efficiency and predictability
- Teams can optimize their processes to reduce the time spent on each work item, often by limiting work in progress and identifying bottlenecks (testing, approvals)
- Increasing throughput boosts productivity and can be improved by alleviating capacity constraints and improving workflow
- However, throughput should be balanced against lead time and cycle time for overall effectiveness to avoid sacrificing quality or responsiveness for raw output
Setting Performance Targets
- Establishing service level expectations (SLEs) for each of the key metrics helps teams define target performance goals to measure against
- SLEs are based on historical data and stakeholder needs and should be realistic yet ambitious
- Example SLEs might be a lead time of 10 days, cycle time of 5 days, and throughput of 20 items per week
- Control charts are used to track cycle time and throughput over time, visualizing variance and identifying when a process goes out of control, helping teams focus improvement efforts
- They plot data points over time and include average lines and upper/lower control limits
- Points outside the control limits indicate special cause variation that should be investigated and addressed
Data-Driven Decision Making in Kanban
Root Cause Analysis Techniques
- Kanban teams use their workflow metrics to make data-driven decisions and solve problems, rather than relying on subjective opinions and guesswork
- When metrics deviate from established service level expectations, root cause analysis is used to dig deeper into the underlying issues and identify opportunities for improvement
- The five whys technique asks "why" five times in succession to get to the root cause of a problem and avoid implementing countermeasures that only address surface-level symptoms
- Example: Problem - Throughput dropped 50% last week. Why? Tester was out sick. Why? No cross-training. Why? Training budget cut. Why? Deprioritized against features. Why? Short-term revenue focus.
Prioritizing and Testing Improvements
- Teams prioritize improvement opportunities based on their impact and feasibility, often using decision matrices and cost-benefit analyses to quantify and rank options
- Impact considers metrics like cycle time, throughput, quality, and customer satisfaction
- Feasibility factors in cost, effort, time, and risk
- Specific hypotheses for improvement are defined and tested using the scientific method, with results validated by tracking the impact on key Kanban metrics
- Example hypothesis: "Adding automated testing will reduce regression testing time by 50%, improving cycle time by 20%"
- A3 problem-solving is a structured approach using a one-page report in an A3-sized format
- It follows the PDCA (plan-do-check-act) cycle to identify root causes, define countermeasures, and check results to promote learning
- A3s create alignment and shared understanding of complex issues
Continuous Improvement Culture in Kanban
Allocating Capacity for Improvement
- Kanban seeks to establish a culture of continuous improvement where teams are empowered to collaborate, experiment, and learn in order to optimize their workflow over time
- Teams should dedicate capacity for both planned and emergent improvement work, allocating time to identify and implement improvements while maintaining a focus on delivering value
- Many teams allocate 15-20% of their capacity for improvement work
- Improvements can be treated as regular work items and visualized on the Kanban board
Engaging the Whole Team
- Improvement work should involve the whole team, collectively owning their workflow and actively looking for opportunities to optimize it
- This creates a shared understanding and buy-in and leverages diverse perspectives
- Teams can self-organize and collaborate to define and implement improvements
- Teams run regular retrospectives, taking time to reflect on their process and brainstorm ways to improve
- Retrospectives should be held at a consistent cadence (every 2 weeks, monthly) and focus on the Kanban practices and metrics
- Techniques like plus/delta, sailboat, and 4Ls help structure the conversation
Sustaining a Culture of Improvement
- Visualizing improvement work and experiments on a Kanban board helps teams track the status and impact of their continuous improvement efforts
- Improvements can be color-coded or placed in a separate swimlane
- Tracking improvements provides transparency and accountability
- Successful improvements should be standardized and shared across the organization to promote organizational learning and elevate overall performance
- Playbooks, case studies, and communities of practice help scale learning
- Leadership should create an environment that embraces continuous improvement by empowering teams, encouraging experimentation, and celebrating learning, even from failed experiments
- Psychological safety and a growth mindset are key to fostering a culture of continuous improvement
Key Terms to Review (15)
Blockers: Blockers are obstacles or impediments that prevent a team from making progress on their work, often hindering the flow of tasks within a project. These obstacles can arise from various sources, such as resource constraints, unclear requirements, or dependencies on external parties. Identifying and addressing blockers is crucial for maintaining efficiency and ensuring continuous improvement in project management practices.
Constraint management: Constraint management is the process of identifying, analyzing, and addressing limitations within a project or workflow that can impede progress or performance. It involves prioritizing tasks based on the constraints that affect the flow of work, ensuring that resources are optimally allocated to improve efficiency. This approach is crucial for enhancing productivity and achieving continuous improvement by consistently reassessing and managing these limitations.
Cumulative Flow Diagram: A cumulative flow diagram is a visual representation used in project management that illustrates the status of work items over time, showing how many items are in different stages of the workflow. This diagram helps teams monitor progress, identify bottlenecks, and understand the flow of work through various stages, promoting transparency and informed decision-making.
Customer collaboration: Customer collaboration is a key principle in Agile methodologies that emphasizes working closely with customers and stakeholders throughout the project to gather feedback, understand needs, and ensure that the delivered product meets their expectations. This ongoing partnership is essential for creating value and fostering adaptability in response to changing requirements.
Cycle Time: Cycle time is the total time taken from the beginning to the end of a process, specifically focusing on the duration it takes for a task to move through all stages of a workflow. Understanding cycle time is crucial as it relates to efficiency, helps identify bottlenecks, and supports effective planning and forecasting in project management.
Feedback loops: Feedback loops are processes in which the outputs of a system are circled back and used as inputs. This concept is vital for improving processes, fostering communication, and ensuring continuous improvement in various aspects of project management, particularly in Agile methodologies. They facilitate collaboration among teams, enhance testing strategies, and prepare organizations for adopting Agile practices effectively.
Flow efficiency: Flow efficiency refers to the ratio of the value-added time to the total cycle time in a process, highlighting how effectively work flows through a system. This concept emphasizes the importance of minimizing waste and delays while maximizing the speed at which tasks are completed, ultimately leading to improved delivery and responsiveness. It connects closely with visualizing work in progress and assessing overall system performance.
Kaizen: Kaizen is a Japanese term that means 'continuous improvement' and refers to the practice of regularly enhancing processes, products, or services through small, incremental changes. This concept emphasizes the importance of involving all employees in the improvement process and fostering a culture of feedback and collaboration. In Agile environments, kaizen is crucial for enhancing efficiency, quality, and team performance.
Kanban Maturity Model: The Kanban Maturity Model is a framework that helps organizations assess and improve their Kanban practices by evaluating their current capabilities and guiding them toward higher levels of maturity. This model emphasizes continuous improvement, enabling teams to identify gaps in their processes and make targeted enhancements that align with Kanban principles and practices, while also focusing on metrics to foster ongoing growth and efficiency.
Lead Time: Lead time is the total time taken from the initiation of a process until its completion, which can include phases like planning, execution, and delivery. It plays a crucial role in project management as it helps teams understand how quickly they can deliver value and respond to changes.
Little's Law: Little's Law is a formula that describes the relationship between the average number of items in a queuing system, the average arrival rate of items, and the average time an item spends in the system. It is represented as L = λW, where L is the average number of items in the system, λ is the average arrival rate, and W is the average time an item spends in the system. This law helps organizations understand flow and efficiency within their processes, making it particularly relevant for metrics and continuous improvement initiatives.
Service Delivery Manager: A Service Delivery Manager is responsible for overseeing the delivery of services to clients, ensuring that service levels are met and that customer satisfaction is prioritized. They play a vital role in facilitating communication between teams, monitoring performance metrics, and driving continuous improvement efforts. This position is crucial for managing the flow of work within frameworks like Kanban, where efficiency and adaptability are key components.
Team Member: A team member is an individual who contributes to the success of a group by performing assigned tasks and collaborating with others to achieve shared goals. In the context of Agile practices, team members are essential as they embody the principles of collaboration, accountability, and continuous improvement. Each team member's role is defined by their skills, responsibilities, and their commitment to the team's workflow and overall objectives.
Throughput: Throughput refers to the amount of work or output produced within a given time frame in a project or system. It is a key measure of efficiency and effectiveness, helping teams understand how much value they deliver over time and how well they can meet demands in an Agile environment.
Work in Progress (WIP) Limits: Work in Progress (WIP) limits are constraints placed on the amount of work that can be in progress at any given time within a workflow. These limits help teams focus on completing tasks rather than starting new ones, enhancing efficiency and flow. By controlling WIP, teams can identify bottlenecks, improve their processes, and ensure a smoother workflow, which is essential for effective visualization on Kanban boards and for utilizing metrics for continuous improvement.