5.1 Revenue recognition principles and standards
4 min read•august 16, 2024
Revenue recognition is a critical accounting concept that determines when and how companies record income from sales. provides a comprehensive framework for recognizing revenue, emphasizing the transfer of control to customers and the identification of performance obligations.
The five-step model for revenue recognition guides companies through contract identification, determination, allocation, and revenue recognition timing. This standardized approach aims to improve consistency and comparability across industries, while addressing complex scenarios like variable consideration and long-term contracts.
Revenue Recognition Principles
ASC 606 Framework and Core Principle
Top images from around the web for ASC 606 Framework and Core Principle
Sample competency framework structures – eCampusOntario Open Competency Toolkit View original
Is this image relevant?
Revenue Recognition | Boundless Accounting View original
Is this image relevant?
Sample competencies – eCampusOntario Open Competency Toolkit View original
Is this image relevant?
Sample competency framework structures – eCampusOntario Open Competency Toolkit View original
Is this image relevant?
Revenue Recognition | Boundless Accounting View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for ASC 606 Framework and Core Principle
Sample competency framework structures – eCampusOntario Open Competency Toolkit View original
Is this image relevant?
Revenue Recognition | Boundless Accounting View original
Is this image relevant?
Sample competencies – eCampusOntario Open Competency Toolkit View original
Is this image relevant?
Sample competency framework structures – eCampusOntario Open Competency Toolkit View original
Is this image relevant?
Revenue Recognition | Boundless Accounting View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- ASC 606 (Revenue from Contracts with Customers) governs revenue recognition providing a comprehensive framework
- Core principle depicts transfer of promised goods or services to customers in an amount reflecting expected consideration
- Requires identification of performance obligations within contracts and allocation of transaction price
- Timing based on transfer of control to customer rather than transfer of risks and rewards
- Aims to improve comparability across industries and capital markets with single, principles-based model
- Extensive disclosure requirements include qualitative and quantitative information about contracts, judgments, and changes
Performance Obligations and Disclosure Requirements
- Performance obligations represent distinct goods or services promised to customers
- Transaction price allocated to performance obligations based on relative standalone selling prices
- Control transfer determines revenue recognition timing ( or )
- Disclosure requirements cover contracts with customers, significant judgments, and judgment changes
- Qualitative disclosures explain nature, amount, timing, and uncertainty of revenue and cash flows
- Quantitative disclosures include disaggregation of revenue, contract balances, and performance obligations
Revenue Recognition Model Application
Five-Step Revenue Recognition Model
- Step 1: Identify contract(s) with customer meeting ASC 606 criteria (legally enforceable agreement, commercial substance)
- Step 2: Identify performance obligations (distinct goods or services)
- Step 3: Determine transaction price considering fixed amounts, variable consideration, time value of money
- Step 4: Allocate transaction price to performance obligations (relative standalone selling prices)
- Step 5: Recognize revenue when performance obligation satisfied (point-in-time or over-time)
- Apply model to various transaction types (single and multiple element arrangements, long-term contracts)
- Consider industry-specific nuances (software, construction, telecommunications)
Model Application Examples
- Single element arrangement: Sale of a product (recognize revenue upon delivery)
- Multiple element arrangement: Smartphone with service plan (allocate price between hardware and service)
- Long-term contract: Construction project (recognize revenue over time as project progresses)
- Contract with financing component: Interest-free payment plan (adjust for time value of money)
- Software industry: License with post-contract support (separate performance obligations)
- Telecommunications: Bundled phone and service plan (allocate based on standalone selling prices)
Variable Consideration in Revenue Contracts
Types and Estimation of Variable Consideration
- Variable consideration includes discounts, rebates, refunds, credits, price concessions, incentives, bonuses, penalties
- Constraint requires inclusion only when probable significant reversal will not occur
- Estimate using expected value method (probability-weighted sum) or most likely amount method
- Expected value method example: 40% chance of 0 bonus = $40 expected value
- Most likely amount method example: Either 100,000 performance bonus, $100,000 more likely
- Reassess estimates at each reporting date reflecting changed circumstances or new information
Accounting for Variable Consideration
- Include variable consideration in transaction price subject to constraint
- Recognize refund liability for expected refunds to customers
- Record asset for right to recover products from customers on expected returns
- Example: Sell 100 products at $10 each, expect 5% returns
- Revenue: 10)
- Refund Liability: 10)
- Asset for right to recover: 5 cost)
- Disclose methods, inputs, and assumptions used in determining variable consideration
- Provide qualitative and quantitative information about constraint application
Point-in-Time vs Over-Time Revenue Recognition
Point-in-Time Revenue Recognition
- Occurs when control transfers at specific moment (typically upon delivery or acceptance)
- Examples: Retail sales, delivery of manufactured goods, software license transfer
- Recognition criteria: Customer has legal title, physical possession, significant risks and rewards of ownership
- Accounting entry: Debit Accounts Receivable, Credit Revenue
- Disclosure focuses on timing of transfer of control and significant payment terms
Over-Time Revenue Recognition
- Occurs when customer receives and consumes benefits as entity performs
- Criteria: (1) simultaneous receipt and consumption, (2) creation/enhancement of customer-controlled asset, (3) no alternative use asset with right to payment
- Methods for measuring progress: Output methods (units produced) or input methods (costs incurred, labor hours)
- Example: Construction contract - recognize revenue based on percentage of completion
- Accounting entries: Debit Contract Asset or Accounts Receivable, Credit Revenue (as work progresses)
- Disclosures include methods used to recognize revenue and measure progress, significant judgments
Key Terms to Review (18)
Accrual Accounting: Accrual accounting is an accounting method that recognizes revenue and expenses when they are incurred, regardless of when cash transactions occur. This approach allows for a more accurate representation of a company's financial performance, aligning income and expenses with the time period they relate to, rather than when cash is exchanged. It plays a crucial role in the preparation of financial statements, guides revenue recognition principles, and influences the understanding of tax bases and temporary differences.
ASC 606: ASC 606 is the Accounting Standards Codification topic that provides a comprehensive framework for revenue recognition, outlining how and when to recognize revenue from contracts with customers. This standard aims to improve the consistency and comparability of financial reporting across different industries by establishing a single model for revenue recognition, regardless of the transaction type or industry. ASC 606 significantly impacts how companies account for multiple-element arrangements and long-term contracts, particularly in construction accounting.
Completed contract method: The completed contract method is an accounting approach where revenue and expenses for a project are recognized only when the contract is fully completed. This method is particularly relevant for long-term contracts and allows businesses to defer revenue recognition until the entire project is finished, aligning income with the actual delivery of goods or services.
Contract with Customers: A contract with customers is an agreement between a business and its customer that outlines the terms of the sale of goods or services. This agreement establishes the rights and obligations of both parties, including pricing, delivery, and performance requirements. Understanding these contracts is crucial as they form the basis for revenue recognition principles, ensuring that businesses recognize revenue in a manner that reflects the transfer of control of goods or services to customers.
Cumulative Catch-Up Adjustment: A cumulative catch-up adjustment is an accounting entry that adjusts the recognized revenue or expenses to reflect the correct amount when there are changes in estimates or methods in recognizing revenue. This adjustment ensures that the cumulative effect of these changes is accounted for in the financial statements in a manner that maintains consistency and accuracy over time. It often arises in the context of long-term contracts where estimates of revenue, costs, or progress toward completion may vary significantly from initial projections.
Deferred revenue: Deferred revenue is a liability on the balance sheet that represents money received by a company for services or goods yet to be delivered. This concept is essential in ensuring that revenue recognition aligns with the actual delivery of products or services, following the principles of accrual accounting. By categorizing payments in this way, businesses can accurately reflect their financial position and performance over time.
Disaggregated revenue: Disaggregated revenue refers to the practice of breaking down total revenue into distinct components to provide a clearer understanding of different sources of income. This approach helps organizations identify trends, assess performance across various segments, and enhance transparency in financial reporting, particularly when dealing with complex contracts or multiple-element arrangements.
FASB: The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) is an independent organization responsible for establishing financial accounting and reporting standards in the United States. It plays a crucial role in improving the clarity, consistency, and comparability of financial statements, which are essential for investors and stakeholders to make informed decisions. FASB standards are foundational for the preparation and presentation of financial statements, help shape the financial reporting landscape alongside international standards, and guide revenue recognition and disclosure requirements.
IASB: The International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) is an independent body that develops and approves International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) for use globally. The IASB aims to create a common accounting language that enhances transparency and comparability in financial reporting, impacting how companies recognize revenue and disclose information.
Over-time: Over-time refers to the method of recognizing revenue progressively as a project or service is completed, rather than waiting until the entire project is finished. This approach allows for a more accurate reflection of revenue in financial statements, especially in long-term contracts or projects where work is performed over an extended period.
Percentage of completion method: The percentage of completion method is an accounting approach used to recognize revenue and expenses based on the progress of a project over time, rather than waiting for its completion. This method allows businesses to report revenues and profits in alignment with the actual work completed, making it especially relevant for long-term contracts in construction and similar industries. It emphasizes matching revenues with the costs incurred during a project's lifecycle, which reflects a more accurate financial position of the entity involved.
Performance obligation: A performance obligation is a promise in a contract to transfer a distinct good or service to a customer. It serves as the basis for recognizing revenue when the promised good or service is delivered, ensuring that companies report earnings in a way that accurately reflects their economic activities.
Point-in-time: Point-in-time refers to a specific moment at which certain financial events or conditions are recognized or assessed. This concept is crucial for determining when revenue is recognized under various accounting standards, ensuring that financial statements reflect accurate information as of a specific date.
Product revenue: Product revenue refers to the income earned by a company through the sale of goods or services. This concept is integral to understanding how businesses recognize and report their financial performance, as it directly impacts both the income statement and the evaluation of profitability.
Retroactive Adjustment: A retroactive adjustment is an accounting change made to previously reported financial statements, reflecting a new accounting principle or correcting errors. This type of adjustment ensures that financial statements present an accurate depiction of a company’s financial position and performance over time, aligning with the revenue recognition principles and standards that emphasize the importance of accurate reporting in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).
Segment Reporting: Segment reporting is the practice of disclosing financial information about a company's different business units or geographic areas, allowing stakeholders to evaluate the performance of those segments. This approach provides clarity on how different parts of a business contribute to overall profitability and helps in making informed decisions regarding resource allocation and investment. It ensures that financial statements reflect the diverse operations of a company, enhancing transparency and comparability.
Service Revenue: Service revenue refers to the income generated from providing services to customers, as opposed to selling physical goods. It reflects the earnings recognized when a company fulfills its contractual obligations to deliver a service, playing a critical role in determining a business's financial performance and cash flow. This revenue must be recorded in accordance with established recognition principles and standards to ensure accurate reporting and compliance.
Transaction price: Transaction price is the amount of consideration that an entity expects to receive in exchange for transferring goods or services to a customer. This price can include various components such as discounts, rebates, and other incentives that might affect the final amount recognized as revenue. Understanding transaction price is essential for accurately recognizing revenue, especially in arrangements involving multiple performance obligations.