8.1 Accounting for share-based payments
4 min read•august 16, 2024
Share-based payments are a crucial part of employee compensation, involving companies giving equity or cash based on share prices. This section dives into the accounting principles, recognition, and measurement of these payments under and .
We'll explore the differences between equity-settled and cash-settled arrangements, their impact on financial statements, and valuation considerations. Understanding these concepts is key to grasping how companies account for and report share-based compensation.
Principles of Share-Based Payments
Core Concepts and Standards
Top images from around the web for Core Concepts and Standards
Journal of Accounting and Taxation - factors influencing international financial reporting ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Measuring the “Adoption” of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) View original
Is this image relevant?
The Statement of Cash Flows | Boundless Finance View original
Is this image relevant?
Journal of Accounting and Taxation - factors influencing international financial reporting ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Measuring the “Adoption” of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Core Concepts and Standards
Journal of Accounting and Taxation - factors influencing international financial reporting ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Measuring the “Adoption” of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) View original
Is this image relevant?
The Statement of Cash Flows | Boundless Finance View original
Is this image relevant?
Journal of Accounting and Taxation - factors influencing international financial reporting ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Measuring the “Adoption” of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Share-based payments involve entities exchanging goods or services for equity instruments or incurring liabilities based on share prices
- IFRS 2 and ASC 718 govern share-based payment accounting internationally and in the United States
- Recognize goods or services received and corresponding equity/liability increase at
- Three categories of arrangements exist (equity-settled, cash-settled, choice of settlement)
- Key dates in share-based payments include , , and
- Fair value measurement typically uses option pricing models (Black-Scholes, binomial)
- Models consider factors like stock price, exercise price, volatility, dividends, and risk-free rate
Classification and Measurement Principles
- Equity-settled payments recognized as expense with equity increase over vesting period
- Cash-settled payments initially measured at liability's fair value and remeasured each reporting date
- Non-market vesting conditions (service requirements) excluded from initial fair value measurement
- Adjusted through expected number of vesting equity instruments
- Market conditions (target share price) reflected in grant-date fair value
- No subsequent adjustments regardless of outcome
- Modifications to arrangements may lead to additional
- Cancellations or settlements of equity-settled payments treated as vesting acceleration
- Immediate recognition of remaining vesting period amount
Accounting for Share-Based Payments
Recognition and Measurement
- Equity-settled payments expensed over vesting period with corresponding equity increase
- Based on grant date fair value of equity instruments
- Cash-settled payments initially measured at incurred liability's fair value
- Remeasured each reporting date until settlement
- Fair value changes recognized in profit or loss
- Non-market vesting conditions adjusted through expected vesting equity instruments
- Examples include service period requirements or performance targets
- Market conditions incorporated into grant-date fair value measurement
- Examples include achieving specific share price or total shareholder return
- Modifications may require additional expense recognition
- Occurs if modification increases total arrangement fair value
- Cancellations or settlements of equity-settled payments treated as vesting acceleration
- Immediate recognition of remaining vesting period expense
Valuation and Fair Value Considerations
- Option pricing models (Black-Scholes, binomial) typically used for fair value measurement
- Key factors in valuation models include:
- Current stock price
- Exercise price
- Expected volatility
- Expected dividends
- Risk-free interest rate
- Fair value measurement significantly impacts financial statements
- Requires sensitivity analysis disclosures
- Valuation assumptions can have material effects on reported expenses
- Changes in assumptions may lead to volatility in reported results
Impact of Share-Based Payments on Financials
Financial Statement Effects
- Share-based payments impact multiple financial statement components:
- Income statement (expense recognition)
- Balance sheet (equity or liability increase)
- Cash flow statement (for cash-settled arrangements)
- Dilutive effect on earnings per share (EPS) must be considered and disclosed
- Follows IAS 33 or ASC 260 requirements
- Extensive disclosures required for share-based payment arrangements
- Nature and extent of arrangements
- Fair value measurement methods
- Effect on profit or loss and financial position
- Timing differences between accounting and tax treatments create deferred tax implications
- Share-based payment expenses typically classified as non-cash items
- May be adjusted in non-GAAP measures (adjusted EBITDA)
Performance Metrics and Analysis
- Share-based payment expenses impact profitability ratios
- Examples include return on equity (ROE) and return on assets (ROA)
- Dilutive effect influences per-share metrics
- Earnings per share (EPS)
- Book value per share
- Cash flow implications differ between equity-settled and cash-settled arrangements
- Equity-settled payments generally do not affect operating cash flow
- Cash-settled payments impact operating cash outflows upon settlement
- Analysts often consider share-based payment expenses in company valuations
- May adjust earnings or cash flows to reflect economic reality of compensation
Equity vs Cash-Settled Share-Based Payments
Characteristics and Accounting Differences
- Equity-settled payments result in equity instrument issuance (shares, )
- Measured at grant date fair value of equity instruments
- Cash-settled payments lead to cash payment based on entity's share value
- Remeasured to fair value at each reporting date until settlement
- Accounting treatment differs significantly between types:
- Equity-settled: No remeasurement after initial recognition
- Cash-settled: Continuous fair value remeasurement
- Balance sheet impact varies:
- Equity-settled: Increase in shareholders' equity
- Cash-settled: Creation of liability
Financial and Strategic Implications
- Choice between equity-settled and cash-settled arrangements affects:
- Entity's cash flow
- of existing shareholders
- Overall capital structure
- Equity-settled payments may be preferred for conserving cash
- Potentially dilutive to existing shareholders
- Cash-settled payments provide recipients with more liquidity
- Create future cash outflow obligations for the entity
- Some arrangements offer settlement alternatives (cash or equity)
- Require analysis to determine appropriate classification and accounting
- Strategic considerations in choosing arrangement type:
- Alignment of employee and shareholder interests
- Retention of key employees
- Impact on financial ratios and performance metrics
Key Terms to Review (16)
Asc 718: ASC 718 refers to the Accounting Standards Codification Topic 718, which governs the accounting for share-based payments. This standard outlines how entities should recognize, measure, and disclose share-based payment transactions, including both equity-settled and cash-settled arrangements, ensuring transparency in financial reporting related to employee compensation.
Binomial model: The binomial model is a mathematical method used to calculate the theoretical value of options and other financial derivatives, incorporating the potential future movement of an asset's price over time. It is particularly useful in valuing share-based payments, allowing for different possible outcomes in the value of equity instruments based on fluctuating market conditions. This model supports the accounting for both equity-settled and cash-settled share-based transactions by providing a structured way to estimate fair value and recognize expenses accordingly.
Black-Scholes Model: The Black-Scholes Model is a mathematical model used to determine the theoretical price of European-style options. It helps in valuing share-based payments by estimating the fair value of options granted to employees, which is crucial for accurate financial reporting and understanding the impact on equity and cash flows.
Dilution: Dilution refers to the reduction in the ownership percentage of existing shareholders due to the issuance of additional shares. This often occurs in the context of share-based payments or when a company issues new shares to raise capital. Dilution impacts earnings per share calculations, as it increases the total number of shares outstanding, thus affecting the per-share metrics that investors use to evaluate a company's profitability.
Earnings per share effect: The earnings per share (EPS) effect refers to the impact that various financial activities, such as share-based payments, have on a company's reported earnings per share. This metric is crucial as it provides investors with insight into a company's profitability on a per-share basis, affecting both perceived value and market behavior. Understanding the EPS effect is vital in evaluating how share-based payments can dilute earnings and influence stock prices over time.
Equity-settled transactions: Equity-settled transactions refer to agreements where a company compensates its employees or other parties by granting shares or share options, rather than paying cash. This type of compensation affects the company’s equity since it results in the issuance of new shares or the transfer of existing ones, reflecting the costs associated with share-based payments. Recognizing these transactions in financial statements is crucial for understanding how they impact a company’s performance, shareholder equity, and overall financial position.
Exercise date: The exercise date is the specific day when the holder of a stock option or similar share-based payment can execute their right to purchase the underlying shares at a predetermined price. This date is crucial because it marks the moment when the option becomes actionable, allowing the employee or option holder to benefit from their share-based compensation. Understanding the exercise date is essential for both accounting purposes and for the recipients who plan their financial strategies around it.
Expense recognition: Expense recognition is the accounting principle that determines when an expense should be recorded in the financial statements. This principle ensures that expenses are matched with the revenues they help to generate, aligning with the matching concept in accounting. By recognizing expenses at the right time, it provides a clearer picture of a company's financial performance and helps stakeholders make informed decisions.
Fair value: Fair value is the estimated price at which an asset or liability could be exchanged between knowledgeable, willing parties in an arm's length transaction. This concept is crucial for accurately reflecting the true value of financial instruments, assets, and liabilities in financial statements, impacting recognition, measurement, and disclosures across various scenarios.
Footnote Disclosure: Footnote disclosure refers to the additional information provided in the notes to financial statements that enhance understanding and transparency regarding a company's financial position and performance. These notes can clarify accounting policies, provide details about specific transactions, and highlight risks or contingencies that are not fully evident in the primary financial statements.
Grant date: The grant date is the specific date on which an entity's board of directors or an authorized committee formally approves a share-based payment award to an employee or other service provider. This date is significant because it marks the point when the recipient becomes entitled to the benefits of the award, and it is crucial for determining the measurement of the fair value of the equity instruments granted, which has implications for accounting, tax purposes, and disclosure.
IFRS 2: IFRS 2 is the International Financial Reporting Standard that governs the accounting for share-based payments, primarily focusing on how to recognize, measure, and disclose share-based transactions. This standard ensures that companies account for employee benefits in a way that reflects their economic reality, helping to provide more accurate financial statements. It applies to both equity-settled and cash-settled transactions, emphasizing the need for transparency in disclosure and proper accounting for compensation related to key management personnel.
Restricted stock units: Restricted stock units (RSUs) are a form of equity compensation offered by employers to employees, where the company promises to grant shares of stock at a future date, contingent upon certain conditions such as continued employment or performance goals. RSUs are an important tool for aligning employee interests with those of shareholders and are often used as incentives to attract and retain talent.
Stock options: Stock options are financial derivatives that give employees the right, but not the obligation, to buy a company's stock at a predetermined price within a specific timeframe. This compensation mechanism aligns the interests of employees with shareholders, encouraging them to work toward increasing the company's value, which relates to various accounting practices and disclosure requirements.
Summary of options outstanding: The summary of options outstanding refers to a detailed listing of all employee stock options that a company has granted but not yet exercised. This summary typically includes information such as the number of options granted, the exercise price, the expiration date, and the vesting schedule. Understanding this summary is crucial for assessing a company's share-based payment obligations and potential dilution of equity.
Vesting date: The vesting date is the specific date on which an employee earns the right to exercise their stock options or receive shares from a share-based payment plan. This date is crucial because it marks the transition from a contingent claim to an actual ownership interest, making it a key milestone in share-based payment arrangements. Understanding the vesting date helps in recognizing the timing of expense recognition and its impact on financial statements.