4.6 Skin friction and heat transfer

Skin friction and heat transfer are crucial aspects of aerodynamics that impact vehicle performance. These phenomena occur in the boundary layer, where fluid velocity changes from zero at the surface to freestream speed. Understanding them is vital for designing efficient aircraft and managing thermal loads.

Factors like Reynolds number, surface roughness, and pressure gradients affect skin friction and heat transfer. Various methods, from empirical formulas to CFD simulations, are used to calculate these effects. Heat transfer mechanisms include conduction, convection, and radiation, with thermal boundary layers playing a key role in energy exchange.

Skin friction fundamentals

• Skin friction is a critical aspect of aerodynamics that deals with the resistance to motion experienced by a body moving through a fluid, particularly near its surface
• Understanding skin friction is essential for designing efficient aircraft, missiles, and other vehicles that operate in fluid environments

Boundary layer concept

Top images from around the web for Boundary layer concept

• 

  aerodynamics - Why doesn't ice form on the fuselage? - Aviation Stack Exchange View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – University Physics Volume 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  aerodynamics - Why doesn't ice form on the fuselage? - Aviation Stack Exchange View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Boundary layer concept

• 

  aerodynamics - Why doesn't ice form on the fuselage? - Aviation Stack Exchange View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Fluid Dynamics – University Physics Volume 1 View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  aerodynamics - Why doesn't ice form on the fuselage? - Aviation Stack Exchange View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  WES - Laminar-turbulent transition characteristics of a 3-D wind turbine rotor blade based on ... View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• The boundary layer is a thin region near a surface where viscous effects are significant and the velocity changes from zero at the surface to the freestream value
• Boundary layers can be laminar or turbulent, each with distinct characteristics that affect skin friction
• The thickness of the boundary layer depends on factors such as the Reynolds number, surface roughness, and pressure gradients

Laminar vs turbulent flow

• Laminar flow occurs at lower Reynolds numbers and is characterized by smooth, parallel streamlines with minimal mixing between fluid layers
• Turbulent flow occurs at higher Reynolds numbers and features chaotic, swirling motions with increased mixing and energy dissipation
• Transition from laminar to turbulent flow can occur due to surface roughness, adverse pressure gradients, or other disturbances (acoustic waves)

Velocity gradients near surfaces

• The velocity profile within the boundary layer varies from zero at the surface (no-slip condition) to the freestream velocity at the edge of the boundary layer
• The shape of the velocity profile depends on the flow regime (laminar or turbulent) and the presence of pressure gradients
• Steeper velocity gradients near the surface result in higher shear stress and skin friction

Shear stress and skin friction

• Shear stress is the force per unit area acting parallel to the surface, caused by the velocity gradient within the boundary layer
• Skin friction is the component of the shear stress that acts in the direction opposite to the motion of the body
• The skin friction coefficient ($C_f$) is a non-dimensional parameter that quantifies the magnitude of skin friction relative to the dynamic pressure of the freestream flow

Factors affecting skin friction

• Several factors influence the magnitude and distribution of skin friction on a surface, which can have significant implications for the performance of aerodynamic vehicles
• Understanding these factors is crucial for optimizing the design of aircraft, missiles, and other vehicles to minimize drag and improve efficiency

Reynolds number effects

• The Reynolds number ($Re$) is a dimensionless parameter that represents the ratio of inertial forces to viscous forces in a fluid flow
• Higher Reynolds numbers indicate a greater tendency towards turbulent flow, which generally results in increased skin friction compared to laminar flow
• The critical Reynolds number ($Re_{cr}$) marks the transition from laminar to turbulent flow and depends on factors such as surface roughness and pressure gradients

Surface roughness impact

• Surface roughness refers to the microscopic irregularities and protrusions on a surface that can affect the boundary layer and skin friction
• Rough surfaces tend to promote earlier transition to turbulent flow and increase skin friction compared to smooth surfaces
• The equivalent sand grain roughness ($k_s$) is a parameter used to characterize the effect of surface roughness on the boundary layer (painted surfaces, polished metal)

Pressure gradients and separation

• Pressure gradients along a surface can significantly affect the boundary layer and skin friction
• Favorable pressure gradients (decreasing pressure in the flow direction) tend to stabilize the boundary layer and delay transition to turbulent flow
• Adverse pressure gradients (increasing pressure in the flow direction) can cause the boundary layer to separate from the surface, leading to increased drag and loss of lift (airfoil stall)

Compressibility and Mach number

• Compressibility effects become significant at high Mach numbers (typically $M > 0.3$) and can influence skin friction
• As the Mach number increases, the density and temperature variations within the boundary layer become more pronounced, affecting the velocity profile and shear stress
• Shock waves can form on surfaces at supersonic speeds, leading to abrupt changes in pressure, density, and skin friction (supersonic aircraft, rocket nozzles)

Skin friction calculation methods

• Accurately predicting skin friction is essential for the design and analysis of aerodynamic vehicles, as it directly impacts drag, heat transfer, and overall performance
• Several methods exist for calculating skin friction, ranging from empirical formulas and charts to advanced computational techniques and experimental measurements

Empirical formulas and charts

• Empirical formulas, such as the Blasius solution for laminar flow and the Prandtl-Schlichting formula for turbulent flow, provide approximate expressions for the skin friction coefficient based on the Reynolds number and other flow parameters
• Skin friction charts, such as the Moody diagram, present the relationship between the skin friction coefficient, Reynolds number, and relative roughness for various flow regimes
• These methods are often used for quick estimations and preliminary design calculations (flat plate, pipe flow)

Computational fluid dynamics (CFD)

• CFD is a powerful numerical approach that solves the governing equations of fluid motion (Navier-Stokes equations) to predict the flow field and skin friction on complex geometries
• CFD simulations can capture the effects of compressibility, turbulence, and heat transfer using various turbulence models and boundary conditions
• High-fidelity CFD simulations require significant computational resources but provide detailed insights into the flow physics and skin friction distribution (aircraft wings, turbomachinery)

Experimental techniques and wind tunnels

• Experimental measurements of skin friction can be performed using various techniques, such as hot-wire anemometry, pressure sensors, and force balances
• Wind tunnel testing allows for the study of skin friction on scaled models under controlled flow conditions, providing validation data for empirical and computational methods
• Advanced experimental techniques, such as particle image velocimetry (PIV) and laser Doppler anemometry (LDA), enable non-intrusive measurements of the velocity field and shear stress near surfaces (aircraft models, automotive testing)

Heat transfer basics

• Heat transfer is a fundamental aspect of aerodynamics, as it governs the exchange of thermal energy between a body and its surrounding fluid
• Understanding heat transfer mechanisms is crucial for designing thermal protection systems, managing aerodynamic heating, and optimizing the performance of high-speed vehicles

Conduction, convection, and radiation

• Conduction is the transfer of heat through a material by molecular interactions, driven by temperature gradients
• Convection is the transfer of heat between a surface and a moving fluid, involving both conduction and bulk fluid motion
• Radiation is the emission and absorption of electromagnetic waves, which can transfer heat between surfaces without the need for a intervening medium (heat shields, insulation)

Thermal boundary layers

• The thermal boundary layer is a region near a surface where the temperature profile develops from the surface temperature to the freestream temperature
• The thickness and shape of the thermal boundary layer depend on factors such as the Prandtl number, flow regime, and surface heat flux
• The thermal boundary layer is often thinner than the velocity boundary layer, especially for fluids with high Prandtl numbers (air, water)

Temperature gradients near surfaces

• Temperature gradients within the thermal boundary layer drive the convective heat transfer between the surface and the fluid
• The magnitude and direction of the temperature gradients depend on the surface temperature, fluid properties, and flow conditions
• Steeper temperature gradients near the surface result in higher heat transfer rates and Nusselt numbers

Heat flux and Nusselt number

• Heat flux is the rate of heat transfer per unit area, typically expressed in units of W/m^2
• The Nusselt number ($Nu$) is a dimensionless parameter that represents the ratio of convective heat transfer to conductive heat transfer in a fluid
• Higher Nusselt numbers indicate more effective convective heat transfer relative to conduction, and are often correlated with the Reynolds and Prandtl numbers (forced convection, natural convection)

Factors influencing heat transfer

• Several factors can significantly affect the heat transfer between a surface and a fluid, which is essential to consider when designing thermal management systems and analyzing the performance of aerodynamic vehicles
• Understanding these factors allows engineers to optimize the heat transfer characteristics of a system and ensure its safe and efficient operation

Prandtl number and fluid properties

• The Prandtl number ($Pr$) is a dimensionless parameter that represents the ratio of momentum diffusivity to thermal diffusivity in a fluid
• Fluids with high Prandtl numbers (oils) have a thinner thermal boundary layer relative to the velocity boundary layer, resulting in more effective convective heat transfer
• Fluid properties such as thermal conductivity, specific heat, and viscosity also influence the heat transfer behavior (air, water, liquid metals)

Surface temperature and emissivity

• The surface temperature affects the convective and radiative heat transfer between the surface and the fluid
• Higher surface temperatures lead to increased convective heat transfer due to larger temperature gradients near the surface
• The surface emissivity ($\varepsilon$) is a measure of a material's ability to emit and absorb thermal radiation, with values ranging from 0 (perfect reflector) to 1 (perfect emitter) (polished metals, black surfaces)

Flow regime and turbulence intensity

• The flow regime (laminar or turbulent) significantly influences the heat transfer characteristics of a system
• Turbulent flow enhances mixing and increases the convective heat transfer compared to laminar flow due to the presence of fluctuating velocity and temperature fields
• Higher turbulence intensity (ratio of fluctuating velocity to mean velocity) leads to more effective heat transfer by promoting mixing and disrupting the thermal boundary layer (pipe flow, jet impingement)

Shock waves and aerodynamic heating

• In high-speed flows (supersonic and hypersonic), shock waves can form near surfaces, leading to abrupt changes in pressure, density, and temperature
• Shock waves compress the fluid and increase its temperature, resulting in intense aerodynamic heating of the surface
• The heat transfer rates associated with shock waves can be orders of magnitude higher than those in subsonic flows, requiring specialized thermal protection systems (re-entry vehicles, scramjets)

Coupled skin friction and heat transfer

• Skin friction and heat transfer are often closely coupled in aerodynamic flows, as the mechanisms that govern momentum and energy transfer are similar
• Understanding the relationship between skin friction and heat transfer is essential for accurate predictions of drag, heating, and overall performance of aerodynamic vehicles

Reynolds analogy and assumptions

• The Reynolds analogy is a simplified model that relates the skin friction coefficient ($C_f$) to the Stanton number ($St$), which represents the ratio of heat transfer to thermal capacity of the fluid
• The analogy assumes that the velocity and thermal boundary layers are similar, and that the Prandtl number is close to unity (air)
• The Reynolds analogy provides a convenient way to estimate heat transfer from skin friction data, or vice versa, but has limitations in certain flow conditions (high Mach numbers, non-unity Prandtl numbers)

Chilton-Colburn analogy for Prandtl numbers

• The Chilton-Colburn analogy is an extension of the Reynolds analogy that accounts for the effect of Prandtl number on the relationship between skin friction and heat transfer
• The analogy introduces a correction factor ($Pr^{-2/3}$) to the Stanton number, which allows for more accurate predictions of heat transfer for fluids with Prandtl numbers different from unity
• The Chilton-Colburn analogy is widely used in engineering applications for estimating heat transfer coefficients from skin friction data (air, water, oils)

Limitations and advanced analogies

• While the Reynolds and Chilton-Colburn analogies provide useful approximations for coupled skin friction and heat transfer, they have limitations in certain flow conditions
• Advanced analogies, such as the Von Karman analogy and the Spalding-Chi method, account for compressibility effects and variable fluid properties, providing more accurate predictions at high Mach numbers
• Numerical simulations and experimental techniques are often required to capture the complex interactions between skin friction and heat transfer in realistic aerodynamic flows (hypersonic vehicles, turbomachinery)

Thermal protection systems (TPS)

• Thermal protection systems are essential components of high-speed vehicles, such as spacecraft, hypersonic aircraft, and rockets, that experience intense aerodynamic heating during flight
• TPS materials and designs are selected based on the specific mission requirements, including the peak heat flux, total heat load, and duration of exposure

Ablative vs non-ablative materials

• Ablative materials, such as phenolic resins and carbon-based composites, protect the underlying structure by absorbing heat through phase change and chemical reactions
• As the ablative material chars and erodes, it carries away heat and creates a protective layer that insulates the surface (re-entry capsules, rocket nozzles)
• Non-ablative materials, such as ceramic tiles and metallic alloys, maintain their integrity and rely on their high melting points and low thermal conductivity to withstand the aerodynamic heating (Space Shuttle tiles, hypersonic aircraft skins)

Insulation and heat sink approaches

• Insulation materials, such as ceramic fibers and aerogels, are used to reduce the heat transfer from the hot outer surface to the cooler underlying structure
• Heat sink approaches involve using materials with high thermal capacitance, such as beryllium and lithium, to absorb and store the incoming heat without excessive temperature rise
• The choice between insulation and heat sink approaches depends on factors such as the mission duration, peak heat flux, and weight constraints (re-entry vehicles, hypersonic cruise missiles)

Active cooling techniques

• Active cooling techniques involve the circulation of coolants, such as water, liquid metals, or cryogenic fluids, to remove heat from the surface and maintain acceptable temperatures
• Transpiration cooling involves injecting coolant through a porous surface to create a protective film that reduces the heat transfer and skin friction (rocket engines, scramjets)
• Regenerative cooling uses the fuel or oxidizer as a coolant, circulating it through channels in the structure before injecting it into the combustion chamber (rocket nozzles, combustion chambers)

TPS design considerations

• The design of thermal protection systems must balance the competing requirements of thermal performance, structural integrity, weight, and cost
• Factors such as the vehicle geometry, trajectory, and operating environment influence the selection of TPS materials and configurations
• Advanced TPS concepts, such as ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs) and active cooling with phase change materials, are being developed to meet the challenges of future hypersonic and reusable space vehicles (scramjets, single-stage-to-orbit vehicles)

Applications in aerodynamics

• The principles of skin friction and heat transfer have wide-ranging applications in aerodynamics, from subsonic aircraft to hypersonic vehicles and propulsion systems
• Understanding and optimizing skin friction and heat transfer is crucial for improving the performance, efficiency, and safety of aerodynamic systems

Aircraft drag reduction strategies

• Reducing skin friction drag is a key objective in aircraft design, as it directly impacts fuel efficiency and range
• Laminar flow control techniques, such as suction, pressure gradients, and compliant surfaces, aim to maintain laminar flow over a larger portion of the wing and reduce turbulent skin friction
• Riblets, which are small streamwise grooves on the surface, can reduce turbulent skin friction by modifying the near-wall flow structure (shark skin, golf ball dimples)

Hypersonic vehicle challenges

• Hypersonic vehicles, such as scramjets and re-entry vehicles, experience extreme aerodynamic heating due to the high Mach numbers and shock waves
• Designing effective thermal protection systems is critical for ensuring the structural integrity and payload survival of hypersonic vehicles
• Active cooling techniques, such as transpiration and regenerative cooling, are often required to manage the intense heat fluxes encountered during hypersonic flight (X-43, X-51)

Rocket nozzle and combustion chamber

• Rocket nozzles and combustion chambers are subjected to high heat transfer rates due to the hot combustion gases and high-speed flow
• Regenerative cooling is commonly used in rocket engines to cool the nozzle and combustion chamber walls, using the fuel or oxidizer as a coolant
• Ablative materials, such as graphite and carbon-carbon composites, are used in solid rocket nozzles to withstand the erosive effects of the hot gases (Space Shuttle SRBs, Ariane 5)

Turbomachinery and gas turbines

• Turbomachinery components, such as compressor and turbine blades, experience high heat transfer rates due to the hot gas path and high rotational speeds
• Internal cooling techniques, such as air cooling and film cooling, are used to maintain acceptable blade temperatures and prevent thermal damage
• Advanced cooling designs, such as multi-pass channels and pin fins, enhance the heat transfer and structural integrity of turbine blades (jet engines, power generation turbines)